Global, Global Geopolitics, Headlines, Human Rights

UNITED STATES-INDONESIA: Jet Fighters Do Not Violate Rights

Thalif Deen

UNITED NATIONS, Oct 8 1995 (IPS) - The United States may find less resistance to selling Indonesia state-of-the-art jet fighters than to peddle assault rifles, tear gas and handcuffs to the Asian nation, according to human rights groups.

The New York-based Amnesty International USA (AIUSA) says it has no plans to fight the proposed sale of F-16 jet fighters even though it has traditionally opposed arms sales to Indonesia.

“It is very difficult to link F-16 fighter planes to human rights abuses,” T. Kumar of AIUSA told IPS.

Even though AIUSA is not opposing the sale, he said, the human rights organisation “will still closely monitor” the deployment of the sophisticated fighter planes.

“We are not going to keep our eyes closed on this. If even a single F-16 is linked to human rights abuses, we will be pushing hard in Capitol Hill” against any such future sales, he added.

Washington is expected to formally offer about 12 to 17 F-16s to Indonesia before the end of the year.

The F-16s originally belonged to Pakistan which had paid for the aircraft in advance of delivery.

But deliveries of the aircraft were held up under a U.S. law that barred weapons sales to countries suspected of developing nuclear weapons.

Pakistan paid about 658 millions dollars for 17 F-16s, all of which have been warehoused in Arizona.

If Washington succeeds in selling them to Indonesia, proceeds from the sale will help reimburse the Pakistanis who have been demanding either their aircraft or their money back.

Addressing the Senate Foreign Relations Committee in July, Stapleton Roy, U.S. Ambassador-designate to Jakarta, said the proposed deal “makes sense in terms of our broad relations with Indonesia.”

Roy also said that Indonesia has legitimate security concerns because of conflicting territorial claims in the South China Sea.

Joel Johnson of the Washington-based Aerospace Industries Association told IPS the Bill Clinton Administration should have no problem selling the jet fighters to Indonesia because “F-16s are not used for crowd control.”

Johnson said that traditionally there has been opposition to the sale of items such as M-16 assault rifles and riot control gear because they could be related to domestic violence. “The sale of F-16s is no danger to human rights violations,” he said.

Johnson also said the Indonesian air force already possesses F- 16 fighters provided by the U.S. back in 1989.

“The Indonesians have not used any of these F-16s against their own people,” he added.

Since the Indonesians already own F-16s, they are qualified to acquire additional planes, along with the aircraft’s military technology provided only to close U.S. allies such as Israel and Egypt.

The proposed sale, however, can still run into trouble on Capitol Hill. Senator Russell Feingold, a Democrat from the state of Wisconsin, has expressed reservations over the proposed sale.

“If we are going to sell these planes to Indonesia, I hope we are getting something in return– a better human rights record or a timetable for the resolution of the East Timor situation,” he said.

Feingold was particularly critical of Indonesia for its alleged human rights abuses in the former Portuguese colony of East Timor, annexed by Jakarta in 1976.

In June, AIUSA criticised Washington for resuming military assistance to Indonesia and increasing sixfold U.S. arms sales to that country.

According to figures released by the Pentagon, Washington plans to sell about 26 million dollars worth of arms to Indonesia in fiscal year 1996: up from 4.6 million dollars the previous year.

In a report released early this year, AIUSA criticised the Clinton Administration for providing military grants to some of the world’s worst violators of human rights.

The United Kingdom too has been thwarted in its attempt to sell weapons to Indonesia because of heavy lobbying against such sales by human rights groups.

In March, Michael Heseltine, president of the Board of Trade, revealed that the British government had approved the sale of some 50 to 90 light tanks and armoured personnel carriers only after a “thorough assessment” that these vehicles would not be used for “internal repression.”

Meanwhile the U.S.-Indonesian bilateral relations have been strengthened with the announcement last year of a hefty 40-billion- dollar package of joint economic and trade projects over the next decade.

The largest of the agreements involves U.S.-based Exxon and Pertamina, Indonesia’s state-run oil company, which will jointly develop a huge 35- billion-dollar offshore natural gas field.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags