Tuesday, November 17, 2026
Analysis - John Roberts
- OPEC has rarely appeared so weak. Its ministers, gathered in Vienna Tuesday for a meeting expected to do little more than maintain an uneasy status quo, face mounting problems, from external competition and internal divisions.
The external competition facing the Organisation of Petroleum Exporting Countries membership is their most pressing problem. Non- OPEC production continues to grow steadily, absorbing most of the increase in global consumption. Countries like Britain and Norway, able either to pare costs or to risk substantial state investments, have managed to increase production, despite relatively low prices.
This year, North Sea oil output is up by 300,000 barrels on last year, and there is still room for further growth. Ed Stanton, an economist with Edinburgh-based oil analysts Woodmac, told IPS: “At the beginning of the year, we forecast a significant rise in Norwegian output in the final quarter of 1995, up from 2.8 million b/d (barrels a day) to 3.3 million b/d.
“It’s actually been slightly lower. There have been major problems with one field, but we’re now looking at production going past 3.2 million b/d in December, and going beyond that in the first quarter of 1996.”
In the North Sea, output is also rising and will continue to climb in 1996. But this is not due, so much, to major new fields, as to bringing on line reserves that has been known about for many years, but which were previously considered too expensive to exploit.
This has been achieved by reducing costs considerably, so that the North Sea Andrew field, for example, which will start production in the next few months, has cost less than 300 million dollars to develop, whereas its principal operator, British Petroleum (BP), originally estimated it would cost at least 450 million dollars to bring on line.
In order to meet these challenges, some OPEC countries are borrowing non-OPEC techniques to cut costs. Venezuela has brought in private Western companies to develop marginal fields. Qatar is setting up a cooperative venture, modelled on BP’s “alliance” structure at Andrew, whereby several companies agree to share both the risks and rewards of developing otherwise marginal resources and by working as a team, rather than in a buyer-seller relationship, they are able to reduce costs considerably.
But bringing the private sector into OPEC threatens the organisation’s ability to fix quotas. Private sector participants working in marginal fields have to squeeze every last commercial drop of crude they can out of their reservoirs to secure their profits.
Yet this may well be at the expense of earnings from more established fields controlled mainly or entirely by state oil companies.
In other words, so long as quotas are observed, income developed by private sector companies can damage public sector earnings. Saudi Arabia, under its new oil minister, Ali Naimi, is particularly concerned at this turn of events, energy sources say.
They note Saudi concerns that the oil policies of two major OPEC members, Nigeria and Venezuela, are driven more by finance ministry requirements for earnings than by oil ministers’ assessments of optimum production levels or development prospects.
Respect for OPEC quotas is subordinated to the immediate need to raise extra cash through extra production above their assigned quotas.
Quota busting is not new. But it is now hindering OPEC ministers from taking effective steps to tackle the challenge from non-OPEC production. Saudi Arabia and Kuwait are both investing heavily in increasing their production capacity.
Saudi Arabia could probably produce an extra 2.5 million b/d on a sustained basis at very short notice, while Kuwait is likewise increasing its capacity from around 2.5 million b/d to three million b/d, while at present its actual output is only 2.0 million b/d.
Kuwaiti oil sources have told IPS they are also looking at the way in which Western companies have managed to cut costs in order to make a profit from hitherto marginal fields.
In effect, Saudi Arabia and Kuwait are warning their colleagues in OPEC that if cheating continues then it makes excellent sense for the two Gulf producers, and possibly for the UAE as well, to increase their own output since they already possess considerable extra capacity for production, whereas most other OPEC producers are already producing at or near to capacity.
OPEC’s weakness is also demonstrated by the problem of Iraq. Although the current furore over Iraq’s slowness in disclosing information concerning its weapons of mass destruction is now beginning to abate, no-one expects an early lifting of sanctions.
But Iraq could produce at least 2.0 million b/d in oil exports as soon as sanctions are lifted. OPEC has no mechanism in place to handle such a vast flood of crude, which would entail cuts of around 10 percent in output amongst the group’s other eleven effective members.
Gulf diplomats have even suggested privately that any U.N. resolution lifting sanctions should lay down strict limits on the volume of Iraqi oil sales: in other words, that the U.N. Security Council should take action because OPEC cannot. Things have rarely looked so bleak for the Organisation.
But perhaps the words of one of the most distinguished oil analysts and OPEC watchers, Dr Robert Mabro of the Oxford Centre for Energy Studies, should be borne in mind: “OPEC is never weaker than when it appears strong, and it is never stronger than when it appears weak.”
Analysis - John Roberts
- OPEC has rarely appeared so weak. Its ministers, gathered in Vienna Tuesday for a meeting expected to do little more than maintain an uneasy status quo, face mounting problems, from external competition and internal divisions.
(more…)