Headlines, Human Rights, Middle East & North Africa

HUMAN RIGHTS/SAUDI ARABIA: Anger As Britain Exiles Saudi Dissident

Darius Bazargan

LONDON, Jan 5 1996 (IPS) - British parliamentarians and human rights activists reacted angrily to Thursday’s government announcement that it will reject appeals for political asylum lodged by one of the most prominent political opponents of the monarchy in Riyadh.

Dr Mohammad al-Masaari, leader of the influential London-based Saudi Islamist group the Committee for the Defence of Legitimate Rights (CDLR) who applied for political asylum here last year, has been given ten days to appeal against his removal to the tiny Caribbean island of Dominica, or to report to London’s Gatwick Airport for deportation on Jan. 19.

Dr Charles Tripp, a specialist on the Middle East from London University’s School of Oriental and African Studies, said the CDLR is viewed in Riyadh as the preeminent threat to stability despite its large security apparatus and powerful allies in the U.S. — and the non-violent tactics employed by the CDLR.

“The CDLR’s method has been to use faxes, cassette tapes and other electronic media to spread their Islamist message inside Saudi Arabia,” said Tripp. “They try to highlight the corruption and double standards of the royal family.”

“The problem with regimes like the Saudis is that they run a very closed political system, so they get ultra-sensitive about any form of political criticism.

When that criticism comes in ways they can’t control they become very anxious about the effects it is having.” But Tripp argued that the importance and influence of the CDLR had probably been exaggerated by both its supporters and detractors alike.

Nevertheless, the expulsion has outraged human rights activists, who say the government decision has set a dangerous precedent.

“This is a tragic blunder both in democratic and economic terms for this country,” said George Galloway, a Scottish Labour MP who has championed the cause of the Saudi opposition. “We have bowed our knee to the tyranny in Riyadh, which as any observer will tell you has never looked less secure.”

Galloway referred to the recent change in leadership in Saudi Arabia in which the ailing ruler King Fahd has handed over the reins of power to his half-brother Abdullah, the bomb attack on U.S. military in Riyadh in November, internal power struggles within the regime as evidence of the short-sightedness of British policy which had chosen to expel Masaari at this time.

“This man, or someone like him may one day be the leader of a democratic Arabia and where will Britain’s interests stand then?” Galloway said.

“We intend to fight this decision to the very end. Right up to the High Court and judicial review if necessary. We believe there are major flaws in the government’s legal reasoning behind this decision.”

Galloway added that he believed the government decision was taken for commercial reasons. Saudi Arabia bought 1.5 billion pounds (2.26 billion dollars) of British goods last year and Britain’s 18th largest export market.

Perhaps more important is the 20 billion pound (30.2 billion) ‘al- Yamamah’ arms-for-oil deal signed by Margaret Thatcher in 1985 which involves the supply of defence equipment including British Aerospace’s Tornado aircraft over the next 20 years.

This view was echoed by Tripp. “Britain’s relations with Saudi Arabia are largely commercial and the British government becomes very embarrassed that Saudi exiles are finding refuge in this country to carry out their activities,” he said.

“The regime in Riyadh then demands that the British take action, like arresting these dissidents or cutting off their faxes, but these are things that supposedly democratic governments simply cannot do.”

“British interests as a whole do require his removal,” said Home Office minister Ann Widdecombe, whose agency is responsible for asylum cases. “We have got enormous export considerations.”

“If people come here and use our hospitality in order to attack extremely friendly countries with whom we have good diplomatic and trade relations, we have a very difficult balance to strike,” she told reporters here.

Human rights activists also condemned the British move as unlawful. “Article 32 in the U.N. Convention Relating to the Status of Refugees says plainly that contracting states shall not expel refugees lawfully in their territory save on grounds of national security or public order,” said Lord Avebury, a Liberal Democrat peer and chairman of the Parliamentary Human Rights Group.

Avebury added that he feared the decision set a dangerous precedent for other regimes whose opponents have sought shelter in Britain. Among the many exile organisations that operate from London are the Bahrain Freedom Movement and the Pakistani Mohajir Quami Movement as well as various Tunisian and Algerian organisations.

For its part the CDLR issued a statement condemning the government’s decision. “It has always been ours and others’ belief that Britain was one of the most secure shelters for those seeking human rights and that it would never compromise her principles,” the statement said. “This move, however, has proved that the contrary is true.”

Masaari himself argued that the move was not simply an attempt to gag him as an individual, but that it had a wider significance. “This is obviously an attempt to silence the whole CDLR, possibly to divide us and destroy the movement,” he said.

“But we intend to stay here as long as we can and to fight this decision in a dignified way.” He noted that when he lived in Saudi Arabia he had enjoyed a comfortable lifestyle but had still decided to oppose the Saudi monarchy.

“We said that we have a duty towards all the people in the country,” he told IPS, “to take the country out of the dark ages and its medieval government system and into a reasonable system which fits into our time — the latter part of the 20th century — to give the people what they deserve; participation in public affairs and control over their own lives.”

He argued that the Saudi government would be disappointed in its belief that the expulsion would put an end to the CDLR’s activities.

“There is a struggle going on in Saudi Arabia, and that struggle needs an mouthpiece, which is what we are”, he said. “We will continue from here, God forbid from Dominica or from elsewhere. We will continue if it means exile. We will continue if it means death.”

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags

Headlines, Human Rights, Middle East & North Africa

HUMAN RIGHTS/SAUDI ARABIA: Anger As Britain Exiles Saudi Dissident

Darius Bazargan

LONDON, Jan 5 1996 (IPS) - British parliamentarians and human rights activists reacted angrily to Thursday’s government announcement that it will reject appeals for political asylum lodged by one of the most prominent political opponents of the monarchy in Riyadh.
(more…)

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags