Saturday, November 21, 2026
Mukul Sharma
- Mine disasters in the vast coalfields of eastern India have claimed more lives than have car crashes in Japan.
At least 74 miners drowned last September in the Gaslitand mine in Bihar state’s Dhanbad-Jharia coal belt. The bodies of the miners are still buried under thousands of gallons of water that rushed into the mine when the Katri River in Dhanbad burst its high embankment following unusually heavy monsoon rain.
The Dhanbad-Jharia coal belt has the country’s richest coal reserves. But for the miners the collieries are death traps. Professor R.K. Kejariwal of the Indian School of Mines has documented at least two dozen accidents since the 1960’s — there are countless minor mishaps.
Yet, as the horrific accident in the Gaslitand mine revealed few lessons have been learnt. Mine authorities are not serious about safety regulations and neglect to implement even the most basic of precautionary measures.
The Gaslitand mine disaster was man-made, preliminary investigations revealed. The river embankment was weak — coal had been extracted from barriers closeby; and the mine management had discontinued the practice of deploying guards to keep an eye on the river. When the flooded Katri river breached the embankment, there was no one to raise an alarm.
Also in violation of safety norms an abandoned mine near the Gaslitand colliery had not been sealed — the collapsed mine provided an easy passage for water to rush into the nearly century-old Gaslitand mine.
Inundation has been the cause of five major mine disasters in the Bihar coal belt in the past decade. The most tragic was the accident in the Chasnala colliery — 375 miners perished.
Every mine disaster is followed by a commission of inquiry. But as the history of mining in the Dhanbad-Jharia reveals, each has been an exercise in futility. Mine safety recommendations remain mainly on paper.
Vinay Mahajan, director-general of Mines Safety, claims he is helpless. “Even when we suggest safety measures they are never properly implemented by the coal management,” he declares.
India’s collieries are state-owned and run either by the Bharat Coking Coal Limited (BCCL) or Coal India Limited (CIL). Gaslitand belongs to BCCL.
A.K. Gulati, chairman-cum-managing director of BCCL, insists the charges of negligence are unfounded. “There is no lapse on our part. The Gaslitand tragedy was a natural calamity, the result of unpredictable, heavy downpour.”
But experts cite several serious lacunae in the running of the collieries.
Mine managements are only concerned with production and profits, declares mining engineer A.N. Singh. According to him, BCCL’s advisory committee had twice recommended the closing of Gaslitand. But the management continued to extract the quality coal discovered at a depth of 180 metres. Singh says 76 of BCCL’s 92 mines have been declared unsafe, but work has never stopped.
India has 22 important coalfields, and together they provide employment to more than a million people. Miners, particularly in the very old mines, work under very primitive conditions even though they are represented by trade unions. The workers and their families have learnt to live expecting the worst.
Says Budhani, a miner in the Bera colliery near Dhanbad: “When I go to work, I don’t expect to be back safely. My wife, children and old mother keep worrying about me and pray to God for my life.” According to Budhani, three workers were killed recently in his mine when a wall collapsed.
After inundation, the most common causes of mine accidents are underground fire, explosion and roof collapse. Two years ago in January, 55 miners were killed by a fire in the New Kendra colliery in the Dhanbad-Jharia coalbelt.
A recent World Bank-assisted survey by the Indian School of Mines has confirmed the opinion of independent experts that there are at least a dozen collieries in Bihar and in the adjoining West Bengal whose continued operation is dangerous to workers.
Scientists who inspected the mines were reportedly horrified by the extent of open-cast mining in the area. Roughly 60 percent of the abandoned mines dug before 1950 are under risk of subsidence and need to be constantly monitored.
Moreover, fires raging in some abandoned mines are also a threat to villages. Villagers living near the Ramnagar colliery
say there was smoke curling out of the ground on June 25 last year. And that day the water in the village pond was hot. Their repeated complaints have, however, fallen on deaf ears.
Local workers’ groups want India’s coal mines to be modernised and managements made more accountable. “There have been a string of accidents, but not a single prosecution,” says a local leader of the All India Coal Workers Federation.
According to union leaders, a Tripartite Committee on Safety in coal mines set up a few years ago has not met even once.