Development & Aid, Headlines, Population

LATIN AMERICA-POPULATION: Sorry Malthus, Not Here

Eduardo Molina y Vedia

MEXICO CITY, Jan 11 1996 (IPS) - Latin American researchers say the theory linking population growth and food output, is not fully applicable to the region.

“The fall in demographic growth has not meant improvements in the welfare of Latin America during the so-called lost decade (of the eighties),” says Raul Benitez of the Independent National University of Mexico.

Limiting population growth was a multifaceted issue which responded to regional criteria, says Benitez.

Developed by Thomas Malthus in his “Essay on the Principle of Population” (1798), the theory with his name holds that if population increased in size, outpacing food production, then only family planning could prevent widespread poverty.

“During the past decades of chronic crisis, the demographic policy of the United States and Britain have stressed economics and the Malthusan principle in the global fora,” says Luis Cieza of the Intercontinental University of Mexico.

“The population explosion led them to suggest that there was an unsurmountable limit imposed by nature, and that economic progress was only possible if accompanied by contraception,” he explains.

And Benitez says his research shows that the Latin American experience is fundamentally different to the European. The continent had high reproduction rates before the trend of early marriages and fewer births took hold in the last 20 years.

The falling birth rate was mainly due to the availability of modern contraceptives. Cultural pressures affected the birth rate as well, along with the nature of resource distribution within each country.

“While neoliberalism is accepted without criticism, the painful situation of poverty is hidden, growing and deepening, delaying its impact on the population structure and process,” says Benitez.

And Amilcar Herrera, author of “Catastrophe and new society: Latin American world model”, said the real problems facing the modern world were more political in nature than physical.

Issues which had to be tackled before birth control included poverty and backwardness. Research had shown that better educated, better off people tended to produce less children.

On that basis, Herrera concluded that “changing the living conditions of the population is the most secure and permanent way to reduce demographic growth.”

These studies were part of an ever smaller body of research, as the funding for social research was now being diverted to bio- medical investigations.

Meanwhile, social policy relies heavily on low-cost family planning programmes, and the international aid agencies are spending less on training social workers and sociologists in Latin America.

The agencies argue that Latin America has the capacity to train and replace its own personnel and academics, but this is impossible in practical terms, given the depth of the economic crisis.

Social activist, Gloria Valdes, told IPS that “the new demographic programmes are predominantly aimed at increasing productivity in the family planning industry.”

“There is a desperate need for constant debate of the research findings, in order to create a deep demographic consciousness that is not merely mathematical,” she said.

Poverty and the accompanying high birth rate are also closely related to ethnic origin on the continent. The main cultural difference between the Latin American nations is the size of their indigenous populations.

Argentina, Chile and Uruguay, who actively decimated their indigenous populations, have population profiles similar those of European nations. Bolivia, Peru, Ecuador and Mexico have greater migratory, indigenous and mestizo populations.

Brazil, Central America and the Caribbean also have large numbers of blacks, mostly descended from African slaves.

Some governments have taken up the findings. Mexico produced a new plan prioritising socioeconomic development in order to bring about demographic change.

However, development is just exactly what Mexico has most lacked since the crisis in 1994, and to all intents and purposes the theoretically “advanced” development plan has still not come out of its gift-wrap.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags