Sunday, November 22, 2026
Eduardo Molina y Vedia
- Strategy on controlling population growth in Latin America swings between those who see social and economic development as the key to success, and those who rely exclusively on family planning. In recent years public opinion, and government programs, have moved more in favour of contraception.
Latin America was the scene of an intense population debate in the 1960s after the region had posted the highest rates of demographic growth in history. The Economic Commission for Latin America (ECLA) calculated in 1961 that an annual population growth rate of three percent would require a savings rate of between six and nine percent over the same period just to maintain living standards.
This perspective drew on studies from outside the Latin American region, such as Frank Notestein’s “Population – The Long View” published in the United States in 1945, and urged rapid change to achieve a “demographic transition.”
Notestein’s approach to the study and control of population concentrated on the fundamental indices of growth (fertility and mortality) in lieu of the traditional approach that examined local population trends in the context of world population growth, including migration, and diverse social and natural indicators.
The new approach sought to achieve higher per capita income through family planning programs based on a voluntary reduction in the number of children, which was encouraged by propaganda campaigns and facilitated by modern methods of contraception.
Notestein asserted that “the nation that wants to be great and prosperous will accomplish this goal more quickly by drastically reducing its birth rate as soon as possible.”
But studies showed that even after fertility was reduced, a decline in the death rate would continue to increase the population before there would be any overall decline.
During the 1970s such Latin American experts as the Mexican Raul Benitez and the Brazilian Paul Singer shifted the focus of study to demographic analysis based on formal theory and the variable relations between population and development.
This new approach was reflected in the 1974 Bucharest Conference’s World Action Plan, which stated that “the very high rates of growth are a problem in any contemporary context.”
At the same time, the conference declared that the freedom of individuals and couples to make their own reproductive decisions was a basic human right.
The conference also concluded that historical conditions and living standards in different countries played an important role in determining the structure and dynamics of population growth.
Later studies conducted by the Latin American Social Science Council demonstrated the decisive importance of the economic structure in industrialized cities for successful family planning.
The experts showed that rapid declines in fertility were achieved without great effort in urban areas, whereas rural and semi-urban residents resisted pressure to reduce the number of children.
In Latin American countries such as Mexico that have formulated demographic plans, the idea is growing that socioeconomic development must be given priority over family planning programs if the population problems is to be successfully confronted.
ECLA studies forecast that Latin America’s 1990 population of 441 million will rise to over 523 million in the year 2000.
Mexico’s 1995-2000 demographic plan – seen as exemplary even though the country’s economic crisis has delayed its implementation – gives priority to socio-economic development.
Jose Gomez de Leon, director general of the Mexican National Council on Population, says that this programme is innovative precisely because it abandons previous plans’ near-exclusive emphasis on reproductive control.
“The highest rates of fertility are seen above all in rural areas that are either not reached or unaffected by propaganda and family planning services, and this is true not only in Mexico but throughout Latin America,” he affirmed.
“Only a harmonious and just socioeconomic development in all of society can guarantee a moderation of population growth that will make improved living standards possible and lead to cultural change,” he concluded.