Development & Aid, Headlines, North America, Population

CANADA: Minorities Lack Confidence in Justice System

TORONTO, Feb 16 1996 (IPS) - New reports on hate crimes and racism in the criminal justice system have shaken some Canadians’ belief that their society is among the most tolerant.

The Commission on Systemic Racism in the Ontario Criminal Justice System published its report last month on the harsh treatment of blacks by police, courts, and prisons.

The report released this week by the federal justice department shows that large portions of the black and Chinese communities — each nearly 10 percent of the metropolitan population — mistrust the justice system.

The report says that nearly 1,000 crimes inspired by race, ethnicity, sexual-orientation, and religion were reported in 1993- 94. But the department estimates the real figure is as high as 60,000, since most cases are not reported.

“The problem of hate crime is a truly global phenomenon, and Canada is no exception,” says the report, titled, ‘Disproportionate Harm: Hate Crime in Canada’.

Paul Grayson of York University’s Institute of Social Research recently released a more reassuring study. But his conclusions are widely criticised here.

Grayson studied racial attitudes among blacks, whites, and Chinese in the metropolitan region and concluded that most whites are not racist.

“While white Torontonians are opposed to preferential hiring based on race, they cannot be characterised as having racist views,” concludes Grayson who conducted telephone interviews with 417 blacks, 405 Chinese, and 435 whites.

He found that 50 percent of blacks, 58 percent of Chinese and 67 percent of whites surveyed believe that “visible minorities often bring discrimination upon themselves.”

A huge influx of Chinese, South Asian, Caribbean, and African immigrants in the past 20 years has radically changed Toronto’s population. By 1991, a quarter of the residents were “visible minorities”. The numbers could reach 45 percent within five years, officials here estimate.

“What other city with this racial composition has as low a level of violence?” Grayson asked during an interview. “Toronto is relatively free of the problems found elsewhere, but that does not mean we should sit on our laurels.”

His critics charge that complacency is exactly what his study encourages. David Hulchanski of the social work faculty at the University of Toronto says his own studies of housing problems among immigrants reveal clear patterns of discrimination based on skin colour and language.

Antoni Shelton, executive director of the Urban Alliance for Race Relations, said Grayson’s study does a “grave disservice.”

“We are not a society that has many of the ethnic problems of other societies, but we are not good enough,” he said. “We seek to collectively distance ourselves from responsibility for the dysfunction of the system.”

Troubled relations, especially between blacks and the police, are historical and deep-rooted, he said, adding that solutions need to be long-term and “surgical”.

The Commission on Systemic Racism in the Ontario Criminal Justice System has recommended dozens of changes in areas including training, decision making, minority hiring, legal aid, victim assistance, juries, complaint procedures, interpretation services, prison discipline, and community relations.

The report found that 58 percent of blacks, 31 percent of Chinese, and 36 percent of whites believe judges treat blacks worse than whites; smaller percentages felt Chinese were treated worse than whites.

Four in 10 defence attorneys and three in 10 provincial judges appointed since 1989 believed that minority groups are treated worse than whites, as did 13 percent of prosecutors.

The study revealed that blacks were more likely than whites to be detained after a bail hearing even though whites were more likely to have a serious criminal record. The differential treatment was greatest for drug-related charges.

Black men are admitted to prison at more than five times the rate for white men while for black women admissions were almost seven times those of white women, according to the report. Blacks and indigenous people have disproportionately high numbers in prison, while Asians and Arabs are under-represented.

Chinese Torontonians are less likely than blacks or whites to be stopped by police. But May Cheng of the Chinese Canadian National Council, Toronto chapter, cautioned against any notion that Chinese people benefit from positive stereotypes.

“The Chinese community perceives that we are also over- policed, like the black community,” she said. “There is a presumption of gang activity associated with Chinese crimes.”

New immigrants and older persons who speak little English say translators are rare, Cheng said, but most Asians are reluctant to speak out about their quarrels with the justice system.

“One thing is that the black community has is a stronger voice, louder, more cohesive than the Asian community,” she added.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags