Sunday, November 22, 2026
Yuli Ismartono
- Indonesia’s rapid industrialisation has pushed up the demand for highly-skilled workers, but the shortage of qualified Indonesians has prompted the government to accept more foreign workers to fill the gap.
Amid high unemployment, Indonesians are finding out that expatriates working in the country earned close to 200 million dollars a month in 1995.
This is in stark contrast to the income earned by one million Indonesians working in Saudi Arabia and Malaysia, who sent back 100 million dollars last year.
Labour Minister Abdul Latief also announced that the government issued work permits to 57,159 expatriates in 1995, a 38 percent increase over the previous year.
“I admit this must be surprising, but the high number of expatriates is caused by the shortage of qualified Indonesians in filling certain positions,” said Latief.
Close to 14,000 of the foreign workers hold managerial positions. Around 11,000 in various professional fields, 8,000 are supervisors and more than 23,000 are technicians.
South Koreans, who represent 20.4 per cent of expatriates working in Indonesia, are the biggest group, followed by the Japanese, the Taiwanese and Indians.
Officials said the doubling of South Korean workers was in line with the rise of their business investments in the country, particularly in the field of construction.
Similar cultural conditions have also attracted Malaysians and Filipinos, most of whom hold middle and senior level management positions, particularly in banks and private businesses.
Filipino accountants, said to be in great demand because of their U.S. system education, currently occupy key positions in the top 10 private commercial banks.
Officials estimate that there would be a need for about half a million accountants in the next five to 10 years.
The increasing number of foreign MBA degree holders followed the government’s decision to deregulate banking seven years ago, as well as the establishment of the Jakarta Stock Exchange and the subsequent mushrooming of brokerage houses.
Deregulation of the television industry, which led to the launch of five new private stations, also brought in large numbers of expatriates, providing advice on everything from programming to production and advertising.
Indonesians with the same qualifications as their foreign counterparts earn the same salaries, sometimes even more. But there are still very few Indonesians qualified for the new jobs, which explains the big gap in salaries for locals and expatriates.
“I’m upset at (the expatriates’) big salaries, but what can I do? I’m only a mechanic, without much skills. I hope the government will spend more money on better schools so we can replace those foreigners,” said Supandi, currently a vendor selling ice cream in the streets.
Analysts say the increase in foreign workers began when President Suharto eased restrictions on hiring expatriates in 1994. They say the trend is likely to continue given the flow of foreign direct investments which are bringing in new technology.
The ongoing industrialisation process requires new skills and new work methods and procedures, all of which need expatriate know- how during the initial phases, until their Indonesian counterparts can master them through training, exchange of knowledge and technology.
“But it will take time for them to become capable of fulfilling the demand for the various categories of skilled workers, both in the manufacturing and service sectors,” said an editorial in the daily ‘Jakarta Post’.
Just how long it will take Indonesians to fill the labour gap is difficult to estimate, but much will depend on the government’s commitment to improving the public education system, which seems inadequate in keeping up with the rapid economic changes.
“What really needs tackling in order to resolve this problem is the educational and training system, to ensure that more Indonesians are qualified to step into the positions currently filled by expatriates,” said the Jakarta Post.
Analysts estimate it would take another five or 10 years before Indonesians can take over those jobs.
Ironically, the rise in the number of expatriates comes at a time when unemployment is also rising. In 1995 the number of Indonesians ‘critically’ unemployed — those working less than 15 hours a week — rose to 14 million, up from 11 million in 1994.
The government is particularly alarmed at the high rate because 52.2 percent of the unemployed last year were between the ages of 15 and 25.
“These are youngsters who need encouragement to work productively,” Latief said. To help ease the problem, the government plans to help establish small and medium scale businesses to absorb some of the unemployed youths.
The government is also encouraging more Indonesians to work overseas, not just to earn an income but also to learn new skills.
“They will be a big commodity by the time the year 2000 rolls around. We are targeting at least 10 billion dollars a year,” said Latief.