Economy & Trade, Headlines, Labour, Latin America & the Caribbean

PANAMA-ECONOMY: Questions on Foreign Investment

Silvio Hernandez

PANAMA CITY, Feb 2 1996 (IPS) - Special labour laws, passed by the government of President Ernesto Perez Balladares for the benefit of Taiwanese companies, have sparked renewed debate over foreign investment in this country.

The Taiwanese assembly plants are located in the former Canal Zone, recently ceded to Panama by the United States and former Political Economy and Planning Minister Delia Cardenas led the questioning of the government initiative. He maintained the assembly-export zones should not function as ‘islands’ but as part of a general plan to develop the canal zone area.

The government plans to create an assembly-export zone in one of the former military bases that Panama received last year from the United States under the Canal treaties of 1977.

The Taiwanese investors were part of a group of 2,500 entrepreneurs who traveled throughout Panama, Costa Rica, El Salvador and Nicaragua recently looking for the best deal in setting up small and medium-sized assembly-export businesses.

The opposition of Cardenas to them receiving special status stance won the support of former Industrialists’ Union president Ruben Dario Selles, who said that foreign investors should not be given privileges over domestic industry.

Perez Balladares defended his decision to given special incentives to the Taiwanese investors on the grounds that they were necessary to attract investment that will immediately create some 20,000 jobs. Despite economic adjustment and new laws offering incentives to foreign investment over the past four years, the creation of new jobs in Panama has fallen by 50 percent since 1993.

Selles reported that 30,000 new jobs were created nationally in 1993, but this number fell to 16,000 in 1994 and 15,00 in 1995.

Economist Juan Jovane declared that Panama’s assembly-export zone scheme showed “that the government is operating according to short-term criteria, driven by political expediency, and has not developed a plan to attract appropriate investment that meets the country’s development needs.”

Jovane, director of the state University of Panama’s Economic Research Center, told IPS that there are three types of investment in the world, and that the one Taiwan is offering Panama “is based on cheap labor and backward technology.”

The expert describes the other two forms of investment as that using “innovative” technology to produce new products that do not compete with domestic industry and that using “apprenticeship” technology, or existing technology that is best suited to efficient production in a given country.

The three models “imply three different work methods, salaries, and standards of living” for workers, Jovane said. In his judgment, Panama should aspire at least to the apprenticeship model, which implies a different policy to that applied to the Taiwanese assembly plants.

“They negotiate with Taiwanese capitalists, but not with that country’s major industries but rather with the small and medium firms that are well known in Central America for their poor labor policies,” Jovane said.

The development plan should center on reacting vertical agriculture-agroindustry and construction materials-construction linkages in addition to developing the canal and canal zone potential, he said.

Jovane declared that “we shouldn’t just produce, but produce in a way that is integrated with the rest of the economy,” and added that “a Taiwanese maquiladora that comes to teach us how to sew clothes is not the same as a company that transfers technology and provides a better income for the labor force.”

The researcher said that another issue concerns how Panama integrates into the world market.

“The country needs to join the world market, but gradually and under selective conditions that allow us to manage the approach,” Jovane pointed out.

“Otherwise,” he warned, “what might happen is that a worker in local industry will lose a job paying 300 dollars a month so that his wife will work for 100 dollars in a garment assembly plant. The working people are the ones who will end up losing.”

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags