Saturday, November 21, 2026
Johanna Son
- The Philippine authorities last week arrested six Vietnamese asylum seekers who had boldly tried to melt into Filipino society, but the incident underlines a dilemma faced by Asian countries hosting tens of thousands of refugees.
Four of the Vietnamese had traveled hundreds of kilometres north from Palawan — site of the Philippines’ first-asylum camp in the south-west — to Ilocos Norte province in the north of the country. Two others settled closer by the camp in the central Bohol province.
At the time of their capture, they were busily trying to earn a living by peddling clothes, perfume and jewellery.
They are among the hundreds of Vietnamese who have escaped from the sprawling camp in recent years, preferring life as illegal aliens in the Philippines to returning to Vietnam, where economic, but not political reforms, are well under way.
As news spreads of Manila’s plan to repatriate them by June, more Vietnamese are taking this option. The foreign office says in past weeks alone, 671 Vietnamese have fled the Palawan camp.
“There are only 1,896 Vietnamese physically in the camp as of today,” Lauro Baja, an assistant secretary at the Philippine foreign office, confirmed this week.
The fate of these asylum seekers — adjudged ‘non-refugees’ and economic migrants by the United Nations — continues to pose a dilemma for the Philippines as it tries to implement a regional plan to complete the repatriation process by June 1996.
Malaysia, Thailand, Indonesia, the Philippines and Hong Kong still host 40,000 ‘non-refugees’ ineligible for resettlement to the West. The countries want the camps closed before the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR) runs out of funds to run them in a few months.
The Comprehensive Plan of Action (CPA), aimed at resolving the exodus from Vietnam that began after communists captured Saigon 21 years ago, was to have expired last year.
But it drags on due to resistance by asylum seekers and Vietnam’s tardiness in getting its people back. South-east Asian nations are also loathe to be seen as forcing Vietnamese back.
The touchy matter of repatriation is fueling a furore in the Philippines, where Church and human rights groups criticised as inhuman, the government’s sending back of 84 asylum seekers on Feb 14.
Since then, Manila moved from showing stern resolve in repatriation, buckled under pressure from the Catholic Church’s objections, and then turned around and reaffirmed its intent to carry out a “humane” repatriation process.
“The position of the Philippine government has not changed except in the manner of repatriation,” Foreign Undersecretary Rodolfo Severino said Tuesday. Stressing a policy of “orderly repatriation” with dignity, he said Church groups would now be given a greater role in the repatriation process.
Severino spoke after a dialogue with Church groups, whose representative Sr. Roseanne Mallillin said they would help “persuade the people (Vietnamese) to go home”. But though the Church is open to humane repatriation, it would look for options for those who wished to stay, she added.
The Philippines’ repatriation plans, finalised with South-east Asian countries in January, appear to be back on track for now.
But the recent controversy, stoked by photos and television footage of Vietnamese being herded onto a waiting plane, shows the process may not become any easier. Scuffles were reported at the Palawan camp that day, but officials said they did not use violence against the Vietnamese.
At a meeting two weeks ago, President Fidel Ramos and religious leaders agreed that the Church and non-government groups “accept responsibility for the administration of services” in the Palawan camp when U.N. funding expires.
Tuesday’s statement by the foreign office represents a turnaround in the Ramos government’s stance. Up until last week and under Church pressure, the government said it find ways to allow the Vietnamese to stay on in the Philippines.
“The government is finding a way to formalise the stay of those who do not wish to leave,” Foreign Secretary Domingo Siazon had said right after the February 14 repatriation. Immigration chief Leandro Verceles cited a law allowing the President to admit aliens on humanitarian grounds.
While such suggestions may be popular to some groups, some analysts ask if they are practical or fair to Filipinos.
“The Philippines has been very understanding and very supportive of the special needs of these people compared with other countries in Asia,” said Carolina Hernandez of the Manila- based Institute of Strategic and International Studies.
“But to what extent can you really legalise their stay without creating additional problems for the government?” Hernandez said in an interview.
She pointed to a likely backlash from squatters living outside the Palawan camp and whose area will be used for airport expansion. She asked if the government could keep the Vietnamese in the camp, leaving Filipino squatters to fend for themselves.
“Here is a case where you have to be humanitarian in the case of economic migrants, yet you are not responding very effectively to the needs of your own squatter population,” Hernandez said.
Legal columnist Raul Palabrica warned: “Charity begins at home. Before pouring the limited resources of the Catholic Church and NGOs on the Vietnamese, what about looking after the interests of our countrymen first?”
The authorities too has had second thoughts. “Integration is not an option for these asylum seekers,” said Severino who explained that the government would not have the 30 million pesos (1.1 million dollars) needed to run the Palawan camp annually after June, because funds are needed for needy Filipinos.
Still, a Filipino senator is drafting a bill to legalise the Vietnamese’ stay. The Church’s calls to let the Vietnamese stay may well also complicate ASEAN’s already difficult effort to hasten repatriation, not to mention raise false hopes among them.
More than 73,000 asylum seekers, given no option by the governments of the Association of South-east Asian Nations (ASEAN), have gone home in the six years since the CPA began urging ‘voluntary repatriation’ of asylum seekers to Vietnam.
“If the asylum seekers were led to believe they could stay here indefinitely, then this false was not raised by the Philippine government,” Severino stressed.
Past experience shows that voluntary repatriation slows when asylum seekers hear of proposals that could mean a reprieve, such as one made by U.S. legislators in May 1995 for new screening to see if they could settle in the United States.
But Robert Van Leeuwen, former chief of the UNHCR mission in Hong Kong, warns that the Vietnamese are the biggest losers when false hopes are raised.
For the Vietnamese, false hopes mean “yet another prolongation of their dehumanising stay in detention camps surrounded by endemic crime, the torn-up papers of vain hopes and children who have yet to see a world beyond barbed wire. That is the price they pay”, he said.