Saturday, November 21, 2026
Redempto Anda
- More than 1,000 Vietnamese refugees, some protesting violently, tried in vain to stop a plane carrying the first batch of 84 persons out of this city in the western Philippine province of Palawan on Wednesday.
Military troops used water canons to disperse the rallyists protesting the forced repatriation, but not after some soldiers were seen roughing up some of the protest leaders.
On Saturday, some 300 troops with automatic weapons swept through the refugees’ shanties, including a Buddhist temple, to round up those already scheduled to be sent back to Vietnam, and detained them inside a military barracks.
A nun working with the asylum seekers denounced the U.N. High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR) for “forcing people who don’t want to go home”.
“Please help me,” 53-year-old refugee Ngo To Nu urged as soldiers shoved him into the Vietnamese Airlines plane. “I will have no clothes or any other item… I don’t want to go back.”
A Vietnamese woman who introduced herself as Lan passed a handwritten note to a local reporter that read: “I don’t want to go back to Vietnam because I love the Philippines. I have no family there. I just got married one year ago and now I am two months pregnant.”
Doc Tanh Hoc, 25, says all his relatives are already in the United States. “How come my name was on the list? I don’t have any family in Vietnam anymore,” he said.
Some of the refugees started a hunger strike earlier this week, hoping to draw the attention of the international community to their plight and to protest an apparent government policy to use force in repatriating them.
One of the hunger strikers vowed to continue his protest even after most of the Vietnamese inside the holding area have left. “We would rather die here than be sent back to Vietnam. I have no more family there.”
The Catholic Church has offered to take over the management of the First Philippine Asylum Camp once the United Nations pulls out on Mar. 16.
“The Church is saying that forced repatriation is inhuman,” said Sr Le Pascale, head of a voluntary organisation operating inside the camp. “The Philippine government does not have to spend a single centavo.”
Indeed, what to do with Vietnamese who refuse to leave has been a nagging concern of the government. Local officials are not keen with the idea of the refugees integrating into mainstream society. “We would rather that they leave,” Governor Salvador Socrates said in an interview.
Under the Church’s plan, the refugees will be allowed to stay “on their own” for at least six months “to encourage them to volunteer for repatriation because they will realise that life here is as harsh as Vietnam”, said Pascale.
Those who refuse to leave will get Church assistance in their integration into mainstream society, she added.
The government has yet to respond to the Church’s proposal, but religious leaders here believe they scored a major victory when President Fidel Ramos agreed with the Catholic Bishops Conference of the Philippines Tuesday not to force those who are not yet willing to leave Palawan.
The first batch of 84 refugees deported Wednesday were all wearing red shirts provided by the government. The remaining 2,300 in the camp here are to be repatriated before Jun. 26, the deadline set by the UNHCR and the Philippine government.
Military officials here explained they cannot stop the scheduled repatriation because Manila has not sent any order to that effect following Ramos’ talk with church leaders.
“The issue of applying force in order to repatriate is inevitable. At the end of the day, somebody has to be forced. I hope we will not reach that point, but we just have to bite the bullet one of these days,” Western Command chief Maj Gen Carlos Tanega said before the repatriation began.
“We are not guilty. We are asking for freedom,” read the placards held by the refugees. The military, aided by water canons and fire trucks, took about 45 minutes to disperse the rallyists and clear the runway for the plane’s takeoff.
Reports reaching the military camp said the plane landed at the Ho Chi Minh airport two hours later, but its passengers were not immediately allowed to disembark because the manifest was left by the military escorts in Puerto Princesa. Tanega said the foreign affairs department had to fax the manifest to Vietnam.
The remaining refugees have been grouped together by the military and security has been tightened since talk about forced repatriation went around the camp.
Last November, nearly half the camp was burned in a fire that started inside one of the dwelling units. Arson investigators ruled it was caused by an accident.
While the refugees are free to roam around the camp, they are not allowed to go out anymore. In the past, they could go around the town to take up odd jobs as carpenters or electricians. Some were even allowed to set up noodle shops.
Life inside the camp after the repatriation is no longer as tense. Children were again playing around a makeshift basketball court while the older men bantered in small groups.