Saturday, November 21, 2026
Eduardo Molina y Vedia
- Representatives of ten regional nations agreed combatting the people traffickers and protecting the human rights of migrants were the paramount issues at the Central and North American conference on migration which ended in Puebla, Mexico Thursday.
The vice-foreign ministers and leading migration officials agreed undocumented immigrants should not be considered criminals, but people seeking better living conditions, who contribute both economically and culturally to the receptor nation.
Discussions were based on a study of the benefits and shortcomings of the phenomenon, which in this region basically means the flow of people from Central America and Mexico towards the United States and, to a lesser extent, Canada.
Arturo Valenzuela, head of the US delegation, estimated there were some four million undocumented immigrants in the United States, 60 percent of whom enter the country from Central America and Mexico along the 3,200 km frontier.
Eight of every 10 of these people are Mexican, with the remainder made up of other Central American nationalities and a smattering of South Americans.
Fernando Solis, commissioner of the National Migration Institution of Mexico, told the press that there were 900,000 deportations of undocumented migrants from the United States to the southern nations.
He explained that the bulk of this number were made up of repeated offenses, as many migrants enter and leave the country repeatedly throughout the year, meaning there were probably only 300,000 people involved.
Solis said the meeting was a “historic step forward,” not only as it was the first of its kind, but also as it recognised the individual rights and dignity of migrants be they legal or undocumented.
The conference outcome seems to fly in the face of the constant appeals to seal off the border and reinforce frontier police in the United States.
At the end of the meeting the Commissioner of the US Service for Immigration and Naturalisation, Doris Meissner, stated they would not be loosening up policies against undocumented immigration, and that more walls would be placed along the border if it was thought necessary.
“What they have seen it what they will continue to see. We are going to supervise the application of the immigration laws strictly. We are a nation of immigrants, but we have a right to say who comes into the country,” said Meissner.
“There cannot be effective relations between countries when illegal activities exist. There are ways to enter the United States and we want them to be used,” she added.
Meanwhile, Solis stressed the need to draw a distinction between migrants and the people who make a profit out of them – a booming business in recent years.
Pilar Norza, director of the Latin America department of the International Migrations Organisation (IMO), said the phenomenon of illegal migration has become one of the biggest black market businesses on a world scale.
She estimated that 120 million people worldwide are involved in some way, nearly two percent of the world population, moving a total of some seven billion dollars per year.
Norza explained this was “a low risk business” as many nations have not yet classed people trafficking as a crime, though Panama and Guatemala are thinking of doing so.
The Mexican delegation said that they will be bringing in a special migration police force on the borders with Guatemala before the end of June, in order to protect the human rights of undocumented migrants from Central America.
Ricardo Arenas, Guatemala’s leading migration officer said his government estimates there are around 1,000 illegal border crossing with Mexico each month.
Arenas said there will soon be a special Guatemalan migration force brought in to help these undocumented immigrants, most of whom come from other Central American nations.
Vice-Foreign Minister of Guatemala Gabriel Aguilera explained that many of those who enter this nation illegally from the south end up staying there, making it an incipient receptor nation.
The conference covered the undocumented people’s rights to be fed, receive medical care, communicate with their family and lawyers, and the salary owed them for their work.
These decisions contrast with the legal proposals the US wants to bring in in the Southern states which deny these rights.
The protection for undocumented people is aimed at avoiding and punishing abuses by the traffickers, other criminals and even excessive action by the authorities.
Jorge Castro, North America director of the Mexican foreign ministry, said this initial conference should not create exaggerated expectations, as its main value is as an effort to encourage dialoque and agreement on a very complex and conflictive issue.
The US delegation based its argument on fulfilment of the law, intensifying frontier controls and facilitating documented migration.
The new walls, military frontier patrols and night vision technology have meant the interception of more of the people illegaly crossing the border.
A report from the University of Houston, Texas, published last week said dozens of undocumented migrants die trying to cross the border each year, either by drowning, jumping from trains, dehydration or mistreatment by frontier officers.
The Mexican National Human Rights Commission also published a report at the same time, citing 406 cases of rights violations or aggression against undocumented immigrants.
The report criticised the “increase of xenophobic arguments and racial discrimination in that country (the United States), along with a resurgence of nationalism, of deep historical traditions, of neofacist, neoracist ideologies and the supremacy of the white race.”
Meissner countered by saying “the (US) citizens are worried by the weak application of the laws, by illegal immigration and by the levels this is reaching. The government is dealing with these concerns.”
She said that the aggressive incidents had in fact been reduced by the new measures, “the results in the areas where we have built walls have been incredible. Levels of violence and the amount of legal crossings have fallen.”
Arturo Montano, member of the US delegation, emphasised that “the problem is not the documents which the policies of each country are based on, but the way they are implemented and their real effectiveness.”
Aguilera stressed the deliberations had been directly affected by the antiimigration stance of the US electorate, one of the mainstays of the two leading platforms in the November presidential elections.