Saturday, November 21, 2026
Johanna Son
- Congestion, squalor, widening rich-poor gaps and government neglect are turning Asia’s cities into seething cauldrons of discontent that could erupt into anarchy.
Urban experts meeting in the Thai capital this week to prepare for a big international conference in Istanbul in June. They say signs of future horrors can already be seen in the region’s cities.
Asian cities like Singapore and Bangkok are symbols of power and wealth, but others like Karachi or Bombay provide a grim warning of how serious the problem already is.
In these teeming cities life is a daily struggle as citizens struggle with poverty, overcrowding, lack of shelter and basic services, traffic, pollution and crime.
“If you don’t deal constructively with cities now, you’re going to have a lot of frustrated groups showing their desperation destructively,” warns Anwar Fazal, regional coordinator of the Urban Management Programme for Asia and the Pacific (UMPAP).
Fazal was speaking at this week’s Second Asia-Pacific Urban Forum, being held among governments and activists in the run-up to Habitat II, the second United Nations Conference on Human Settlements to be held in Istanbul in June.
Some extreme signs of discontent, like urban terrorism, are already common.
Gunfights are a daily occurence in Pakistan’s port city of Karachi. Crime and communal violence is a concern in India, Sri Lanka and the Philippines, where urban poverty creates a huge underclass of alienated people.
“Neglected groups are going to start attacking the symbols of power and wealth in cities,” Fazal said. “As attacks like the bombing of the World Trade Centre in New York and Oklahoma showed, cities are extremely vulnerable to terrorist violence.”
By the year 2020 Asia will have 17 of the world’s 27 megacties, and governments need to heed the warning signs of urban decay. Already, Jorge Wilheim, deputy secretary general of Habitat II said: “News about cities today are usually bad news.”
And Asia’s urban population is expected to more than double between 1990 and 2020 — by that time, over half of Asians will be living in cities.
But while cities like Bangkok, Kuala Lumpur or New Delhi post impressive economic growth rates that contribute to national output, a large proportion of their populaation remains poor.
Analysts say governments should sit up and pay attention to the people they have largely neglected: the urban poor, who comprise up to half of Asian city populations.
Yet the poor are often unrecognised in urban planning and statistics though they, working as vendors, factory labour and small employees, are the backbone of the informal economy that powers the city economy.
Majority of the population in Asian cities work in the informal economy, which provides 75 percent of jobs in Karachi and 60 per cent in Jakarta.
Because the poor are out of the urban mainstream, they build slum settlements on land they do not own. Governments in Asia, unable to come to terms with how to house its poor, often evict them to free land for commercial purposes, public works or luxury housing.
The result is a growing gulf between the informal sector and governments. “When cities become dysfunctional, it is the poor who suffer most,” said Adnan Aliani, human settlements officer at the U.N. Economic and Social Commission for Asia and the Pacific (ESCAP).
Today Asian cities increasingly reflect the contradictions. The coexistence of opulence and abject poverty, the formal and informal economy. As the gap between rich and poor widens, Fazal said: “The poor are much less able to get access to good things in cities.”
Aliani says: “This shows a growing and increasingly persistent urban underclass that feels excluded from the mainstream of society and is consequently becoming aggressive and militant.”
Alienation is afflicting not just the poor, but also the middle class at a time when there is a perception by almost everyone that all governments are corrupt, Aliani adds.
Governments received much of the blame for Asia’s troubled cities at the meeting this week. Arif Hasan, a key figure in efforts to upgrade Karachi slums, says it is the “systemic failure of government in the urban context in Asia” that has made the informal economy a powerful force in urban life.
The informal economy can include forces that Hasan calls the ‘mafias’ – slum landlords, criminals and corrupt officials – who fill the vacumme left by government.
In turn, non-government groups are now trying to bridge the formal and informal economies with people at the bottom of the pile, says Patrick Wakely, a human settlements expert from the University College London.
Communities around Asia have begun putting up own garbage disposal systems and cooperatives. In Karachi’s slums, residents built their own schools and clinics. Slum occupants in Delhi and Surabaya and Indonesia invested together in water supply and sanitation.
Thirty local government representatives will attend the Istanbul conference, dubbed the ‘City Summit’, and will have equal status with national governments that normally attend U.N. summits.
The United nations says it still does not know how many heads of state will attend the Istanbul conference.