Europe, Headlines, Human Rights

NORTHERN IRELAND: Isolated Republicans Debate ‘The Long Peace’

Sarah O'Hara

DUBLIN, Mar 14 1996 (IPS) - Sinn Fein means ‘Ourselves Alone’ in Irish, and the political wing of the Irish Republican Army (IRA) is finding itself very much alone since its guerrillas restarted their bombing campaigns in London this month, killing three.

The party, which took 10 percent of the vote in the last elections in the disputed province of Northern Ireland, has found itself suddenly isolated by many of its former allies in the wake of the new bombings, which have also wounded over 100 people.

Sinn Fein, treading a difficult path between republican factions has declined to publically condemn the attacks.

As a result political doors once open to them in London, Dublin and Washington have been slammed shut. Sinn Fein leader Gerry Adams has gone to the U.S. this week but he has been firmly banned from contacts with the White House.

“There is a real worry on the republican side that they’ve been marginalised,” said professor Paul Arthur on Wednesday. “Isolated and marginalised.”

Arthur, a politics lecturer at the University of Ulster, said republicans were repeating those words like a ‘mantra’. “People who believe themselves to be in that situation can be pretty dangerous,” he warned.

The ‘republicans’ seek to reunite the province of Northern Ireland with the Irish Republic to the south. The mainly Protestant populated province remained under British rule when the rest of the island won independence after World War I.

Civil rights disputes between the mainly Catholic minority and the majority pro-British Protestants spilled over into civil conflict in 1969. A ceasefire by the IRA failed to lead to all- party talks and the guerrillas ended their truce last month.

The order to restart the bombings provoked an angry response from U.S. president Bill Clinton, in whose administration Sinn Fein had put great faith as a force for impartial international mediation.

“The people of Northern Ireland have clearly chosen peace,” he said in New York, Tuesday. “They do not deserve to have a small group choose bloodshed and shatter their dreams.”

The memories of the Oklahoma bomb are strong in American minds, it is an election year and there is new distrust among some U.S. politicians who had come out in support of Sinn Fein as a party of peace after the ceasefire and then left high and dry by its end.

Some argue that the isolation of the republicans is concealing the decision of Sinn Fein to fight politically, rather than militarily, for the long-term goal of a united Ireland — whatever the actions of the IRA.

Sinn Fein now talks about “an agreed Ireland,” rather than a “united Ireland”. The implication of this is that they will accept the existing division of the island into two parts, the Republic of Ireland and Northern Ireland, as long as it is part of a political agreement resulting from all-party talks in the North.

This strategy has not yet been sold to the republican ‘family’ as a whole, which is currently engaged in an intense internal debate on the issue.

In fact most republicans blame the British government for provoking the IRA bombings of London. Under pressure from the pro- British ‘unionist’ parties, London had refused to meet Sinn Fein in formal all-party talks until the IRA had made a ‘gesture’ and surrendered some weapons. The IRA’s frustration with this stalemate made it hard to resist calls from within to restart attacks.

But many are also angry with the IRA, according to Joe Liechty, who lectures on peace studies at the Institute of Ecumenics in Dublin. They know that the end of the ceasefire means Catholics themselves, their families and friends, may once again be the target of attacks by pro-British ‘loyalist’ guerrillas.

The loyalists, who up to now have held their fire, issued a statement on Tuesday saying that they were still committed to a political solution, but that they would match IRA bombs in Britain “blow for blow”.

Leading members of the largest Catholic party in northern Ireland, the Social Democratic and Labour Party (SDLP) — and thus both a political rival and an ally in getting Sinn Fein into all- party talks — argue Sinn Fein has to convince its own members too.

Back in the 1970s Sinn Fein slogans — ‘Victory 74’, ‘Victory 75’ and so on — were dropped in favour of a new party concept of ‘the Long War’. It answered activists’ foiled hopes of a quick win over the British, at that time pouring troops into the province.

“Sinn Fein are used to the politics of making demands,” said SDLP councillor Mark Durkan. “They see themselves as the guardian of the Holy Grail and everybody else has been dupes or traitors.”

Durkan, SDLP general secretary, argued that Sinn Fein finds it difficult “to adjust to being a party like any other”. Sinn Fein leaders need to prepare members for the slow pace of political progress — ‘the long peace’ — as, back in the old days of militarism, they prepared for ‘the Long War’.

The political stalemate over the 17 months of ceasefire hindered this process of strategic redefinition. “One of the problems was their members were seeing no clear evidence of purpose from the unionists or the British Government,” said Durkan.

“But you’ve got to do it (yourself). If you can’t find the purpose in others, you’ve got to find the purpose in yourself.”

There are reports of sharp divisions within the ranks of IRA and Sinn Fein supporters, between ‘hawks’ and ‘doves’, but all are anxious to avoid a split. Loyalty is engendered by the sense of being part the republican family — of being ‘ourselves alone’ against the rest.

“They stick together for the greater good,” said one young Sinn Fein activist, Michael, considering the ‘republican family’. “The closeness of many republicans is tied to the years of hardship where you had to do it.”

“The ‘ourselves alone’ I find is very real with Sinn Fein,” said Eddie Kinner, a community worker in Belfast and a former loyalist bomber who was jailed in the 1970s for sectarian attacks on the Catholic community.

As a member of the tiny Progressive Unionist Party, he was one of the people who used their influence with the paramilitary Ulster Volunteer Force and other loyalist armed groups to maintain the loyalist ceasefire even after the IRA returned to armed conflict.

Kinner sees an urgent need for the all-party talks, which the British and Irish governments have announced for Jun. 10, to include Sinn Fein. “If they become more excluded, more isolated,” he told IPS, “it reinforces that position of ‘ourselves alone — everybody is against us’. It’s a form of paranoia.”

Britain and Dublin say Sinn Fein will be excluded from the all- party talks beginning on Jun. 10 unless the IRA renews the ceasefire, and Britain seeks a more explicit commitment to democratic methods on the part of the republicans.

Sinn Fein should address the reasons why the main unionist parties won’t talk to them, said Kinner, rather than trying to get the British government to force the unionists to talk.

However, he believes that some unionists actually take a form of comfort in the IRA’s return to violence. Many are now claiming the moral high ground after 17 months stonewalling talks with Sinn Fein.

“They are afraid to come face to face with Sinn Fein, and I don’t know what their fear is. The sooner they do, the sooner they can crack the flaws in their arguments.”

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags