Saturday, November 21, 2026
Reese Erlich
- U.S. politicians outdo one another as they try to sound tough on crime, but little discussion centres on the long-term impact of violence on the victims.
“In September of 1995, my daughter was held at gunpoint and gang raped by a group of teen boys. Between eight to 12 boys were involved,” says Ellen, who asked that her name not be used. Her daughter, only 12 years old at the time, was rushed to a hospital where she was treated for her physical wounds.
The emotional wounds continue to this day.
Luckily for the girl, Oakland provides a community-based therapy centre to help crime victims get on with their lives. Within two weeks of the attack, Ellen and her daughter were seeing therapists at La Cheim Counseling Centre.
La Cheim is one of California’s few successful, small clinics to practice community-based therapy for crime victims. La Cheim, which has nothing to do with the Hebrew term that is a toast “to life”, was founded by a Mexican-American social worker who took the name after seeing a production of ‘Fiddler on the Roof’.
“I refer a ton of people” to La Cheim, says Deborah Leeds, a child welfare worker with Alameda County Child Protective Services. “I’ve never had a bad experience with their counselors.”
Neither has Michael Stroud. The Oakland teacher was walking down the street just after Christmas when three teenagers attacked him from behind with a baseball bat. Although he offered his wallet, they didn’t take it.
“I never heard them say anything,” says Stroud. “The only sensation I had was being kicked.”
Stroud still has a small, open crack in his skull from the 1992 incident. For several years, he also suffered severe anxiety attacks.
Stroud, a white man, was particularly troubled by the nature of the attack by the black teenagers. He still does not know if it was a random, racially motivated assault or a botched robbery attempt.
“I didn’t want it to make me racist,” he says. “Counseling helped me feel anger against the specific people who attacked me” without hating African Americans in general.
While serious crimes have actually decreased in Oakland and many other cities over the past two years, crime remains rampant in the United States. Politicians try to sound “tough on crime”, promising greater police crackdowns and longer sentences. California is now observing the first anniversary of the country’s first “three-strikes-and-you’re-out” law. Three-time felons now serve mandatory life sentences.
La Cheim Programme Director Alan Rinzler says victims of violent crime such as Stroud often suffer from Post Traumatic Stress Disorder. Victims may have nightmares, loss of appetite, and panic attacks.
“You’re having a really normal reaction to a really horrible situation,” says Rinzler.
Most of La Cheim’s clients are victims of molestation or family abuse. Their therapists “form a very safe relationship with the child,” says child welfare worker Leeds. “They learn they can trust adults again.”
Good quality counseling not only helps these victims, but can help prevent a future cycle of violence, according to Paul Balzouman, a child abuse investigator for the Oakland police. He says most criminals have been abused as children.
“But 90 percent of the time, they never went through counseling,” says Balzouman. “People who have are more likely to report it. They’ve shared it with somebody, recognised it for what it was and are usually the ones willing to step forward.”
If today’s criminals had received counseling early on, says Rinzler, “a great percentage of them would not be abusing today.”
Rinzler quickly notes that counseling will not solve the problem of violent crime. “Not everyone who was abused as a child grows up to be an abuser or molester,” he says. “They must take responsibility for what they do.”
Some crime victims at La Cheim say that tougher police enforcement and the three-strikes law are needed to deter violent crime. Others say such measures cannot combat underlying problems such as poverty and racism that give rise to crime.
Ellen, mother of the young rape victim, says coming to grips with her views on punishment has been part of the healing process.
“There’s a part of me that wants horrific punishment,” she says. “There is a part of me that is primal. But that’s not how you run a society.” She opposes the “three strikes” law as unduly harsh and because it doesn’t really deter crime.
Ellen says she certainly wants the rapists punished with jail sentences. But she also wants them rehabilitated so they won’t do it again. The rape of her daughter “was a tragedy of a whole group of children,” says Smith, “not just the tragedy of one child.”