Friday, November 20, 2026
Nadire Mater
- Women in Islamic and Christian countries have seen their faiths twisted into doctrines that repress women, but while political resistance to fundamentalism is seen as essential, total secularism may not be the easiest answer.
Many agree however that the rise of political Christian and Islamic forces has imposed new restrictions on women that go beyond pressure of legislative change — especially where the radicals’ influences run deep into local communities.
“In Poland Christian Catholic values on abortion have become so widespread that the pharmacies, even though there exists no official ban, refuse to sell contraceptives,” says sociologist Kalina Randell from Warsaw.
“The values of post-communist Poland regarding a women’s place, particularly in terms of women’s control over their bodies have considerably changed,” she adds. She believes the age-old concepts of Catholic ‘original sin’, the supposed innate depravity of men — and particularly women — are taking a new grip in Poland.
“These attitudes have resulted in an undeclared ban on women’s sexuality,” she warns.
“Islam’s conception of women’s sexuality is the other way round,” observes Turkish sociologist Aynur Ilyasoglu. “In Islam, the concept of original sin is not prevalent. Sexuality is not something sinful,” she says, citing the richly erotic texts of 14th century Andalusian and Arabic Islamic literature.
Unlike Christianity, the evolution of repression of women had a different root in Islam, Ilyasoglu argues.
“During the resistance against colonial oppression, preserving the dignity of colonised women from the violence of the aggressor became of utmost importance. Thus the rules of Islam regarding (protection of) women were over-emphasised by men.”
Today, she believes, in countries like Algeria or Iran, Islamists are fomenting the rise of hostile attitudes to women’s sexuality which were not originally intrinsic in Islamic ethics.
“Since Turkey has never been colonised throughout its long history, Turkish Islamism does not necessarily require women’s confinement at home,” she adds.
“We should gain a deeper understanding of the reasons for women’s participation in Islamic movements.” Ilyasoglu cited the extensive role of women activists in securing the recent electoral triumph of the Turkish Islamist Welfare Party (RP).
In Algeria women and young girls have been targeted and murdered by Islamist radicals for their ‘failure’ to obey the rules of a particular version of ‘traditional’ Islamic doctrine. But even there women activists are aware that some women consider themselves better off under the ‘protection’ of Islam.
“Veiling of women in Algeria grants women a unique identity what they had never experienced before,” observes Caroline Brac from Algeria, now living in Paris, but in Istanbul to join Ilyasoglu, Randell and others at a seminar on women and fundamentalist religion last week.
. “A young girl who one day takes on the veil suddenly becomes mistress of the home and gains herself a dignified place at home and in the neighbourhood,” she told IPS.
Likewise, Ilyasoglu says, for many women already living under traditional and repressive secular social systems, the privileges of improved status — even if only in the home — as promised by the RP’s brand of Islamism do appear as a form of liberation.
But this commitment has not been well rewarded. Despite their efforts to campaign for the RP, its liberation of its women had its limits. “No women were placed on RP election tickets. That is why the RP women’s movement has now come to a standstill.”
“Algerian Islamists give the front line in demonstrations and in massive funeral ceremonies to women,” Brac observes. “But these women are effectively forced to keep in line or their lives come under serious threat.” Mullahs at Algerian mosques announce the names of un-Islamic women with the aim of encouraging violence against them, she says.
The women argue that the scale of the threat to women posed by the rise of extremist religious factions in national faiths has diverted attention away from wider issues of male social, political, economic and cultural domination.
In Algeria the threat is so great that the basic issues of the feminist movement such as male violence in the home and legal rights have been dropped from the agenda.
“Though Algeria is still an long way from becoming an Islamist country, secularism is such a matter of life and death for Algerian women that, male dominance — if secular — is seen as almost bearable,” admitted Brac.
Randell agreed. “In Poland too, the need for secularism has gained such vital importance that fight against male domination has retreated to second place in the agenda. The Polish church has become so notorious for championing women’s seclusion at home and is involved in every detail of daily life that even the Vatican has raised its voice against them,” she says.
“Secularism is vital for Poland,” she adds. To resist what she called “the rising tendency of segregation of women from daily life” Polish women had founded a pro-secularism group called Neutrum where men and women “join forces” against the church.
But Ilyasoglu maintains that women should understand why women join Islamic movements. Brac also argued that while you could “never push too hard” for secularism, people should understand the power of Islamists to undermine women by making them feel “westernised or colonised” if they commit to a secular lifestyle or seek broader liberties for women.
“In my very short experience in Istanbul, I have experienced a similar sense here,” she said. “So I can not confirm the widespread belief here that Turkey can never become another Algeria. It is still possible.
“And if it goes that way it is very difficult to bend the stick to back the other way, as can now be seen in Algeria.”