Development & Aid, Headlines, Latin America & the Caribbean, Population

JAMAICA-CUBA: Refugee Or Illegal Immigrant?… Pick Your Choice

Corinne Barnes

KINGSTON, Apr 10 1996 (IPS) - The wealth of joy and relief on the faces of the arriving Cubans was evident even through the fatigue which accompanied the harrowing 144 km boat ride.

Arriving last month on a 23 ft boat which had taken them from Cuba to Jamaica, the Cubans appeared satisfied that they were where they had wanted to be.

Speaking in halting English and sometimes through an interpreter they talked of their hopes of blending into the Jamaican society and making whatever contribution they could.

Many of those who had arrived weeks earlier hovered around, anxious to tell of the hospitality of the Jamaican people and how they were being fed and housed and taken care of.

Among the lot were doctors, lawyers, nurses and other professionals. As they spoke, switching from Spanish to English one thing was clear — they had no intention of voluntarily returning to Cuba.

Almost all of them said they left Cuba in pursuit of freedom and economic survival.

But Wednesday the government prepared to wrest the dreams from the would-be Jamaicans, despite their pleas and those of their supporters and a hunger strike threat. The Cubans are going on another boat ride, this time back the way they came.

“We are pleading to the Jamaican government not to deport the 63 refugees who landed on the island. These people will suffer all kinds of harassment if they are returned to Cuba, some may be put in jail. They don’t want to go back to such a system. They are pleading for mercy,” says Rosa Rosales, Secretary of the newly formed Cuban Association of Jamaica.

Others fear that when they return they will be treated as deserters and will not have any jobs and will have their rations cut off.

“No doubt when they return to Cuba these people will be regarded as enemies of the regime and God knows what will happen to them,” says Wilmot Perkins, a popular talk show host here.

But according to Minister of Foreign Affairs and Foreign Trade, Seymour Mullings, the government has been in consultation with the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees and his administration is convinced that they should be repatriated.

“If they were deemed to be refugees they would be treated differently and the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees would either ask the Jamaican government to allow them to stay here or find some other place for them,” says Mullings. “We have gone through the required process.”

Mullings says the Cubans are being treated as illegal immigrants as they have not convinced the authorities that they are political refugees and the government has no reason to believe that they will be mistreated when they return to their native land.

But Mullings’ explanation has failed to appease many Jamaicans who are outraged at the decision to return the Cubans to their homeland and some have even offered to act as sponsors for each member of the group.

“Since hearing about their plight I have made friends with them and I have been feeding them and taking care of them and the Montego Bay community has been wonderful,” says one hotelier in the northcoast resort.

The Cubans who arrived in the island between January and March were initially housed in police stations in the Montego Bay area where they first landed, but were later moved into private homes and the Half Moon Hotel as public sympathy for their plight was aroused.

The opposition Jamaica Labour Party (JLP) has also lashed out at the government for its move, calling it inhumane. Opposition spokesman on Foreign Affairs, Ossie Harding says the Cubans should be allowed to stay in the island as it is clear that they are fleeing political oppression in their own country.

“It is a disgrace and the people of Jamaica should rise up against it,” says Perkins. “Mr (Percival) Patterson and his government are going to have their (the Cubans) blood on their hands. Mr. Patterson and his government do not care about human dignity or they would not be doing this to these people.

“If we cannot take them why don’t we just give them the opportunity of appealing to some other countries. Why are we bundling them up and sending them back?” asks Perkins.

But the Jamaican government has had a history of returning refugees to their homeland. Approximately 100 Haitians who arrived in the island during the early 1990s as they fled political upheaval in that country were returned home when stability was re-established in 1994 with the return of President Jean-Bertrand Aristide.

This move also engendered some amount of hostility towards the government at that time but failed to move the authorities to back down. The same stance is being taken with the Cubans.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags