Active Citizens, Civil Society, Development & Aid, Headlines, Health

RUSSIA-HEALTH: Tuberculosis is Back, and Harder to Control

Sergei Strokan

MOSCOW, Apr 18 1996 (IPS) - Tuberculosis, a disease once thought under control in Russia, is once more a scourge — at a time when limited resources have reduced the capacity of the beleaguered health services to cope.

Cited by the World Health Organisation (WHO) as a killer of more adults than all other infectious diseases combined, Tuberculosis (TB) had an infection rate of almost 1O percent in Russia last year. Health experts say it threatens the lives of millions.

Worldwide, at least 30 million people will die of TB in the next 10 years if present trends continue, according to WHO. It is now the main killer of women leading to more orphaned children than any other single cause. TB is the leading cause of death in HIV-positive people causing over 30 percent of Aids deaths, the U.N. agency says.

Latest statistics released by the Russian Health Ministry and the State Sanitary Control Committee tell the story of its dramatic spread in this country: TB had an infection rate in 1995 of 57.4 cases per 100,000 people.

Since 1991, when the scourge reappeared for the first time in decades, the rate of infection has grown by nearly 5O percent, according to Ludmila Mikhailova, chief expert of the State Sanitary Control Committee.

“The main reason for the violent outbreak of this almost- forgotten disease in Russia after 1991 is the collapse of the time- proven system of (preventive meedicine) which succeded in nearly eradicating TB in the ex-USSR,” Mikhailova told IPS.

He said a Federal Law passed in 1992 imposing a requirement that health care institutions be self-sufficient had accelerated the rate of deterioration.

This forced a vast network of formerly budget-financed medical institutions to either close or give up on treatment of TB, Mikhailova said. A compulsory national TB verification system had also been abandoned as “non-democratic” and given way to voluntary checkups.

That had exposed more people to infection from the disease and reduced the country’s capacity to control its outbreak.

Lev Katkov, an expert from the department of medical services of the ministry of health said he was not satisfied with international TB treatment practices approved by the WHO. These did not include obligatory annual lung screening as was the case in the former Soviet Union.

The recommended WHO treatment method is the so-called DOTS — Directly Observed Treatment, Short Course. This involves medical supervision to ensure that a full course of treatment with several different drugs is given.

“It is fine for developing countries, but we have our own experts who have been studying TB for 7O years,” says Valentina Aksyonova, deputy director of Russia’s Central Research Center for Tuberculosis. Adopting such a system here would be a step backwards.

“We prefer a more individual approach to treatment — especially with the rise of drug resistant strains of TB,” she says.

While health ministry officials complain about the scarcity of funds and loss of former medical infrastructure, TB specialists who treat thousands of ordinary Russians in different regions also pinpoint social and economic reasons for TB revival.

Aksyonova cites the drop in living standards associated with unemployment, rampant inflation and environmental pollution.

While the national average of TB infection rate was 57.4 cases per 100,000, the figures tended to be generally lower in the northwest and grow increasingly higher in the southeast, Siberia and the Far East.

One of the hardest hit areas is Tuva, the coal and uranium mining region located in eastern Siberia. There the rate of illness is more than twice the national average. North Caucasian republics of Dagestan, Chechnya, Ingushetia, as well as the ethnic minorities of Russia’s North are also severely hit.

Deaths from TB throughout Russia has grown by 87 per cent and is equal to 14 cases in 100,000. Russian males are affected three times more than females, with TB level being the highest among 4O- 59 years old.

Those who are at the greatest risk of contracting the disease are children. Child TB infection grew by 62.2 percent last year. In heavy TB-infected areas, the child infection rate is exceeding average Russian levels by 5O times. Other risk groups include the homeless, beggars and other victims of the disintegration of the USSR.

Tuberculosis is also rampant in other former Soviet republics.

The Crimean peninsula, once famous for its Black sea health resorts — including sanatoriums for TB patients — now has 27,000 registered TB patients. Crimea is part of Ukraine where the total number of TB patients is 612,000, out of a population of 5O million.

Ukrainian doctors and health authorities blame the collapse of the former system health system and lack of funds for the epidemic.

Mikhail Bystrov, Head of the Health Care Commission of the Crimean Supreme Council, says the local health care system is currently receiving 75 percent less financing from the republic’s budget than before 1991.

Aksyonova and her colleagues have developed a natioanl TB prevention programme that focuses on early detection. They are awaiting presidential approval to put the 600 billion ruble (125 million US dollars) project into effect.

Aside from channeling money into additional research, the programme aims to re-institute the old Soviet system of TB detection.

“We have a reliable system, it’s just that it has fallen apart,” says professor Alexander Priymak, a Russian specialist in TB, referring to the mandatory screening that took place in schools, factories and institutions requiring annual X-raying for all adults and microscopic smears for those in high risk groups.

Russia’s programme also differs from WHO’s in that it consists of full isolation of TB patients during treatment — a point doctors want emphasised by law in a draft bill on tuberculosis, recently introduced to the Russian parliament.

Among other things, that law calls for mandatory treatment and a system of fines that would essentially bar people contaginous with TB from workplace, public transportation, schools and residential buildings.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags