Friday, November 20, 2026
Nadire Mater
- Casualty figures are the first indication of success or failure in war, especially when hard news from the front hard to is come by — or in the case of Turkey’s latest offensive in its disputed south-east, is tightly controlled.
Losses are not new in the war against the guerrillas of the Kurdistan Workers Party (PKK) which has claimed over 20,000 lives since 1984. But this week’s bald announcement of 30 Turkish troops ‘killed in action’ in the army’s Spring Campaign against the PKK has struck a raw nerve in a tense community starved of other news.
Some 35,000 Turkish troops are sweeping the mountainous area around the Diyarbakir region, hunting an estimated 250 hard core PKK cadres operating on its inhospitable slopes. In return for their losses they claim 99 PKK killed.
“If they were not 30 soldiers but 30 politicians, Turkey would tremble with awe,” said popular columnist Rauf Tamer of the daily Sabah, known for his conservative nationalist opinion. “But how many hundreds must die before Ankara forges a reasonable solution to that war?” The PKK seek self-determination for the country’s 15 million Kurds.
Turkish Chief of Staff General Ismail Hakki Karadayi said he considered the losses “normal”. Celebrating what he called “a beautiful blow against the terrorists,” he said the army could not hold back for fear of losses. “Every operation bears an element of risk; without assuming the risk you cannot not operate,” he said in Ankara, Wednesday.
An anonymous army officer blamed the relatively high casualties on the difficult conditions. “Troops are fighting at altitudes as high as 3,000 metres through two metre thick snowdrifts,” he said. “Since they attacking from the plains up the heights, they are more easily targeted.”
The officer described the fighting as typical ‘low intensity warfare’ — a war predominately fought by infantry patrols in intermittent clashes, not major offensives fought by large-scale troop concentrations.
“The Americans lost one man in Vietnam for 11 enemy killed; the Russians in Afghanistan lost one for ten. But our rate is one to seven, and that is fairly low. Western military specialists acclaim our success,” he claimed.
Gungor Mengi, another top columnist with the daily Sabah felt the losses were still not justified. “I am against sacrificing 30 soldiers in order to eliminate 90 terrorists,” he said. In any case, “professionals equipped to such a high level fighting a heap of bandits do not have the right to suffer such great losses,” he said. “They should be brought to account.”
A spokesman for PKK front organisation the People’s Liberation Front of Kurdistan (ERNK) in Germany denies the Turkish figures. The claim that 150 Turkish troops and 15 villagers from the Andoq mountains. He declined to give PKK losses.
Senior staff officer general Erol Ozkasnak said civilians were being kept out of the firing line. “All measures within our reach are considered for the safety and protection of the civilian population in the area.” He did not give details of evacuations.
Turkish Prime Minister Mesut Yilmaz, in his address to junior coalition ANAP parliamentary group meeting Wednesday said the attack was justified by reports that the PKK would lift its unilateral cease fire, declared on Dec. 14.
“Intelligence reports were coming in that said terrorist groups were moving towards their strongholds in order to launch a fresh campaign with the advent of spring,” Yilmaz claimed.
The ERNK spokesperson in Germany denied this and said that the PKK units in Turkey were only fighting in “self-defence”. In its view the ceasefire still technically stood.
“We originally declared that the ceasefire comprises of PKK abstention from deliberate guerrilla attacks on military targets, and we still comply with this.”
“Since December all casualties in the area totalled around 116, that is one man per day, a relatively small figure compared with the previous period, when it was 20 a day” says Husnu Ondul, Secretary General of Turkey’s Human Rights Association. This was, he said, “graphic evidence” that a ‘de facto’ truce existed in the region after Dec. 14.
Eren Keskin, a lawyer on the Istanbul bar, said the government remains subordinate to the army in direction of the Kurdish war. She noted how Yilmaz demanded a peaceful settlement before the election, endorsed a political solution afterwards and is now overseeing a military offensive.
“But it is apparent that the military is pushing hard for a military solution and the government is simply abiding by the army’s hard line.”