Sunday, November 22, 2026
Patrick Smikle
- As transnational companies scour the globe for sites and situations which allow them to minimise their production costs, redundancies, layoffs and cutbacks are becoming the bane of the workers’s existence in this region, analysts say
It is a climate in which the region’s trade union movement should be thriving, meeting the problems head on and turning the challenges into opportunities, but instead the movement is in rapid decline, they add.
“It is a paradoxical situation,” says George Depeana of the Trinidad and Tobago-based International Labour Organisation’s Caribbean office.
Membership in the movement has fallen from 30 to 15 percent of the workforce since trade unions became a part of the Caribbean worker’s life in the 1930s.
These analysts paint a dismal picture of the labour scene for the worker.
There is an increasing level of job insecurity as globalisation continues to create fundamental changes at the workplace — changes which have a negative impact on the workers.
The “global factory” which is a production facility whose various operations are distributed across a number of countries in order to take advantage of the existence price differentials, is a reality, says Eastern Caribbean Central Bank economist, Arthur Williams.
Transnational companies, the main agents of globalisation can now move large amounts of capital around the world in minutes. Labour cannot match this mobility and is therefore at a significant disadvantage.
Add to that International Monetary Fund (IMF) and World Bank- dictated structural adjustment policies which see governments laying off hundreds of workers and the privatisation of state enterprises, and what you have is an acute crisis.
This crisis manifests itself in several ways, says Depeana. There is an increasing level of job insecurity. Workers are less inclined to struggle for better wages and working conditions.
Sensing this insecurity, some employers have moved to minimise what workers get for their labour. Safety standards at the workplace have been relaxed. ILO conventions previously ratified by employers, workers and governments, are being ignored.
Child labour is creeping into the industrial scene as the economic situation forces children out of school and into the workplace to help support their families.
Contract, part-time and work at home which offer none of the traditional benefits such as health insurance, paid sick, maternity and vacation leave are becoming more prevalent.
Large numbers of investors are establishing plants in third world countries on condition that trade union activities will be severely restricted or prohibited entirely, says Depeana.
Justice and fair play at the workplace is becoming a thing of the past, he adds. Unless something is done “workers rights won by the trade union movement over 60 years of tenacious struggle, could be watered down or eliminated altogether,” says Depeana.
So what should the unions be doing to counteract this unfavourable situation, observers ask?
Harmonise trade union activities across the region, some union leaders respond. Put greater emphasis on bringing women into the movement. Get governments to support workers education programmes. Educate the wider public on the historical role and contribution of the movement.
Improve and increase the research capabilities of trade unions. Place more emphasis on occupation safety and health. Some countries in the region are still operating on the United Kingdom’s Factories Act of the 1940s.
Common to these proposals is a desire to turn the challenge of globalisation and structural adjustment into an opportunity to rebuild the influence and effectiveness of the trade union movement, says Depeana.
And, says Rex Nettleford of the University of the West Indies’ Trade Union Education Institute, the unions themselves need to “shape up” to meet these challenges.
“I have to give a word of warning to the trade unions. We can’t go about calling on everybody else to change, while we want to remain the same.”
Nettleford paints a backward picture of the trade union office, for instance. He points to the untrained secretary typing on an ancient typewriter, inefficient administrative systems, lack of research capability and continuing male dominance. This picture will have to change, he says, if the movement is to successfully tackle the tasks which it faces.
Nettleford, who has for more than two decades headed the UWI’s trade union institute, the region’s premier labour college, calls for education programmes to give trade unionists, workers and the wider public a deeper understanding of the region’s history. This understanding, he says, will show the central role that workers and their trade unions have played in building the modern Caribbean.
It will show that the working classes have always produced the leaders to resist exploitation and give them a voice in their destiny. “It would suit us to delve into the past to see how our forefathers coped,” he says.
“The first Caribbean Congress of Labour in 1946, spent more time discussing a Caribbean federation than workers rights. Those trade union leaders understood the larger issue…,” says Nettleford.