Saturday, November 21, 2026
Deborah Horan
- “There is no need to talk about the east side of the city,” Hatem Abdel Qader Eid told his fellow ‘parliamentarians’ at a session of the new Palestinian Council. “We would like to keep it (the issue) open.”
“But we have to keep our Arabic identity there to protect the rights of our Palestinian residents in Jerusalem as our independent capital,” countered Ahmed Nasser, a Council member from Gaza.
“Jerusalem is Jerusalem without specifying the 1967 borders,” interrupted Ali al-Qawasmi, the Council member from Hebron.
The lively debate at a recent Bethlehem session of the newly elected ‘parliament’ of Palestine, the Palestinian Council, ran on for twenty minutes, sometimes rising in crescendos of anger or collapsing into fits of laughter.
At one point, the Speaker told Sheikh Wajih Yaghi, a popular Islamic leader who spends his days advising his Gaza congregation on family matters, to speak up. Yaghi quipped, “It’s the microphone that is broken, not me,” and the room burst into laughter.
The jocular tone was starkly curtailed by fellow council member Saab Ereikat who shouted, “Remember, none of you are allowed to go to Jerusalem”. It was a stark reminder of the limited power of the Council and the restraints put on its members.
This particular debate centred on the function of the ‘Jerusalem Committee’, a parliamentary body charged with monitoring the problems Palestinians face in the holy city, such as housing, in anticipation of talks with Israel over the city’s future.
Elected five months ago, the Council has met only six times, but it is already in full swing in its efforts to shape Palestinian policy in negotiations with Israel and to create a viable democracy in which power is not concentrated solely in the hands of Palestinian president Yasser Arafat.
Things have not always gone smoothly — the council had to postpone one meeting because members from Gaza did not have proper permits to leave the strip and members such as Haidar Abdel Shafi have complained of disorganisation. But most Council members say they are pleased with small strides they have made, if only symbolically.
“(Jerusalem) is a very sensitive issue,” said Abdel Shafi, a former top Palestinian negotiator who is now a Council member. “We have to make our position very clear.”
As Ereikat’s remark during the session so briskly emphasised, the Council’s ability to influence policy on Jerusalem — and other issues that will be negotiated with Israel in final status talks — is largely circumscribed. Only a handful of Council members can travel to the disputed city without first obtaining a permit from the Israeli government.
But in shaping internal Palestinian politics, the Council may not be not so limited.
Amid some disturbing signs — such as a lack of press freedom, arbitrary arrests and torture in Palestinian prison — Council members have wrested a few small but important victories in their struggle to establish a system of checks and balances.
The first sign that Arafat would have to contend with an independent-minded Council came when members voted to pledge their oath of allegiance to the ‘chief of the constitutional court’ rather than to the president. Arafat stormed out of that session in anger, only to find that the Council continued its business without him.
Council members also stood behind four Islamist members who had been threatened with having their parliamentary immunity stripped so they could be prosecuted for protesting against the treatment of Hamas detainees in Palestinian prisons. Against Arafat’s wishes, the Council voted to reject the threat — and the Attorney General withdrew it.
“The groundwork is being laid,” said one observer working for an American organisation promoting democracy, who spoke on condition of anonymity. “It would naive for anyone to think there is a balance of power now, but small steps (taken now) could develop into something viable.”
These two major confrontations occurred shortly after Arafat’s choice of speaker of the parliament passed by a vote of 57 to 31, causing observers to fear that a constant blocking majority would side with Arafat.
But, although 55 members of the 88-member council belong to Arafat’s Fatah party, there is no unified voice among them and different political alignments coalesce and then dissolve with each issue.
“I am somehow optimistic about the Council’s ability to force its way to start a democratic process,” said Abdel Shafi. “Generally, I think the members of the Council sense their responsibility to the electorate. Their sense of being accountable is strong and this is a very good sign.”
Most recently, Council members lobbying on behalf of their constituents resulted in a presidential decree signed by Arafat to dissolve a monopoly held by two Gaza companies importing gravel into the Strip. Traders fighting for a share of a market dominated by monopoly suppliers created since the Palestinian Authority began two years ago had their hopes raised as a result.
Council members receive hundreds of requests from constituents for help in everything from securing the release of prisoners to obtaining permits to leave Gaza — but often their hands are tied, either by Arafat or Israel.
Yet, not all signs point toward a burgeoning pluralistic democracy. The most worrying manifestation is the lack of freedom of the press, say observers. Since his arrival to Gaza in July 1994, Arafat has ordered local Arabic newspapers closed because they printed stories he did not like.
The pro-Islamic militant Hamas newspaper al-Watan was shut down for three months and its editor-in-chief sentenced to two years in prison for printing articles said to criticise the Oslo peace agreements. The daily An Nahar received a similar fate for printing allegedly pro-Jordanian articles.
Even the pro-government al-Quds was forced to stop circulation after it failed to give sufficient prominence to an article Arafat wanted on the front page. And a Palestinian journalist from Gaza was arrested for publishing a picture of a donkey in Gaza — Arafat raged that this was not the image he wanted portrayed of the poverty-stricken Palestinian enclave.
The result is an acquiescent Palestinian press corps that survives by self-censorship — and rarely informs its audience of controversial issues. Without a press corps functioning as a watchdog over government, corrupt practices — like the current monopolies on construction imports or future shady dealings by Council members — can continue uncovered.
And the Council itself has a long way to go toward installing a viable — and lasting — democracy. For instance, the Council is now having to debate whether to include in the Basic Law its right to approve or reject Arafat-appointed members to the judiciary.