Sunday, November 22, 2026
Pavol Mudry
- Slovak journalists are strongly opposing the latest moves by the government of Prime Minister Vladimir Meciar to have a new media law passed by the parliament.
The opposition of the two journalists groups stems from their concern that the latest draft for a new media law, the fifteenth in post-communist Slovakia, is seeking to tighten governmental control over the media.
“The (cultural affairs) ministry is trying to concentrate influence over the media in its hands,” says Josef Darmo, head of the Association of Slovakian Journalists. He says Slovak journalists have already agreed to create an independent media council, which will consist of journalists to serve as a ethical watchdog. A second control mechanism is not needed, he added.
The new draft comes as a shock to journalists who believed they had established a good working relationship with the government on media law issues. Efforts to create new media bill to reform the old communist rules have been in hand since the old regime’s fall in 1989. However amendments since then have only tackle the most extreme problems, such as censorship.
The Slovak Journalists Syndicate has been striving to find a path independent of politics and is the Slovak representative of international media organisations like the International Press Institute and the International Federation of Journalists.
Darmo’s Association split from the Syndicate in pursuit of what it called a ‘true picture of Slovakia’ and supports, often uncritically, the current ruling coalition of Prime Minister Meciar.
In spite of their political differences, both groups found a common cause infighting for the rights of journalists and both took joined the Council for the Media that was appointed by the government last year with the aim of drafting a new media law.
Under the chairmanship of vice-premier Katarina Tothova the Council agreed upon a new draft law, the fourteenth amendment.
But this was shortlived. Tothova was replaced by Ivan Hudec, minister for culture, and in a weekend his officials came up with a fifteenth version — without the participation of the journalists’ organisations — and submitted it to the cabinet.
Both the Syndicate and the Association have objected. “As long as we could influence the wording of this law,” said Darmo, “both main organisations agreed upon its main ideas and goals.
“Now the ministry of culture wants to create a second controlling power, besides the courts, over the media.”
According to the new draft, the ministry will not only control allocation of permits to new print or electronic media — usually the task of business courts — but it also has powers to slap fines up to a million crowns (30,000 dollars) for ‘disturbing’ the new law’s rules.
Both groups are troubled by lack of clarity on censorship. “Both of us (the Syndicate and the Association) agreed upon a paragraph forbidding censorship in the 14th draft, but the fifteenth draft created by the ministry of Mr. Hudec misses such a paragraph,” said Syndicate chief Jan Fulle.
Other senior journalists and the political opposition have also opposed the new rules. Marian Lesko, a well known Slovak journalist, said legal violation of press ethics can only be judged by an independent court, not by government institutions which will “naturally protect the ruling party”.
Journalists are also concerned about protection of sources. The draft mentions an obligation on the part of the journalists to protect their sources from exposure, but the journalists demand the rules cite their ‘right’, not just their ‘obligation’.
The draft law has to pass through Meciar’s cabinet before submission to the parliament and the media organisations are hoping both will consider their objections.
Although the new draft is quite tough, the Slovakian government is not alone in trying ways to increase its control over the media.
In the neighbouring Czech Republic, the parliament has decided to put off debate of a more restrictive press bill.
“Czech journalists should be glad that the parliament decided not to discuss this draft before the coming elections,” wrote the renowned Czech journalist Peter Uhl in a recent commentary.
“The Slovaks will possibly correct the mistakes of their draft,” added Uhl, “which seems as a whole to be much better than the Czech one, and we can later copy it and do not make similar mistakes.”