Asia-Pacific, Development & Aid, Headlines, Population

CHILDREN: In the East and West, a Low EQ – Not IQ – is a Problem

Yojana Sharma

HONG KONG, Jun 6 1996 (IPS) - Rising levels of stress and anxiety among young people, increasing teacher-student conflicts and complaints by children that their parents do not understand them, all point to a drop in levels of “emotional quotient” (EQ).

Academics say that levels of anxiety among young all over the world could become critical unless they themselves learn how to tackle their problems and parents and teachers learn how to help them through difficult times.

The warning may come as a surprise to Asians who have long prided themselves in being more emotionally stable than their counterparts in the West where the young tend to leave their homes at earlier ages to lead independent lives.

But sociologists say that Asian nations have their own unique causes for low levels of emotional quotient, like parents and teachers being aloof toward children.

Declining EQ among Hong Kong teenagers, although not described in those terms, has been acknowledged by many studies including one by the Learner-Teacher Association which found a high degree of anxiety among Hong Kong students over the future and also that young people lacked confidence in tackling problems.

The same problems have been noted in Thailand and South Korea in particular and also to a lesser extent in Japan.

Conversely, in China, due to the strict one-child family planning policy, children are doted upon as toddlers but cannot live up to parents’ expectations and tough competition in school.

Recently, the New China News Agency warned that Chinese youth are “stunned and troubled” by the intense pressure to succeed and by the relatively few opportunities for advancement.

The Beijing College Psychological Counseling Association estimates that during the past decade, 20 out of every 100,000 students kill themselves annually. Most are in their teens and are unable to confront their parents with failed grades.

Up till now researchers have focused more on how teenagers cope with emotional problems than on the problems themselves.

Loosely, EQ examines how one deals with oneself and others. High EQ say psychologists, is not difficult to spot. Some of the greatest humanitarian leaders have very high EQ, as do successful managers and the most inspirational and respected teachers.

The problem however, is not merely how to spot high EQ but to improve on low EQ so that society as a whole can benefit.

A book by a Harvard professor Daniel Goldman entitled “Emotional Intelligence” did much to publicise the concept of EQ when it was released in the United States last year.

It found that declining “emotional intelligence” among young people is one of the factors behind rising juvenile crime because young people fail to “empathise” with others — one of the key components of EQ which some psychologists in the West see as important as academic intelligence for success in life.

It put forward the theory that high emotional intelligence was as important as Intellectual Intelligence (IQ) in determining success in life.

Unfortunately this led many academics in Asia to dismiss the concept as yet another U.S. excuse for not promoting a higher standard of academic education in favour of “life skills”.

But some Asian psychologists say EQ should not be dismissed outright as a U.S. fad. “Chinese and Western societies both value EQ, whether they realise it or not,” says Dr Wu Jing-Jyi, professor of Psychology at Taiwan’s National Chengchi University.

“Both Chinese and western societies believe you should be confident, but not overconfident, you must express empathy towards others effectively, be able to solve problems independently and creatively,” said Wu.

“Both Chinese and people in the West need to deal with people, have successful careers and lead a happy life,” he added in a recent interview.

Dr Goldman cites a number basic elements of high EQ: firstly awareness of your feelings as you experience them — this is crucial to making good decisions in life.

Secondly, empathy or awareness of what others are feeling. “Ninety per cent of emotional information is expressed non- verbally and people vary in their ability to pick it up,” says Dr Goldman in his book.

Thirdly managing your moods, staying motivated and optimistic despite setbacks and interacting well with other people.

He also believes that professional failure often revolves around some emotional failing. Dr Goldman argues that without high EQ even highly educated, highly intelligent people will not find success in life.

Conversely those with low EQ, even though they may be brilliant, tend to lack empathy. They are easily frustrated, intolerant and aggressive in interpersonal relations.

Some educational psychologists believe work on EQ could be important in Hong Kong with its high rate of suicide among school children. EQ tests may well be able to help predict those most at risk — those least able to cope with their own emotions or unable to deal with others, particularly parents and teachers.

But more work needs to be done on defining a specific EQ for Chinese societies. Dr Wu says EQ is highly culture-specific and more influenced by environmental factors than IQ, so that prospects for helping youngsters master the emotional skills to better deal with the world are far higher than, say, helping educationally disadvantaged students to get a university place.

Ways of interacting among Asian peoples can differ greatly from the West. What is crucial however, is that people should get the message that is being relayed to them, in whatever way it is expressed, notes Dr Wu.

“In the West, children deal with parents on a more equal basis, they have the right to object to what their parents ask them to do. If a child does not get a good grade he can ask the teacher why.

“Similarly at work (in the West) if you feel you deserve a promotion or a raise you can ask for it. Or if someone is angry, they can say ‘leave me alone’ without causing offence,” notes Wu. “Career choices are also personal.”

Not so in Chinese societies. Choices are not purely individual but a combination of personal and parental wishes. Effective ways to deal with this must be different from in the West, he says.

Other psychologists say that while the Western approach can give rise to more confrontation between individuals, the Chinese way may lead to serious misunderstandings, resentment and bottled up anger which can eventually explode into major conflict.

“Chinese people tend to be more indirect,” notes Dr Wu. In particular Chinese use “sa Jiao” or subtle tactics to influence people, establish relationships and ingratiate themselves.

Wu considers “sa Jiao” — which significantly has no Western equivalent — to be so important in Chinese interpersonal relations that he has set up a special “Sa Jiao Research Group” in Taiwan to coordinate research.

“The goal of ‘sa Jiao’ is to, without directly revealing one’s motives or demands, make people understand one’s intentions and adjust their behaviour of actions to accord with them,” says Dr Wu in a recent paper presented at an international symposium on Child Development organised by the Baptist University.

“The ability to effectively and positively sa Jiao may be one of the most important elements of Chinese EQ.” says Wu.

This comes as good news to those who feel the American “touchy- feely” approach to solving personal problems just will not work in Asia. “We acknowledge that there are problems in Asia in the way young people cope, but there may be some uncomfortableness over the Western approach,” says Dr Wu.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags