Development & Aid, Global, Global Geopolitics, Headlines, Human Rights, Population

HABITAT: Temperatures Rise In Reproductive Health Row

Yvette Collymore

ISTANBUL, Jun 11 1996 (IPS) - Cultural and religious sensitivities have again steered international debate on the protection of women’s reproductive and sexual health towards incensed debate.

The political see-saw continued late Tuesday as countries negotiated a global plan intended to address housing shortages and urban problems. Tired, negotiators looked towards compromise, but spirits were frazzled.

“They think this conference is about bricks and mortar,” grumbled a northern delegate, who argued that Habitat II was bound to address all aspects of the community and people’s welfare, even though countries remain challenged by the need to house 100 million homeless people.

Some 180 nations are in Istanbul for Habitat II, officially known as the Second U.N. Conference on Human Settlements or the City Summit.

Countries raced against a Wednesday deadline to resolve difference over proposed commitments to increase women’s access to reproductive health services in the plan to be adopted here this week.

Roman Catholic and conservative Islamic delegates and Mormon non- governmental organisations argue that such language opens the way for female promiscuity, abortions, and a free-for-all in the use of contraceptives.

But the main problem appeared to be many delegates’ inability to understand the links between the well-being of communities and cities, and the welfare of the inhabitants, particularly women.

The chairman of one committee negotiating the draft plan clearly demonstrated this confusion: “The discussion on Habitat is not about health; it’s not about women; it’s not about environment,” Ambassador Shafqat Kakakhel of Pakistan told reporters here Tuesday. “We have to bring in language only to the extent that it is relevant.”

But others may beg to differ with this position. In fact, past U.N. conferences have sought to stress the inter-dependence of all these issues.

“In the Habitat conference, population and development-related recommendations — reproductive rights, reproductive health, gender equality — must be fully protected in the programmes that come us,” Nafis Sadik, executive director of the U.N. Population Fund (UNFPA) told non-governmental organisations here last week.

Sadik presided over the 1994 U.N. Conference on Population and Development in Cairo, where the international community agreed that women’s empowerment — access to credit, education, and health services — was key to the development of the community and wider society.

Both the Cairo meeting and last year’s Fourth World Conference on Women in Beijing called on governments to give women, especially young people, better access to resources and services, including reproductive health care.

But some countries of the 185-member United Nations argue that the current conference on housing and the sensible development of communities and cities should not enter into discussions on reproductive health. Others maintain that all the issues are intertwined.

“A lot of G-77 (developing countries) don’t know what reproductive health has to do with housing. They don’t know why we’re talking about health and cities,” said one official delegate.

But a U.N. Children’s Fund (UNICEF) report, just released, suggests that women’s reproductive health is a critical issue in any talk about sustainable communities.

The report says that one in four women in developing countries dies or is disabled by pregnancy or childbirth. Almost 600,00 women die each year from causes related to pregnancy and childbirth — a figure that exceeds previous estimates by 20 percent.

“The world, at the close of the 20th century, is guilty of a colossal failure of imagination if it remains deaf to the cries of so many women who daily live with the sadness and sufferings that travel under the name of maternal morbidity,” says the report.

These figures notwithstanding, the Vatican, other Roman Catholic delegations, Islamic states, and right-wing U.S. groups held their ground here Tuesday.

“There’s definitely going to be some compromise here,” said a non-governmental official from the United Families International, based in the U.S. state of Utah, home of the Mormons.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags