Saturday, November 21, 2026
Ramyata Limbu
- In Baitadi, a small district of far western Nepal, Chandra Chand, 54, argues passionately that one of the major reasons why Nepali women are ill-treated is because they are economically dependent.
A law which provides equal rights to property for sons and daughters will go a long way in ensuring an improvement in their status, she adds.
But 850 kms to the east, Sita Karki of Jhapa district is dead set against her daughter inheriting any of the family property. “It’s not that I don’t love my daughter. But my son-in-law might claim it as his,” Karki says. “And after all my daughter will get her dowry.”
Nepal’s Supreme court last year found the inheritance provision of the country’s civil code unconstitutional and discriminatory against women, sparking off a lively country-wide debate about the rights of women in Nepal.
The Supreme Court also stated in its decision that granting equal property rights to daughters might result in social fragmentation and the society not being able to sustain an abrupt change in traditional value systems.
By tradition and law, it is the sons who inherit paternal property in Nepal.
The movement for women’s property rights first gained ground with the realisation that Nepal’s civil code — stating that only women of 35 and above were entitled to parental property — was a violation of the Nepali constitution which guarantees equality in all spheres.
It was also a violation of the International Convention of all Forms of Discrimination against Women (CEDAW) to which Nepal is a signatory.
In 1994, two young women advocates, Mira Kumari Dhungana and Mira Khanal appealed to the Supreme Court demanding equal rights for both the sexes in paternal property.
Ten months have passed since the Nepal Supreme Court on August 3, 1995 directed the government to table an appropriate bill on property rights incorporating the views of women’s organisations, sociologists, legal experts, religious leaders and considering the provisions in other countries.
The government has to present the Bill in the summer session of parliament before August 3, 1996.
“There are so many pros and cons to the issue that have to be weighed very carefully otherwise there may be a backlash,” says Dr Shanta Thapaliya of the Legal Aid consultancy Centre (LACC), an NGO which provides legal services to women.
LACC has despatched 40 lawyers to various districts of the country to lobby for the proposed bill and to collect public opinion about equal rights of daughters to parental property.
Reports from Nepal’s Terai districts, adjacent to the plains of India reveal locals are concerned that property given to their daughters might be taken across the border to India, where many brides marry.
Parents are also concerned that the prevalent custom of paying a dowry to the girl on her wedding will enable her to get a double share in the paternal property.
The birth of a daughter in Nepal usually means that a father will have to collect between four and seven thousand dollars on credit for his daughter’s dowry.
Prithvi Chandra Chaurasiya spokesman for the Nepal Sadbhavana Party, while welcoming the bill, cautions that its implications should be studied beyond Kathmandu, the Nepali capital.
Arguments range from — possible discrimination against sons, as women according to the Property Rights Act Section 1 are entitled to both their husband’s property and their father’s property but after the age of 35.
Some feel that men will only want to marry rich brides. Others suggest a system based on willing property to desired heirs will be more appropriate.
“It will help to increase productivity in the country where many men don’t work because they are confident about their inheritance,” says Pushkar Bajracharya, a doctor.
Still others doubt whether Nepal has the legal infrastructure to accommodate such a system that may be too ahead of its time.
“Women’s equal right to property is not a new concept or a
concern ahead of its times, but a reaffirmation of what is already in the Hindu scriptures,” says Shanta Thapaliya. “And as women form over 51 percent of the Nepali population, it is a national issue.”
But even as the debate continues, reports indicate that the issue does not affect more than six million of the nearly 20 million Nepalis.
A report of a high level commission on land reform says more than 2.75 million Nepalis are still landless. Another 500,000 families possess less than 0.2 hectares of land. Multiplied by the average family size of 5.5, the number of people falling under this category also comes to around 2.75 million.
The recently set up Women and Social Welfare Ministry has, however, already circulated copies of a draft based on surveys carried out in different parts of the country to members of all political parties.
“We need the commitment of all the political parties to see this Bill come through in parliament,” says Lila Koirala Minister for Women and Social Welfare.