Saturday, November 21, 2026
Eduardo Molina y Vedia
- The increase in trade between Mexico, Canada and the United States since the signing of the North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA) has brought little benefit to the average Mexcian worker. Unemployment is up and the value of wages has dropped dramatically.
Any hopes of better working conditions for the Mexican worker came crashing down along with the peso in December 1994 and a think tank here last week could see no immediate relief coming.
During the continent-wide seminar on integration held in the Pacific resort town of Culiacan, University of Arizona sociologist Edward Williams pointed out that real wages in Mexcio had plunged 50 percent. They also had dropped slightly in Canada and the United States since NAFTA went into effect in January 1994.
NAFTA created a free trade area with 375 million inhabitants and an annual product of seven trillion dollars.
Williams said the deterioration of working conditions other than wages – labour stability and social benefits – that began years ago remained steady over the last 29 months – to which was added a drop in the share of the workforce that is unionised. The phenomenon affected all three members of NAFTA, but was only severe in Mexico, he added.
Another delegate, Douglas Hanson, a U.S. expert in Mexican-U.S. border issues, said the three North American nations have a current turnover of 406 billion dollars in trade.
Hanson cited official figures from 1995 that show an annual trade of some 300 billion dollars between Canada and the United States, and 100 billion between the United States and Mexico. Trade between Canada and Mexico accounts for the remaining six billion dollars, which although considered a low figure is higher than Mexico’s trade with the rest of Latin America.
Ruben Rocha, rector of the Autonomous University of Sinaloa in Mexico – which organised the seminar – told IPS that “the trade figures reveal the radial character of NAFTA, the centre of which is in the United States.”
They also show Mexico’s marginalisation in terms of trade with Latin America, which has been stuck at less than four percent of the country’s total since NAFTA went into effect, he added.
According to Rocha, “inertia and conformism predominate in the economic relations between the United States and Mexico, as well as in terms of Mexico’s weak ties with the rest of Latin America.”
Although the rhetoric of the Bolivarian dream of Latin American unity continues to be bandied about, 70 percent of Mexico’s trade is with the United States, he stressed.
“There is a pressing need to diversify ties,” said Rocha, “not only towards the rest of Latin America, but also with European and Asian countries, in order to reinforce ties, on a more balanced level, with our North American neighbours.”
Alfredo Guerra-Borges, at the National Autonomous University of Mexico, said that directly or indirectly, Mexico’s integration accords with other Latin American countries extend NAFTA norms towards the south.
Mexico has signed bilateral agreements with Chile, Costa Rica and Bolivia, as well as a trilateral accord with Colombia and Venezuela. And it is negotiating pacts with Ecuador, Nicaragua, El Salvador, Guatemala and Honduras.
Guerra-Borges said integration ties in Latin America are fragile, and tend towards a focus on larger markets: the United States in the case of NAFTA and the European Union in the case of the MERCOSUR (Southern Common Market – Argentina, Brazil, Paraguay and Uruguay).
“Governments and the business community in the region are chasing illusions by overestimating the potential of the accords, and naively staking their bets on what they see as the automatic character of the benefits of free trade,” he argued.
With respect to the possibility of alternatives to the neoliberal model predominant in the region, Guerra-Borges maintained that, regardless of the level of economic crisis, there will be no in-depth changes without something new in the field of politics.
He said it would be difficult for Mexico to continue promoting integration with the rest of Latin America over the next few years, not only due to its economic crisis, but also because it is unclear where its network of accords could spread.
“The Caribbean option has problems that would not be easy to overcome, and negotiations with the MERCOSUR are not on the books for now,” Guerra-Borges added. “What would be most reasonable for Mexico, which is still bogged down in its own economic crisis, is to take time to allow existing accords to mature, to be able to distinguish” what will, and will not, work over the next few years.