Asia-Pacific, Economy & Trade, Headlines, Labour

BANGLADESH-LABOUR: World Bank, ILO Differ on Floor Wage

Tabibul Islam

DHAKA, Jul 1 1996 (IPS) - The World Bank and the International Labour Organisation (ILO) are disputing the need of a floor wage for Bangladeshi workers even as national trade unions demand a steep hike in the minimum salary fixed by the government.

Like entrepreneurs in the country, the Bank wants remuneration to be linked to worker efficiency. But the international labour body thinks this will be unfair to underpaid hands in one of the world’s poorest nations.

In an interview with IPS, the ILO deputy chief in Dhaka, Hans J Lokollo, contested the World Bank’s position on minimum wages set out in a recent report on Bangladesh.

There is no evidence that a minimum wage guarantee makes workers lazy, he pointed out. Low productivity is more often the result of agitational politics, natural calamities and power failures.

“There is no valid data or evidence that minimum wages actually lead to inefficiency and low productivity of workers. Rather standard wages and good working environment usually lead to high productivity,” he said.

Upgrading employee skills, better work conditions and good management can make Bangladeshi workers as productive as anywhere else in the world, the ILO official declared.

Moreover, the World Bank’s stand is based on purely economic reasons, Lokollo added. “Minimum wages have social and other implications for the protection of income of workers,” he said.

Three years ago, the government fixed the minimum wage of an industrial worker at 25 dollars a month. An extra 35 percent of this is given as house rent, plus a one-dollar monthly medical allowance.

Labour leaders now want a 100-dollar minimum wage packet both in state-owned and private enterprises. They want the government to protect poorly educated workers from exploitative employers.

However, in a recent study on Bangladesh, the World Bank noted that government-set wages and working conditions in the formal sector have politicised labour relations, causing inefficiency and losses.

“Hence the Government must reduce its role in the labour market,” says the Bank report. It instead advises stepping up industrial investment and boosting national economic growth.

“Increasing private and public investment in physical capital and infrastructure is key to higher growth, more jobs and better working conditions,” the World Bank insists.

According to the Bank, sound labour market policies are crucial for tackling mass poverty. Increasing the chances of productive employment is the best way to raise living standards of poor households, it says.

“The message for Bangladesh is very clear. Bangladesh policy markers must be careful not to provide high benefits to those who have already good modern sector jobs at the expense of the masses of the rural poor who operate in the rural and urban informal sectors,” says the Bank study.

Sections of the report dealing with labour were jointly prepared with the ILO, though the Bank acknowledges that the world labour body “does not share all the anlyses, conclusions and recommendations set forth in the report.”

The World Bank’s stand will cheer Bangladeshi employers. “We do not agree with minimum wages system. Higher wages do not necessarily lead to higher productivity, rather it may lead to inefficiency in some sectors,” says Sirajul Islam of the Bangladesh Employers Association.

Not all sections of business think so. The Dhaka Chamber of Commerce and Industry is for the minimum wage system as it provides social benefits. “It is a tricky issue, but from the social context the workers need some kind of protection in terms of wage and job security,” says its President Ali Hussain.

Ali, however, says that there must be safeguards against misuse. “The labour unions sometimes tend to abuse minimum wage system and some workers expect wages with little or even no work done,” he points out.

Bangladesh’s 4,000 labour unions which hold sway over millions of workers and influence government policy, are often blamed for putting public sector enterprises in the red, with annual losses of 375 million dollars.

Despite economic liberalisation, the state companies with 60,000 workers, are the biggest employer in the formal sector.

However, nearly two thirds of the Bangladesh’s 52 million hands work on farms. Industrial labour makes up about a tenth of the workforce.

The nation’s working population is growing faster than work. The World Bank report says that to find gainful jobs for them, Bangladesh must step up industrial investment to about a fifth of the Gross Domestic Product (GDP) and accelerate economic growth up to at least 7 percent from the present four percent.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags