Europe, Headlines, Human Rights

BOSNIA-HERCEGOVINA: Closing The Case On Karadzic and Mladic

Milo Branic

THE HAGUE, Jul 8 1996 (IPS) - After hearing from 16 witnesses, several experts and three different prosecutors, the War Crimes Tribunal in the Hague once more Monday heard the case against Bosnian Serb leader Radovan Karadzic and his army chief Ratko Mladic.

Once more the call went out to the major powers, most of whom who have troops in Bosnia-Hercegovina, to arrest the two and hand them over to stand trial for genocide. And once more, prosecutor Mark Harmon criticised them for failing to do so, a year after the two were first charged by the court.

“We believe the evidence we have presented,” Harmon told the court, “is more than sufficient to demonstrate that there are reasonable grounds for believing that Dr. Karadzic and General Mladic committed genocide.”

By gruesome coincidence the calls came as U.N. investigators continued to unearth pits filled with the bodies of Bosnian Muslim prisoners massacred after the Bosnian Serb conquest of Srebrenica last July in what was Europe’s worst atrocity since World War II.

But at the weekend, the U.S. commander of NATO peacekeeping troops in Bosnia-Hercegovina said he would not seek out and detain Karadzic, despite the urgings of the court’s senior judiciary.

Opening his comments in the eighth day of the hearing, Harmon also criticised the appearance of Karadzic’s defence counsel, one from Belgrade in Serbia, two from Los Angeles in the United States, as a “hollow and cynical gesture” by the Bosnian Serb leader.

Harmon emphasised that he concerned himself with the individual criminal responsibility of Karadzic and Mladic alone and not the Serbian people, noting that at least 40,000 Bosnian Serbs endured the siege of Sarajevo alongside Bosnian Muslims and Croats under fire from the two indicted leaders’ guns.

Karadzic’s personal responsibility was based on the fact that he had created a unified command for the Bosnian Serb army and police forces and was its undisputed leader. Harmon noted that Karadzic’s Serbian Democratic Party (SDS) created a shadow government — “a state within a state” — before the war started.

After it started, the SDS seized power in the various municipalities throughout Bosnia-Hercegovina. Karadzic was reelected as president of the SDS last week, telling local radio that his party’s decision had re-validated “the righteousness of his vision” of a strong state ready for “final unity with other Serb lands”.

“Dr Karadzic treated Sarajevo and the lives of its citizens as his personal plaything,” said Harmon, reviewing the siege of the city and a shot from a British BBC TV film in which he was seen standing “above the city like a lord proudly surveying his domain”.

Karadzic and Mladic were indicted by the War Crimes Tribunal for Former Yugoslavia on Jul. 25 last year. The indictment was amended in November 1995 after evidence of Bosnian Serb atrocities in Srebrenica in eastern Bosnia-Hercegovina came to light.

The twenty-three page original indictment and 13 page amendment on Srebrenica, contain general descriptions of specimen atrocities during the three and half year long war.

The indictment gives a list of 20 persons killed and 50 persons wounded by Bosnian Serb snipers — a small number of the actual dead — citing the prosecutor’s view that ordering snipers to fire on civilians or even the failure to take necessary and reasonable measures to prevent such acts is regarded as a basic violation of international conventions on the conduct of war.

Also cited are the pair’s involvement in “atrocities perpetrated against the civilian population throughout Bosnia-Hercegovina and the taking of U.N. peacekeepers as hostages and their use as human shields”.

The prosecutors maintained that when Mladic and Karadzic ordered U.N. peacekeepers taken as hostages and used as human shields, they were fully aware that such conduct was a gross violation of international law.

But the central part of Harmon’s speech was devoted to the tragedy of the fall of the supposed U.N. ‘safe area’ of Srebrenica, a year ago this week.

Between 3,000 and 7,000 civilians were executed and their bodies dumped in mass graves, an incident that Tribunal judge Fouad Riad described as “scenes from hell, written on the darkest pages of human history”.

“The genocidal acts described in the indictment were planned in advance, efficiently organized and executed by the Bosnian Serb army,” Harmon said. “In the Balkans, a part of the world where history is never forgotten, Dr Karadzic’s and general Mladic’s perfidious and cowardly deeds will long be remembered.”

The two he said the two were at liberty today “due to the failure of the Federal Republic of Yugoslavia (Serbia and Montenegro) to arrest them and transfer them to the Hague.”

Both have been able to move more or less freely throughout Serb- held Bosnia-Hercegovina. To the anger of senior Tribunal judge Richard Goldstone, Mladic even freely travelled to Belgrade to attend the funeral of a former Yugoslav army colleague.

Harmon recommended that the president of the tribunal notify the Security Council of this refusal to cooperate. In theory this would empower the U.N. to rule Belgrade in breach of U.N. resolutions and call sanctions down on the state.

But though Serbian president Slobodan Milosevic is accepted as the chief architect of the chaos in the Balkans, he has won a new place as a guarantor of peace since the signing of the Dayton Accord last year.

After the prosecutor’s statement Judge Claude Jorda, presiding over the hearings, said they would proceed with their deliberations and that a further decision will be handed out on Thursday, Jul. 11.

The hearings under the court’s Rule 61 procedure, allow hearing of evidence from witnesses in the absence of the defendants. But the hearing is no more than that; it is not a trial ‘in absentia’, which is not permissible under the Tribunal’s statute.

The judge will not determine the guilt of the accused nor pronounce any sentence. Instead Jorda is expected to issue an international warrant for the two’s arrest on sight.

But there is little suggestion that the international forces in Bosnia-Hercegovina will be any more inclined to hunt down the two men even if a new warrant is issued. NATO commanders have made it clear that there will be no attempt to seize and detain him, recalling a disastrous bid by U.S. troops to capture warlord Mohamed Farah Aideed in Somalia in 1993.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags