Saturday, November 21, 2026
Andrew Nette
- Cambodia is turning to large-scale, chemical intensive agriculture to solve food shortage problems and generate export revenue, but critics warn this may result in disaster for small farmers and the industry as a whole.
Four out of five Khmers are farmers, and agriculture and related areas such as fisheries and forestry exploitation account for approximately half the country’s Gross National Product (GNP).
Yet, save for 1995, when there was a 120,000 tonne rice surplus, food self-sufficiency has proved an unattainable goal thus far and now, with the financial backing of international lending institutions, the authorities are introducing sweeping changes to agriculture sector.
The World Bank recently announced a 40 million dollar soft loan to assist in the upgrading of the ministry of agriculture and another 30 million dollar package has been provided by the Asian Development Bank (AsDB).
Among the prescriptions they are touting is expanding rice production by using more chemical fertilisers and pesticides, and introducing new, high yield, seed varieties to replace local rice strains.
At the same time, the government wants to move away from a reliance solely on rice, which presently comprises 90 per cent of the total cropped area in Cambodia, and develop export crops such as cotton, coffee, tobacco, cashew nuts and feed grains.
“We have a foreign investment law and this includes the agriculture sector. We want to encourage foreign business to come in and develop agriculture,” says It Nody, director of Department of Agronomy for the Ministry of Agriculture, Forestry and Fisheries.
This is in keeping with the recommendations of the international financial institutions which are advocating the liberalisation of agricultural trade restrictions, privatising state-owned agricultural enterprises, and opening the door for large-scale foreign agribusiness concerns.
Agribusiness interest from Singapore, South Korea, Thailand, Taiwan and Malaysia are already active in Cambodia.
“Although the level of investment is not yet huge, the message that the government wants to encourage agribusiness is out there in the region and big players are coming to take a look,” says Baden Cameron, an adviser with the agriculture ministry in Phnom Penh.
“Cambodia is now moving to the next stage, that is agricultural development strategies like Thailand, where there has been heavy reliance on promoting export opportunities for crops,” Cameron said.
An AsDB review of options for agricultural development produced in October 1994, but only circulated recently, advocates making private enterprise the ‘engine of growth’ for the sector and achieving self sufficiency.
But Lot Miranda, a Filipino working on sustainable agriculture for the non-governmental organisation (NGO) Swiss Church Aid, cautions that gearing the agricultural sector towards satisfying export markets is particularly dangerous given Cambodia’s precarious food situation.
“What we are seeing in Cambodia now is merely a re-run of the so- called Green Revolution, implemented throughout the developing world in the late sixties and early seventies and now generally recognised to have been a failure,” Miranda told IPS.
The Green Revolution was a package of measures including the increased use of high yield rice varieties, heavy dependence on external input such as machinery, chemical fertilisers and pesticides, and the introduction of agribusiness.
Initially touted as a solution to global hunger, the Green Revolution reached its peak in the Philippines during the l970s under the dictatorship of the late Ferdinand Marcos, before eventually being curbed due to strong pressure by local NGOs and affected small farmers.
“As a result of this strategy most agriculturally suitable lands in the Philippines are now owned by big U.S. and Japanese companies, who have used them to plant cash crops,” says Miranda. “While many in the Philippines go hungry, the market they are producing for is not domestic, but international.”
According to Miranda, the AsDB review on options for the agricultural sector in Cambodia was completed by a consulting company managed by a senior member of the former Marcos regime. “His prescription did not work in the Philippines and I see no reason why it would work in Cambodia,” said Miranda.
But proponents of the strategy like the International Rice Research Institute (IRRI) argue that Cambodia must take urgent steps to improve its crop yields.
“Cambodia’s rice yield currently averages around 1.3 tonnes per hectare, one of the lowest in the region,” said Harry Nesbit, IRRI project manager in Phnom Penh. “This is not enough to sustain the country’s population growth of 2.8 per cent annually.”
Nesbit attributes 1995’s rice surplus to, among other things, increased use of chemical fertilisers. “Without the increased use of chemical fertilisers the present low yield will continue and farmers will be locked into a cycle of rural poverty.”
Nody of the Cambodian agriculture ministry, agrees. He predicts that agribusiness will improve the living standards and increase employment opportunities for rural communities.
Not so, says Miranda.
“The rice surplus for 1995 was not due to the greater use of chemical fertilisers, but favourable weather conditions,” he says, an assessment shared by the Food and Agriculture Organisation (FAO). “The surplus is not much, and by no means guaranteed in the future they have to be very careful.”
As Miranda sees it, “The transformation to corporate farming will reduce farmers to labourers. There will be less need for them eventually if they decide to mechanise, as they always do. What will happen then? They go to the city where they have no skills to compete for jobs.”