Thursday, November 19, 2026
Analysis - Mushahid Hussain
- The United States has no choice but to rethink its policies regarding the Muslim world following recent developments in the Middle East and in Turkey where a new Islamic government has been installed in power.
Since the end of the Cold War, radical Islam has been the bogey that U.S foreign policy is obsessed with. Containing the forces of fundamentalism and promoting moderate Muslim leaders and political parties decided Washington’s diplomatic agenda.
This led to the situation in Algeria where three years ago when an Islamic party which won general elections was prevented from forming the government by the military, Washington said the imposition of martial rule was “constitutional”.
The United States has since had to change its opinion following the death of at least 40,000 people in the war that has broken out between the government and the opposition, whose party has been banned and members hounded and harassed. Washington has been calling for a dialogue between the two feuding sides.
This week the United States had to quietly accept an Islamist as leader of a NATO member country. In a break with Turkey’s 73- year record of zealous secularism, the Turkish Parliament gave approval Jul 8 to a coalition government led by an Islamic party that has campaigned to restore the country’s Muslim identity.
For once, Washington seems to have learnt its lesson well and realised the futility of blocking Islamic movements either through state power or repression. It did not repeat its Algerian misadventure in Turkey.
“The rise of political Islam is a response to the corrupt and coercive practices of Muslim rulers, who seek American crutches for their sustenance and survival by presenting themselves as readily available bulwarks against the ‘Islamic threat’,” says a Pakistani foreign policy analyst.
Though ‘Islamic Fundamentalism’ remains of obsessive concern, Washington is having to rethink its basic foreign policy interests.
That the process may have already begun, was indicated by a senior diplomat in the U.S Embassy in Islamabad who said his country will be forced to rethink its views as Islam would very soon become the second biggest religion in the United States.
“Islam could become a political factor within American politics and, by extension, start influencing the shape and direction of American foreign policy towards the Muslim World,” the diplomat said.
“A better understanding of the political processess in the Muslim world should be in order,” advises an Islamabad-based observer of Middle East politics.
“The U.S. needs to imbibe the right lessons from these recent developments by responding to the reality with maturity and wisdom rather than a policy based on knee-jerk reactions.”
In fact, the entire edifice of U.S. Middle East policy seems to be in danger of crumbling with the election of hardliner Binyamin Netanyahu as Prime Minister of Israel, notwithstanding the United States’ openly declared preference for the more moderate, Shimon Peres. Following the polls, the presence of the right-wing in Israel can no longer be brushed under the carpet.
Till fairly recently, Yasser Arafat was the only representative of the Palestinian people for Washington. Now it is having to make a distinction between what it terms “moderate Muslims” and “extremist Muslims”.
Commenting on the new geopolitical realities, the Pakistani expert points out rather harshly: “It is time that the United States realises that Arafat has been marginalised in the Middle East and his only claim to fame, apart from the trappings of office, is that he holds more Palestinian political prisoners than Israel.”
In addition, many think, the United States has had to learn the hard way that it has been counterproductive to isolate Iran. That Tehran has been making rather smart moves was obvious from the recent Group of Seven rich countries meeting in Lyon, where Washington found itself isolated from its western allies on Iran.
Iran was behind the critical forging of an alliance between Afghan President Burhanuddin Rabbani and his arch rival, Gulbadin Hekmatyar, which could be the first halting step towards restoring peace in that war-torn country. Afghanistan has been a war zone ever since a pro-Communist government was ousted.
With Hekmatyar and Rabbani on the same side, Iran has successfully marginalised a right-wing student militia, Taliban, who were threatening its western frontier. As a result Pakistan
which was said to be behind the Taliban, has been banished to the sidelines in the proxy war for control of a strategic region.
Iran has been calling the shots in other areas of conflict. It was Iranian military support to Bosnia which served as a catalyst for U.S military intervention. And in the Middle East, Iran is a player with its backing of the militant Hizbullah and Hamas.
It also has close ties with Yeltsin’s Russia, China, India, Germany, France and Japan, while being the first to seize the initiative to establish a land route to Central Asia. In return the landlocked region has an access to the sea through Iran.