Saturday, November 21, 2026
Gustavo Capdevila
- The responsibility for sanctioning the Complete (nuclear) Test Ban Treaty (CTBT) passed on to the UN General Assembly after the Disarmament Conference accepted defeat Thursday.
The Conference plenary session thus missed its last chance to produce a treaty document extending the ban on nuclear tests to underground explosions.
Most of the delegates at the Conference said they were disappointed by the outcome, as the meeting was the culmination of two years of intense diplomatic negotiations.
The Indian delegation once again exercised its veto to prevent the Disarmament Conference from transmitting the report prepared by the special treaty negotiations committee to the United Nations.
The committee report refers to the negotiations carried out this year and the positions adopted by the 61 member states, but ommitted the draft treaty blocked by India’s veto.
Though there are still three more weeks to run in the Disarmament Conference’s last period of sessions, the delegates said this organism had already washed its hands of the CTBT.
The end of the negotiations open uncertain perspectives both for the Disarmament Conference and the CTBT, said US Ambassador, Stephen Ledogar.
“The future of the Conference does not appear brilliant. Its work expectations are doubtful,” he added.
The Disarmament Conference speeded up the CTBT negotiations in January 1994, and last December received orders from the 50th UN General Assembly to present its conclusions on Sept. 15.
The special negotiations committee developed a CTBT text which was approved by 60 delegations, even though nearly all of them opposed to various aspects of the draft treaty.
But India blocked the consensus needed for the document to be sanctioned, by questioning the lack of perspectives of dealing with nuclear non-proliferation and the formula proposed for the agreement to come into action.
The Disarmament Conference, “history is now being written in New York,” said Ledogar, referring to where the CTBT will go next.
However, he avoided stating which precise mechanisms would be applied in order to get the CTBT approved, though he insinuated that a “group of friends of the CTBT” would probably present the treaty to the 51st UN General Assembly on Sept. 17.
He said some of the UN procedural requisites could be avoided in order to rush the project through and avoid voting being postponed until mid-December, which “would be too late.”
The current US governemnt never hid its interest in getting the CTBT approved by the UN before the presidential elections in November, when President Bill Clinton will be running for reelection.
For the last two weeks, when India’s plan to veto was already patently clear, some delegations, led by Australia, started consulting on alternative ways to obtain the sanction.
Ledogar predicted Washington would take the first steps in this process. And for the treaty to have the greatest possible support, he added, it would need to be supported by those countries who have historically fought to impose this ban on the nations with nuclear weapons.
As a matter of fact, the first nation to back a ban on nuclear testing was India itself, back in 1954.