Saturday, November 21, 2026
Aaron Freeman
- Think of it as Klondike II, only this time, it’s diamonds.
North America’s first diamond mine, projected to be the third largest diamond find in the world, received the green light from a Canadian Environmental Assessment Review Panel Jun. 21 and is scheduled to begin construction later this year in anticipation of commercial production in 1998.
The 17-billion-dollar find is located near Lac de Gras, 300 kms northeast of Yellowknife in Canada’s Northwest Territories. It is expected to earn the Australia-based Broken Hill Proprietary Co. Ltd. (BHP) 500 million dollars a year, a figure comparable to the total current value of the Northwest Territories’ mining and exploration industry.
In an area where unemployment hovers at 17 percent, the mine would provide 650 permanent jobs over its 25-year life span, making it the largest private employer in the Territories.
The project has also spurred a flurry of spin-off mining projects, as smaller companies stake dozens of claims nearby. Six mines are already on the drawing board for the region over the next 10 to 20 years, including planned projects by British conglomerate RTZ Corporation and South African industry giant De Beers Consolidated Mines Ltd.
Among the mine’s cheerleaders are the region’s mayors, local shopkeepers, and territorial government.
Yellowknife Mayor David Lovell said he was “quite pleased” with the panel decision. “We need an industrial base to support the population in the Northwest Territories,” he said. “And that’s going to have to be (resource) extraction.”
But while they generally support opening a diamond mine in the region, environmentalists, indigenous leaders, and scientists are alarmed at the lack of scrutiny and the pace of the approvals process.
“The environmental review was not comprehensive, rigorous, or fair,” the Ottawa-based Canadian Arctic Resources Committee wrote in a letter to federal Environment Minister Sergio Marchi following the ruling.
Among its criticisms, the group points to the absence of land claims settlements for native groups, the lack of a rigourous technical review of the project, the limited scope of the panel, and the need for effective monitoring of mining operations.
The group was moving to launch an application for judicial review of the panel decision before the project is considered for federal cabinet approval Aug. 6.
The World Wildlife Fund/Canada has filed for judicial review of the panel’s procedures. Former Prime Minister John Turner, who serves on WWF’s board, is spearheading the court challenge, which seeks to obtain commitments for action on protected areas in the region.
“This is too valuable a natural treasure for Canada to allow it to be ruined by poor planning,” says Turner.
The proposed mining site lies in the migration path of the Bathurst caribou herd, the largest free-roaming herd in the Territories. This sub-arctic wilderness is also home to grizzly bears, wolves, and other species.
BHP plans to drain five lakes, covering 890 hectares, in order to access the diamond-bearing rock and to dump 826 million tonnes of waste rock annually into a sixth lake.
The environmental effects of the mine are “predictable and mitigable,” according to Karen Azinger, manager of external affairs at BHP Diamonds, the BHP subsidiary that owns 51 percent of the project. (The Vancouver-based Dia Met Resources owns 29 percent, and the two people who discovered the site, Charles Fipke and Stewart Blusson, own 10 percent each).
“Diamond mining is the most benign form of mining that there is,” says Azinger.
But scientists call the company’s environmental impact study shoddy and the scope of the environmental assessment panel’s review inadequate.
David Schindler, an expert on aquatic ecosystems at the University of Alberta, criticises BHP’s environmental impact assessment as “superficial” and “totally inadequate (in assessing) the effects of the mine on the environment.”
“Frankly, we don’t have enough left in Canada to write off another region of lakes and fish,” Schindler added.
Dr. Joe Svoboda, a botanist at University of Toronto, told the panel that nearly a thousand people will be working in the Lac de Gras region. He said, “They will be blasting, excavating, crushing and stockpiling 35 to 40 million tonnes of rock every year.”
Yet the company’s study describes an overall scenario of minimal environmental impact.
The federal government has also not reached a land agreement with native Dene peoples who reside on land where the mining will take place. Without such agreements, native groups are worried that they risk becoming an “embittered minority” as new residents move into the area, drawn by mining development.
They are also concerned that industrial development will not be balanced with conservation of the ecosystem, and that they will not be entitled to any revenues from the mining activity.
“It’s unbelievable (the panel) didn’t make recommendations on those issues…our people are the most concerned about,” says Dene Chief Darrell Beaulieu of Yellowknife.
The federal government’s Department of Indian Affairs has rejected native claims to any part of the 4,000-km BHP site. Beaulieu says the Department has a conflicting mandate, since it oversees both aboriginal issues and northern development.
“The other major aboriginal group involved, the 3,000-member Dogrib nation, also supports the development of diamond mining in the region, but wants to sign a joint-venture agreement to help construct the mine site.
BHP is negotiating with both native groups to sign impact benefit agreements with preferential hiring, scholarships, and training provisions for natives. But the key issue for natives is enforcement of these agreements, since there were no such provisions in the panel’s decision.
“I don’t have faith in their intentions,” says Dene Chief Don Balsillie. “I think they’re just stringing us along.”
BHP’s track record as a friendly neighbour at one of its other sites has many native leaders concerned.
Representatives of 30,000 indigenous people in Papua New Guinea (PNG) are suing BHP in Australian courts for 4.16 billion dollars over the company’s dumping of 80,000 tonnes of mine tailings daily into the Ok Tedi River. The company began building a tailings dam at the mine, but the dam collapsed in 1984 and has not been rebuilt.
PNG indigenous leader Alex Maun testified at the environmental hearings. “We can’t drink the water,” he said. “The river is dead.”
“Up until now, we have only heard about BHP’s reputation as a good corporate citizen,” said Kevin O’Reilly, a spokesperson for the Northern Environmental Coalition, following Maun’s testimony. “We are utterly shocked. We must be more determined than ever to see this mine become the most stringently regulated in Canada.”
BHP settled the Ok Tedi case Jun. 11, agreeing to pay the indigenous leaders 115 million dollars in compensation as well as their legal costs. The company will reduce the tailings that flow into the river.