Headlines, Human Rights, North America

MEXICO-HUMAN RIGHTS: Report Blasts Abuses Against Women Workers\REPEAT\

WASHINGTON, Aug 19 1996 (IPS) - Employers in the export processing zone along the U.S.-Mexico border systematically violate women workers’ rights in open defiance of the law and while the government turns a blind eye, according to a new report from Human Rights Watch.

And no one knows this better than pregnant women.

To curb these abuses authorities on both sides of the border must do more to ensure that labour codes are observed and human rights principles are upheld, according to the report released here Saturday by the Human Rights Watch (HRW) Women’s Rights Project.

The report, ‘No Guarantees: Sex Discrimination in Mexico’s Maquiladora Sector’, documents widespread abuses by multinational corporations, most of them from the United States, in export processing factories, or ‘maquiladoras’.

Pregnant women are the target of most of the abuses cited by HRW, including being barred from employment. Although the firing of women who become pregnant while employed is uncommon, largely because this option strikes bosses as too blatant a violation of labour laws, subjecting them to especially harsh work conditions in hopes that they will quit is a widespread practice.

Maquiladoras, which employ more than 500,000 Mexicans, at least half of them women, are a source of “billions of dollars a year in export earnings for Mexico,” according to HRW. And, the group argues, this is one reason why the Mexican government “fails to protect women from pregnancy testing and other discriminatory treatment.”

“Some labour officials saw themselves as being unable to monitor vigorously maquiladoras for compliance with the federal labour code for fear of reprimand from higher officials in Mexico City,” according to an HRW statement, “because the maquiladoras were seen as an untouchable source of employment and foreign- income earnings.”

“The Mexican government should not tolerate maquiladora development at the expense of women’s human rights,” said Dorothy Thomas, director of the Women’s Rights Project. “Sex discrimination is prohibited by Mexican and international human rights law.”

Thomas said she is “troubled” that Mexican authorities would allow the discrimination to “flourish unchecked.” But, she added, “we are (also) troubled that U.S. and other corporations openly practice” it.

The rights group wants the Mexican government to publicly condemn abuses and guarantee women workers’ rights to nondiscrimination and privacy, and their right to “decide freely and responsibly on the number and spacing of children without discrimination.”

Since existing laws are general, the report urges Mexico to enact federal legislation that explicitly prohibits public and private companies from requiring that women surrender information on their reproductive choices, or health, in order to apply for, obtain or keep a job.

And, since government regulators currently can only investigate charges of discrimination once a worker has been hired, the report calls for the Office of the Inspector of Labour, the Office of the Labour Rights Ombudsman, and the Conciliation and Arbitration Board, to be given the power to “investigate and adjudicate cases of discriminatory non-hyring.”

More to the point, HRW adds, these agencies should be permitted to flex their muscle.

For its part, the U.S. government should take up the issue of pregnancy-based discrimination and “encourage the Mexican government to take immediate steps to combat it,” according to the report, which is based on interviews with women from some 40 maquiladoras in the Mexican states of Baja California, Chihuahua, and Tamaulipas

It also recommends that corporations that use maquiladoras as sub-contractors should require proof that these factories are being operated “without discrimination, as a condition for a continuing contractual relationship.”

Among the major companies charged by Human Rights Watch with abusing their women workers are General Motors, General Electric, Zenith, Panasonic, W. R. Grace, Sunbeam-Oster, Carlisle Plastics, Sanyo, and AT&T.

In response to a letter from the rights group, Zenith noted that it is “common practice among Mexican and maquiladora employers in Matamoros and Reynosa to inquire about pregnancy status as a pre-existing medical condition.”

According to HRW, however, the company “admitted to screening out pregnant women…in order to avoid the costs of company-funded maternity benefits.”

Carlisle Plastics, a U.S.-based company which operates a maquiladora under the name of Plasticos Bajacal, denied any wrongdoing. Nevertheless it is promising to mend its ways.

“We will prepare a custom application (form) excluding any questions related to pregnancy during the application process,” Carlisle president and chief executive officer Clifford Deupree told HRW. “Further, we will meet with our on-site physician to develop a prenatal programme which will be available to all female employees of Plasticos Bajacal.”

Labour activists and observers say Deupree has particular cause to appear “proactive”, to use his own word. The Plasticos Bajacal plant in Tijuana has been a target of harsh press coverage in recent years. At issue has been the company’s treatment of women, its record on envrironmental and workplace safety, and the way it has handled workers’ unionising efforts.

Overall, about half the maquiladora workforce is made up of women workers. But in some regions and industries, such as assembly of small electronic appliances, as many as eight in 10 workers are women.

Labour activists and organisers in Mexico told Human Rights Watch that employers seek women workers because they believe women are “more diligent and hard working than men, and consider women’s hands more adept at executing the repetitive motions necessary” for assembly work.

Additionally, the reports says, “women are considered to be less informed about their rights, and consequently less insistent in demanding them.”

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags