Asia-Pacific, Development & Aid, Headlines, Population

PAKISTAN-POPULATION: Poor Planning Adds to Growing Numbers

Amir Mir

LAHORE, Aug 20 1996 (IPS) - Pakistan has spent nearly 290 million dollars on the average every year over the last three decades on population control, but its growth rate is among the world’s highest.

Every seven seconds a baby is born, leading demographers to calculate that the country’s population may well swell to 150 million by the turn of the century from the present 130 million.

“We would be better off if our population did not rise above 140 million by the year 2000 and 170 million by 2020, as we would be able to overcome poverty and achieve our goals,” Prime Minister Benazir Bhutto said regretfully in a recent speech.

The deterioration in the quality of life is apparent. The number of people living below the poverty line, with no access to safe drinking water, decent shelter and electricity, has increased several fold in the last half a century.

At the time of Pakistan’s creation in 1947, its population was a third of war-destroyed Japan. But the birth rate climbed sharply subsequently to 3.1 percent and is now at 2.9 percent, though the government claims it is being brought down to 2.6 percent because of its efforts over the last three years.

Donor agencies and international organisations do not share the Bhutto government’s optimism. They question the veracity of the government’s claim saying the programmes are still bedeviled by functional and financial loopholes.

They have also been indirectly critical of the working of the concerned officials who “invariably refuse to accommodate reason and wisdom.” Foreign donors would like the authorities to simplify their approach to population control, and devise plans that are easy to implement and will deliver quick results.

“The purpose of the FP (family planning) programme has been lost in the plethora of initiatives which have led to confusion among mid-level and upper-level managers who have yet to devise effective communication techniques to reach out to clients,” according to a report by a foreign donor on population control.

Such criticism annoys the authorities, who insist on their right to devise their own strategies to spread the message of family planning. “We do not want to go with imported ideas,” said one Pakistani official. “We know what is best suited for our traditional culture and practice.”

According to official wisdom, Pakistan is at the second stage of family planning. Through radio, television and the media, the message of “small families” has reached every village in the country. Now only extension services are needed.

But international agencies point out that illiteracy is still a serious problem in Pakistan. The spread of schooling is slow, and at least 53 percent of the male population and 79 percent females do not know how to read or write.

And the country’s contraceptive prevalence rate, a convenient yardstick for measuring the success of family planning, is still a low nine percent.

Pakistan is way behind its neighbours in the region. While Bangladesh with a CPR of 39 percent is leading in South Asia, India has a rate of 36 percent and Nepal 22 percent. Sri Lanka, which before an ongoing ethnic bloodbath broke out in 1983 was a model developing country, has achieved a rate of 44 percent.

Pakistan, which was the first in South Asia to make birth control a government programme, has had two comprehensive schemes since 1965. The first was abandoned five years later when Pakistan’s politicians deemed it “irrelevant and inconsistent with socio-economic and socio-religious conditions.”

Strategies though have been more on paper. The 1993-98 plan aims at “strengthening and making fully functional family welfare centres, reproductive health centres and mobile service units,” but it does not spell out how this will be achieved.

Also the managing of the finances has been amateurish, allowing room for mismanagement and leaks in spending. For instance, the operating cost of a Mobile Service Unit in the country’s four provinces are different in each, though there is no justification for the disparities.

Various reports confirm that the network of Family Welfare Centres are the worst managed, and their cost of running is way beyond the projected estimates. But though they are a drain on resources, the centres will not close down because the government’s population control plans have been based on them.

Instead of programmes to promote contraceptive use, the federal Population Welfare Ministry has been hoping a decline in infant and maternal mortality as a result of better services at

the Welfare Centres would convince Pakistanis of the practicalities of restricting their number of children.

That the Ministry has not been able to make a difference has been acknowledged by Population Welfare Minister J. Salik. “The government will have to go all out to stop a further explosion of the population,” he said. “But that does not clear the people of their responsibility — the family planning.”

The delay in deciding who is ultimately responsible has already proved costly. Had Pakistan been less populated, it could have been a wheat exporting country, with a 100 percent literacy rate and a per capita income that would have been the highest in South Asia, Prime Minister Bhutto said in Islamabad recently.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags