Development & Aid, Headlines, Latin America & the Caribbean, Population

COLOMBIA: Rage Over Proposal that Prostitutes be Sterilised

Maria Isabel Garcia

SANTAFE DE BOGOTA, Sep 5 1996 (IPS) - A storm of protest has erupted in Colombia over a suggestion by the country’s Ombudsman, Jose Castro, that prostitutes should be sterilised.

Women’s groups have joined sex workers and human rights bodies in denouncing the idea, which was presented by Castro as a way of reducing child neglect. They accused the Ombudsman of being “ignorant”. Some said he was a “fascist”.

Castro said tying the fallopian tubes of sex workers — thus preventing them from having children — would fulfill the constitutional mandate requiring “responsible procreation”. It would also ensure the family remained the “fundamental nucleus” of society.

He asserted that “the majority” of juvenile delinquents were children of prostitutes, though no evidence was offered to back up this claim.

Such is the anger over the proposal and accompanying remarks, critics have taken to placing quotation marks around his title (Defensor del Pueblo in Spanish).

Critics say the proposal is reminiscent of Nazi attempts to exterminate ethnic minorities. They say it runs counter to the efforts of women to decide what to do with their bodies, highlighted one year ago at the first anniversary of the IV World Conference on Women in Beijing.

Women’s groups note that the summit’s focus on the need to improve the situation facing girls and women, and offering equal opportunities for men and women, ran counter to the Ombudsman’s talk of accentuating gender exclusion.

At a demonstration against Castro, at the Plaza de Bolivar, in front of the national Congress building, prostitutes wearing masks and carrying signs demanded the right to work and to earn proper wages.

“We have children to support and we need to be allowed to carry out our work,” said Rosalba, a 35-year-old sex worker who is mother of an adolescent. She said her daughter is currently studying “so that she can be someone in life.”

“We don’t want our children to have to go through the same things we did,” said Rosalba.

“Someday I will tell my children, who are very young now, what I have had to do to make a living so that I could buy them clothing and food and send them to school. Right now, I don’t tell them about my work, which I don’t like, but it’s the only one I have to be able to support them,” explained Yolima, 27 years old.

“If I had gone to school myself, I wouldn’t have had to go out, as a young girl, and I would have had another life. But I came to city alone, and it swallowed me up,” says Ercilia.

“If we can’t have children, so that we can think that there is a future and that all this is worth it, then what are they proposing to us? Maybe that we should die?” asked Maricela, another woman at the demonstration.

A study by the Bogota Chamber of Commerce estimates that there are 15,000 night workers who operate in an area of downtown Bogota covering the neighborhoods of La Alameda and Las Nievesa.

The CCB estimates that in this area of the city, some 1,200 girls under the age of 14 work in brothels with the complicity of the building’s owners and that of the authorities, who tend to overlook irregularities in return for “favors” and bribes.

The CCB report analyzes data collected in 1,087 brothels. They are generally classified as bars or cafes, since brothels are illegal. Lack of income and education and exposure to family violence are among the main causes of prostitution, said the report.

Castro presented his proposal as a starting point for a “debate in which society and government can define what can be done about a problem as serious as child neglect.” Critics say he failed to address the reasons women turn to prostitution.

“It is difficult to understand why the ‘people’s defender’ would want to prevent pregnancy among prostitutes, but is not interested in addressing the problem of prostitution,” said writer Fernando Garavito in the Colombian edition of the magazine Cambio 16.

Garavito asked: “Why doesn’t he also propose assassinating the ‘gamines’ (street children), castrating transvestites, killing beggars, crucifying the blind, putting illiterate people in stocks, and sacrificing Blacks and Indians in the gas chamber?”

Sociologist Norma Enriquez, director of Women’s House in Bogota, said men also participate in the sex trade. “Why not require the frequent visitors to brothels to submit to a vasectomy?”

The theory that female sex workers are irresponsible and neglect their children “is not based on any serious study; it is an a prior assumption,” Enriquez adds.

A similar opinion was expressed by Jose Florez, director of the government’s Colombian Institute for Welfare in Cundinamarca, the department in which Bogota is located. “Not all abandoned children are children of sex workers,” he said.

Antanas Mockus, Mayor of the Capital District, a philosopher and former rector of the National University, stated that “in this country there many ‘sonsofbitches’, but not because they are really children of prostitutes, but rather children of well-to-do families.”

Many of these women that Castro proposes be sterilized, he added, could probably raise children “better than I could.”

Sociologist Nora Segura, writing in El Tiempo, the newspaper with the largest circulation in Colombia, stated that Castro’s moralism “prevents him from referring to studies on the excellent quality of maternal care among some prostitutes.”

“Horrible,” was the adjective that Senator Vivian Morales, representative of one of the non-Catholic Christian groups, used to describe Castro’s declarations. “It reminds one of Hitler’s time,” she said.

But the proposal is not new. Castro, who was installed in office on Sep 2, had already outlined a similar policy when he was a Congressional representative.

Carlos Vicente De Roux, presidential advisor for human rights, who was defeated by Castro in the Congressional race, was alarmed at the proposal and said that it revealed strong intolerance.

Meantime, the Adoratrices, an order of Catholic nuns, run 22 houses throughout the country in which some 400 nuns are devoted to the reintegration of sex workers into the society offering training in sewing and various other skills.

The idea is that once they are trained, women can abandon prostitution and can make a living in small, domestic enterprises that can guarantee them a decent living. In these centers, female sex workers have a place to share with their children and their friends, for chats and evening cultural events, far from the harassment of clients.

“Whenever I can, I go there with my son and I can feel like a normal person. My friends are my family,” says Virginia, one of the women who participates in these programmes.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags