Headlines, Middle East & North Africa, North America | Analysis

IRAQ-U.S.: And the Winner is Clinton – and Saddam!

Analysis Jim Lobe

WASHINGTON, Sep 8 1996 (IPS) - Despite their mutual hostility, both U.S. President Bill Clinton and Iraqi President Saddam Hussein appeared to have emerged as winners in the latest crisis in the Gulf.

By sending 40,000 troops into the northern Kurdish city of Arbil, Saddam not only dramatically reasserted his influence in a region off-limits to him since the 1991 Gulf War, but proved U.S. intelligence reports that his hold on Iraq was waning was only wishful thinking.

His actions also showed that the western coalition which crushed Baghdad both diplomatically and militarily five years ago is a thing of the past.

Clinton also benefitted from this week’s confrontation. By launching two waves of cruise missiles against Iraqi military targets and expanding the ‘no-fly’ zone in southern Iraq to the very outskirts of Baghdad, the former draft-evader demonstrated that he was not averse to using force.

Clinton’s insistence on acting unilaterally against Saddam Hussein, without prior approval from the U.N. Security Council, belied the charge by his Republican election foe Robert Dole, that he was too willing to subordinate U.S. national interests to those of U.N. Secretary-General Boutros Boutros-Ghali.

Indeed, Dole emerged as the big loser, aside from the Iraqi Kurds, who appeared to have lost the semi-autonomous status guaranteed by the West’s enforcement of the northern ‘no-fly’ zone in 1991.

Having harshly assailed Clinton immediately after the attack for “weak leadership” that may have encouraged Hussein, Dole ended the week praising the president’s response.

Worse news for the wounded World War II veteran came in a Washington Post-ABC News survey published Friday. It found that in any new conflict with Saddam, 54 percent of respondents preferred Clinton to Dole as commander-in-chief. Only 35 percent were more confident with Dole in that position.

The same poll found that 72 percent of respondents approved of Clinton’s actions in the Gulf.

The net result was virtually no upward movement in Dole’s overall poll figures, even as his presence on nightly television newscasts was squeezed out by the news from the Gulf, the president’s declarations, and Hurricane Fran. With only eight weeks to go before the Nov. 5 elections, Clinton’s lead appears to have gelled at around 15 percentage points.

While the political analysts agreed that Clinton had come out a winner, foreign policy specialists were less sure.

Clinton’s own spokesmen this week admitted that Iraq’s move into Arbil is very likely to have altered the strategic equation in a region that was supposed to be off-limits to him.

“He did not simply vanish into the night in a benign fashion, leaving nothing behind,” said State Department spokesman Glyn Davies about the reported withdrawal of Iraqi army units after Arbil’s capture last week. “Saddam Hussein’s footprint remains very much indelibly placed over that region of northern Iraq,” he said.

That admission confirms that northern Iraq is now up for grabs, and that the United States can do little, or nothing, about it. With tacit U.S. support, Turkey announced by week’s end that it will establish its own buffer zone in northern Iraq, extending at least 10 miles into Iraqi territory along their common border.

Iran, which in July intervened briefly on behalf of the Kurdish faction which was routed from Arbil last week, is also now expected by U.S. analysts to step up its own involvement in the region.

As for Baghdad itself, White House spokesman Mike McCurry noted Wednesday that, despite the Iraqi withdrawal from Arbil, the “force that remains (is) in a position to do damage.” Administration and human rights sources say Hussein not only has left his feared security apparatus in place in the region’s most important city, but may also have captured and executed scores of political opponents operating from the town.

In any event, sporadic five-year efforts by the Central Intelligence Agency (CIA) to reconcile the two major Iraqi Kurd factions and to build a potent anti-Hussein coalition in the Kurdish region now lie in tatters. CIA personnel on-site are reported to have abruptly fled into Turkey Aug. 31 in advance of the Iraqi offensive.

Administration officials concede Saddam’s gains in the north but stress that Hussein’s strategic position in the south – much closer to his oil-rich neighbours Kuwait and Saudi Arabia – has been badly weakened both by the missile strikes and the extension of the southern “no-fly” zone.

“He (Saddam) is strategically worse off than he was before these strikes began,” Clinton said Wednesday.

According to Air Force Gen. Joseph Ralston who is also vice chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, “By denying this airspace to the Iraqi regime, we have given ourselves more warning should (Saddam) decide to move to the south against our friends and allies.”

At the same time, Washington cannot help but be distressed at the reaction to this week’s events in the capitals of its European and Arab allies. Almost universal Arab denunciation – especially by Jordan and Egypt – of the cruise-missile strikes underlines the degree to which Washington’s position in the region has been weakened by recent events.

These include the election of a rightwing Likud government in Israel, the victory of the Islamic Welfare Party in Turkey, the successful bombing attack on U.S. soldiers based in Saudi Arabia, and last month’s unprecedented riots in Jordan.

Nor can the White House be heartened by France’s refusal to help police the expanded southern no-fly zone or Russia’s threat to veto any Security Council resolution condemning Iraq.

“Clinton did very well this week, but I’m not sure that long- term U.S. interests were particularly well-served,” noted one official.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags