Headlines, Human Rights, Middle East & North Africa

PALESTINE: Hebron Not Mentioned At First Meeting, But Still The Key

Deborah Horan

JERUSALEM, Sep 4 1996 (IPS) - The long-awaited meeting Wednesday between Israeli prime minister Binyamin Netanyahu and Palestinian president Yasser Arafat may signal movement on the main issue dividing them — Israeli troop redeployment in the West Bank town of Hebron.

In a meeting so sensitive that officials preparing it negotiated the time and type of handshake, the issue of Hebron was not discussed during the one-and-a-half hours the two spent together at the Erez military checkpoint that divides Gaza from Israel.

But the matter is the test of Israeli willingness to meet the terms of the Oslo peace accords signed by Netanyahu’s predecessors — and Arafat’s determination to stand by what has already been signed and sealed, but not yet delivered.

“Israel must do what it has agreed to do,” Hebron mayor Mustafa Natshe told IPS after the meeting. “We expect to see Israeli soldiers withdrawn from the city.”

“Any foreign armed force aside from the (Israeli army) is dangerous,” replied Hebron settler spokesman David Wilder. “Hebron is a Jewish city. Hebron will always be a Jewish city.”

Speaking after the meeting Netanyahu said only that Hebron redeployment would be dealt with in the steering committee that oversees implementation of the Oslo peace accord.

“We are going to discuss this issue in the steering committee,” Netanyahu said at a press conference after the meeting. “We must concern ourselves with questions of security. If security breaks down, the peace process breaks down.”

The Netanyahu-Arafat meeting came after ten weeks of tense Israeli-Palestinian relations in which Netanyahu appeared hesitant to meet the Palestinian leader. Placards waved by Peace Now activists at the Erez checkpoint during the ice-breaking meeting read, ‘Bibi (Netanyahu), it’s about time’.

Israel agreed to redeploy from some 85 percent of the city — the eighth West Bank city scheduled to come under Palestinian self- rule — while keeping its army in some 15 percent of the city in which Jewish settlers live.

About 450 Jewish settlers live in five large apartment buildings, four relatively close to each other in the city centre and one about one kilometre away. They are surrounded by 110,000 Palestinians.

The city is the most sensitive of eight cities slated for Palestinian self-rule because it holds the Cave of the Patriarchs, known as the Ibrahimi Mosque to Muslims, and revered by both Muslims and Jews as a holy site. Some 30 Arabs at prayer were massacred by a Jewish fanatic from the nearby settlements in 1994.

Israeli troop redeployment in the city was repeatedly postponed by the previous Israeli government due to security concerns. The two sides agreed to implement the redeployment last March, but the order to move was held up after four suicide bus bombs rocked Israel.

In April, then-prime minister Shimon Peres pushed the date back again, promising to implement the redeployment after Israel’s May elections. That decision placed the burden of redeployment on Netanyahu’s right-wing government.

Netanyahu campaigned on a hard-line platform that promised Hebron would remain a Jewish city under Jewish sovereignty.

Faced with pressure internationally and among moderates in his own government, he changed that rhetoric with the buzzword “reciprocity” — a code word for mutual compliance to the letter of the Oslo accords.

“We emphasise the need to take into account the needs of both sides based on reciprocity and assurances and the well-being of Israelis and Palestinians alike,” Netanyahu said.

In recent weeks, several Israeli ministers have proposed changes to the existing agreement that would allow Israeli soldiers to continue to patrol all of the city after a symbolic redeployment took place and Palestinian policemen were allowed into the city.

Israeli health minister Tzahi Hanegbi said Israel would not consider moving from the city unless changes were made in the security arrangements and Palestinians agreed to Israel’s demand that the settlements lodged in the center of the city were allowed to grow.

Infrastructure Minister Ariel Sharon proposed altering the signed agreement to allow Palestinians civilian control over 95 percent of the city, while Israel would retain “overriding security” control throughout the city. Jewish enclaves would be allowed to expand.

Palestinians now reject any Israeli proposal regarding Hebron that would alter existing agreements. They maintain Israel should implement what the previous Labor-led government signed.

This stand is an apparent turn-around from previous Palestinian assurances given to the Israeli government that it would agree to discuss changes in Hebron. Palestinians analysts said Palestinian negotiators backtracked out of fear of setting a bad precedent by agreeing to alter signed agreements.

Israeli troop redeployment in Hebron will put the final third of the West Bank under Palestinian self-rule. The largest of the West Bank provinces, Hebron and its surrounding villages include around 300,000 inhabitants.

Jewish settlers denounced any Israeli plan to redeploy from the city, including the one promulgated by Sharon, considered one of the most hawkish of Netanyahu’s cabinet. Settlers leaders said they would reject any proposal that would bring a “terrorist army” into Hebron.

“It has to remain a united city as part of the state of Israel and all of the security has to remain in the hands of the army,” said Wilder.

No date was set for the convening of the steering committee to oversee implementation of the redeployment in Hebron. Egypt this week called on Israel to moved troops out of the city within three weeks.

Peace Now has scheduled a weekend demonstration in favour of troop redeployment in Hebron. The group tried to reach the city Wednesday for a solidarity march with Palestinians but were held up by the Israeli army in the West Bank just south of Jerusalem.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags