Saturday, November 21, 2026
Johanna Son
- Asian governments opposed to a Western initiative aimed at introducing a ‘social clause’ on labour standards in the World Trade Organisation (WTO), may find comfort in a new study submitted to the Asian Development Bank (AsDB).
Leading academic prof. Arvind Panagariya of the University of Maryland in the United States, says the ‘social clause’ proposal faces several “difficulties”, and that it would be an unwise and unnecessary inclusion to global trade agreements.
Developing nations in South and South-east Asia say plans by industrialised countries to widen the scope of world trade rules to include labour standards — especially in child and forced labour and trade unionism — are a cloak for trade protectionism.
Developed countries say they do not wish to deprive developing countries of economic edges stemming from cheaper labour, but that there must be a minimum level of decent social standards.
Labour standards are among the ticklish ‘non-trade’ issues, such as environment, corruption and rules for multilateral investment that give ‘national treatment’ to foreign investors, that some developed countries want put under the WTO umbrella.
But regardless of the motives behind such moves, Panagariya, who obtained a masters degree in economics at the Rajasthan University in India, says there is little logic for adding a social clause into the WTO when the world’s trade ministers meet in Singapore in December.
“Because the demand for such a clause has been made by developed countries while the likely object of trade sanctions are developing countries, the issue has a North-South flavour to it,” Panagariya wrote in a paper submitted at an AsDB conference last week on the emerging trade environment and developing Asia.
With labour standards in place, WTO members would be able to impose trade sanctions on nations with low labour standards, such as those using child labour in producing carpets or soccer balls.
While developing nations bar bonded labour and exposure to hazardous working conditions, they say they lack the resources for enforcement and that sanctions will not stop child labour.
Panagariya takes this one step further by arguing that the immediate abolition of child labour on pain of sanctions “will leave children nowhere to go”, and force the youngsters into crime and rob their parents of needed income.
Estimates of children working in the South Asia’s carpet industry alone — often the focus of debates on child labour — are 500,000 in Pakistan, 300,000 in India and 200,000 in Nepal.
Panagariya says the General Agreement of Tariffs and Trade (GATT) accord, concluded in 1994, already has room for countries that believe its industries are being undercut by cheaper labour costs due to child labour.
“If a country feels that one of its industries is injured due to child labour in the corresponding industry of another country, the former can take action against the latter within the existing GATT agreement. No additional social clause is required.”
He agrees with developing countries that the right institution to promote labour standards is not a trade body like the WTO, but the International Labour Organisation (ILO).
Panagariya recalled the attempt at unilateral phase-out of child labour by Bangladesh, which found that many children laid off from garments mills became prostitutes or welders.
Dhaka has since changed tactics and is working with the garments industry, the ILO and the United Nations Children’s Fund (UNICEF) to phase out child labour and to ensure children are not retrenched without rehabilitation.
India’s response was to launch two years ago an inspection scheme by the Rugmark Foundation that puts its logo on carpet exporters to certify that no child labour was used. But the scheme is faulted for not rehabilitating children.
Panagariya warns this could simply create a cheaper market for those willing to buy carpets made by children and higher-priced ones for those who are not. “That will, of course, make matters worse by reducing the wages received by children.”
Pakistan has been under scrutiny for child labour, which U.S. officials say remains “persistent” there. It has passed laws against child labour, stepped up inspections, and gotten exporters to contribute to child welfare centres.
Panagariya adds the ‘social clause’ is flawed because “the only standards being put forth for inclusion are those lacking in developing countries. But one can also complain about weak labour standards in developed countries”.
How can a sanctions system work if it is only imposed on developing countries and not on rich nations? he asked.
Labour standards within the developed world differ, with those of the European Union (EU) being more comprehensive than the United States. And while American workers have the right to organise, only 12 per cent of its labour force is actually organised, Panagariya said.
“A social charter sympathetic to the cause of children should focus on not merely child labour but child welfare generally” in developed and developing nations, he said. He noted as well that Washington is yet to sign the U.N. Convention on the Rights of the Child.
Meantime, the debate on linking trade with labour rages on ahead of the December Singapore meeting — the first among the world’s trade ministers since GATT’s conclusion two years ago.
The Group of Seven (G-7) bloc of rich nations, despite warnings from Japan and Britain, issued a document in March noting “the importance of core labour standards around the world and examining the links between international trade and working conditions in the appropriate fora”.
Developing nations have been busy opposing the ‘social clause’, which the United States and European countries also tried to get into the GATT signed in Morocco in 1994.
Countries like India want a total embargo on adding any “new issues” to the agenda of the WTO so soon after its conclusion. “We don’t revise the constitution of countries every two years, nor do we change traffic laws every two years,” Tajendra Khanna, secretary of India’s commerce ministry, said in May.
In July, South-east Asian foreign ministers issued a common position against “any attempt to include any issues which not trade related” in the Singapore meeting.
“We are alarmed at the tendency of developed countries to resort to a new form of protectionism in the guise of linking labour standards and other social and environmental concerns to trade,” said Indonesian Foreign Minister Ali Alatas.
“The case for a social clause is weak,” Panagariya said. “Nevertheless, the pressure from developed countries is there and likely to stay.”