Saturday, November 21, 2026
Dipankar De Sarkar
- Trickle down isn’t dead. Its new incarnation is dressed in the garb of economic reforms, and it is hitting women the hardest, says the author of a new report on gender and development published by a UK nongovernmental organisation.
The original trickle down theory — a justification for freeing Southern markets in the Cold War years — held that as developing countries followed certain export-oriented growth models, so the increased wealth in society would percolate (trickle down) to the poor.
In practice, however, this never happened — increased liberalisation in country after country merely saw the rich getting richer and the poor becoming poorer.
Trickle down soon went out of fashion — even as jargon.
Enter Trickle Down Version II at the end of the Cold War as a debt crisis loomed. Its authors are the neo-classical economists of wealthy Northern countries and the midwives are international financial institutions like the International Monetary Fund (IMF) and the World Bank.
Together they are sponsors of economic reform policies whose patriarchal nature assumes women and children to be the automatic benefitiaries of the greater wealth accruing to men, according to the report published by One World Action.
Its just that it doesn’t quite work that way.
“The economic reform programmes depend on, and exacerbate, women’s inequality and the current unequal relations between women and men. The programmes take for granted women’s unwaged and low- waged work in the home, in the workplace and in the community,” says the report, which coincides with the first anniversary of the Beijing Women’s Conference.
“They postpone women’s equality,” it adds.
Not even two decades of efforts by women’s organisations to put gender issues on the international development agenda has succeeded in addressing that gender gap.
Instead, what has happened is that in spite of the fact that the world has grown richer in the last 50 years, women’s position has declined as income gaps between nations and within societies have widened.
One World Action reports that despite the advances made, women are 70 percent of the poorest people, twice as many women as men cannot read or write, and girls constitute 60 percent of the 130 million children without any access to primary education.
Women worldwide produce half of the world’s food but own only around one percent of the world’s land. The number of rural women living in poverty has increased by 50 percent in the last 20 years, compared to three percent for men; women also represent the highest percentage of the unemployed.
This increase in the marginalisation of women has occurred as world income has risen from four trillion dollars in 1950 to 23 trillion dollars in 1992, according to figures publshed by the United Nations Development Programme (UNDP).
“In no country, world-wide, do women enjoy and excercise their full human rights — civil, political, social economic and cultural.”
For the last half-century, measures taken by governments to promote women’s equality have been “peacemeal, erratic and insufficient,” the report says.
For the most part, these measures, whether in the form of legislation or donor-funded ‘women’s projects,’ had been conceived and implemented more as a temporary indulgence than a right — an indulgence that could be withdrawn at any moment.
“Northern governments have been doubly irresponsible. They have not ensured the equality of women in their own countries, nor have they used their aid and their leverage on the international stage to promote and protect thoroughly women’s rights and security elsewhere.”
And very little progress had been made in ending male- domination of the powerful international and national decision- making structures. Their development model — whether then or now — is patriarchal, argues the report.
In the Cold War years, women and children featured initially only as assumed beneficiaries of the greater wealth that would accrue to men. The model rested on Western-centric assumptions about the social, economic and political position of women: women were perceived as dependents on male bread-winner.
Development planners and promoters failed to see the central roles and responsibilities held by women in Southern countries — though not accompanied by equal rights.
Though the emergence of strong women’s organisations has forced donors to put gender on the development agenda, the basis of the Northern development model still remains a kind of trickle down.
“The jargon is no longer in use, but the concept is alive and just as ineffectual as before,” says Helen O’Connell, author of the report titled ‘Equality Postponed.’
“We have had decades of policy statements and verbal commitments to women’s rights as central to development. At the same time, in parallel to this, the economic reforms policies are running counter to these commitments.
“The World Bank, for instance, still talks about women in an instrumental way — so that they can contribute to growth,” says O’Connell, a well known campaigner on gender and development issues.
What has replaced the earlier development model in the post- Cold War years, according to O’Connell, is no better — if anything, it is “more blatant.” Neo-classical economics — the driving force of structural adjustment — is inherently male- biased, she says.
The report says economic reform programmes force women into situations where they have to work for exploitative wages in increasingly overcrowded labour markets. The reforms decimate the public infrastructure necessary for women to fulfill the family and community responsibilities allocated to them.
Further, reform packages concern themselves only with macro- economic matters: governments are required to set right the balance of payments position, reduce budget deficits and get prices right.
No attention is paid to activities at the micro level — such as village, community and home — and non-monetised forms of labour.