Development & Aid, Global, Global Geopolitics, Headlines, Population

WOMEN-DEVELOPMENT: Women Weigh Progress at World Bank

Abid Aslam

WASHINGTON, Sep 8 1996 (IPS) - One year after World Bank president James Wolfensohn left a global women’s conference “wounded but stimulated” by criticisms of the Bank’s policies, he says he has made “a damn good start” in making the institution more open and responsive to women.

But many women’s organisations remain unimpressed.

“He’s basically saying the same things (he said at the Beijing conference),” said Maria Hamlin Zuniga, director of CISAS, a Nicaraguan non-governmental organisation (NGO) specialising in primary health care.

Zuniga was among a group of women who met with Wolfensohn last September at the Fourth World Conference on Women. There, some 900 women’s NGOs handed Wolfensohn a petition demanding changes in the Bank’s personnel, policies, and structural adjustment programmes (SAPs), which they say are drawn up without their involvement and, consequently, at their cost.

Zuniga and some 200 other women went to the Bank’s headquarters Friday to see what the institution has done to meet their demands.

The demands included promoting the involvement of grassroots women’s organisations in economic policy-making; taking stock of their views when designing and implementing Bank projects; increasing Bank lending for education, health, and credit programmes for women; and increasing the number of women in the Bank’s senior management.

Echoing the claims of a March 1996 progress report, Wolfensohn said an External Gender Consultative Group of 14 women had been formed and will participate in a Bank-NGO review of SAPs slated to begin by year’s end. Meanwhile, gender considerations are being built into the Bank’s poverty assessments, country assistance strategies, and project formulation process.

The Bank has deposited the first million dollars of what Wolfensohn hopes will be a six-million-dollar ‘leadership fund’ for African women. Lending for population, nutrition, and health has increased, and the Bank hopes 42 of its borrowers will achieve universal primary education by the year 2010.

The multi-donor Consultative Group to Assist the Poorest, housed at the Bank, is placing emphasis on providing small loans to women, who make up 70 per cent of the poor, Wolfensohn added.

And the institution’s first woman vice president in charge of personnel will work with Wolfensohn to create a system by which staff will be judged on their performance, including their commitment to gender justice.

Bank staffers, many of whom Wolfensohn has characterised as cynical, say privately there is little chance he can deliver on such promises.

Officially, the Bank has issued assurances the substance of accepted standards will not be changed. But Bank staffers and NGOs privy to the process say environmental and social safeguards are being dismantled.

Mandatory operational directives and Bank policies are being downgraded to advisory ‘good practices,’ staffers and NGOs say. What good, they ask, is a new policy if it is not binding?

Offering women the hope that they will see “significant improvement” in the Bank’s operations within three years, Wolfensohn nevertheless conceded Friday that he “can’t promise any miracles.” The extent to which his “beliefs on gender” are reflected in Bank programmes and projects depends on the institution’s executive directors who must approve these operations.

Such hedging on promises might be realistic, but it is worrisomely familiar, women activists told IPS. “He always deflects criticism by saying he has to answer to shareholders,” Zuniga said. “But poor people aren’t shareholders.”

Wolfensohn’s audience had two days to mull over his words before leaving here Sunday at the end of a Beijing anniversary conference organised by the U.S.-based Association for Women in Development.

The Bank chief points out that he has visited some 40 countries and, in most of them, “spent about 70 per cent of my time in the field”.

His audience remains sceptical. “He might visit a hospital, but he can’t see how SAPs are denying people access to health care,” said Zuniga.

In Nicaragua, public hospitals are being “upgraded” so that paying patients can be treated there under “cost recovery” schemes. As more space is made for the well off, the poor have to wait longer for surgery, to see doctors, and to get medicines, Zuniga added.

This, she exclaimed, “in a country where up to 70 per cent of the people are unemployed or underemployed.”

The Bank’s claims of a renewed emphasis on primary — or preventive — health care are “absolutely ridiculous,” she added. Under SAPs, most government primary health care workers have been laid off or have undergone “occupational reconversion,” which involves being trained for new, usually non- existent jobs.

“Now (the World Bank) puts money into periodic campaigns for immunisation or vitamin A supplements or to promote breastfeeding,” Zuniga added. Such campaigns attract a lot of attention and appeal to financiers, but they achieve little and provide no opportunity for meaningful follow-up.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags