Saturday, November 21, 2026
Johanna Son
- Plans by 18 Asia-Pacific economies to achieve free trade by 2020 pay too much attention to what business can gain from it, but not enough to workers’ concerns like decent wages and freedom to organise unions, activists say.
Failure by the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) forum to address the social aspects of the region’s drive toward free trade could negate the gains expected from the removal of all barriers to trade and investment by the year 2020, Asia-Pacific labour activists add.
The labour campaigners, who belong to the Asia-Pacific Labour Network of the International Confederation of Free Trade Unions, (ICFTU) met here this week to draw up a ‘Trade Union Vision for APEC’ ahead of the November APEC summit in the Philippines.
“Politicians (of APEC economies) are to date listening more to the needs of business than to the people who elected them,” Bill Jordan, general secretary of the Belgium-based ICTFU, said at the end of the conference Thursday.
ICTFU economist James Howard urged APEC leaders to heed workers’ concerns on the possible ill effects of free trade on wages and living standards, especially in a region where there is increasing competition for investments and whose growth is export- driven.
“Economic integration, if left purely to the market, will widen income disparities and perhaps poverty,” he pointed out.
The solution lies in ensuring that economies have mechanisms, ranging from collective bargaining accords to action against the use of child labour, to make the transition to free trade more painless and to ensure that businesses do not profit from exploitative practices, labour activists explained.
Jordan said these mechanisms are among the “few basic rules” that APEC leaders should support.
In the ‘Trade Union Vision For APEC’ document given Thursday to Philippine President Fidel Ramos, host of the 1996 APEC leaders summit on Nov. 25, trade unionists sought a social contract between workers and governments.
“In the context of APEC, this is envisaged to lead to a policy climate in which workers, through legal rights to form and join their own freely chosen organisations, are able to work with employers and the government to establish a sound system of industrial relations,” the document said.
Specifically, it urges APEC to commit itself to “eliminate exploitation, discrimination and repression in the workplace,” which hold back workers’ contributions to growth.
Jordan says that unless the workers’ concerns are heard by APEC leaders, the move to free trade is likely to mean growth in inequality. “And inequality means one thing: political instability, and that will do much damage to the prospects of economic growth,” he added.
“Our aim is not to put a break on economic development, but to make sure there is balanced economic development,” he added.
The ‘Trade Union Vision For APEC’ report said: “APEC provides the potential for substantially higher economic growth, employment creation, higher living standards and poverty alleviation for workers.”
“However, in the absence of respect for human rights, labour standards, social programmes and redistributive measures, these benefits are not guaranteed,” it explained. “Increased competition can drive down wages and living standards.”
The Asia-Pacific Labour Network asked APEC leaders to set up an ‘APEC Labour Forum’ to put in workers’ concerns in the forum’s discussions, akin to the way they have given businessmen consultative status through the APEC Business Advisory Council.
Edsel Custodio, a Filipino trade official, concedes that liberalisation puts pressure on labour by altering production structure and technology and weeding out low-skilled jobs, and that it causes some job loss.
“It is true, under a fast-changing scenario we are in, that there will be transition pains and frictions,” he said, but adds liberalisation will help industrialisation in the long term.
Explained Custodio: “APEC stands for liberalisation – for freer trade and investments and flow of services. Its most immediate beneficiaries are labour.”
Despite efforts by Asia-Pacific trade unionists to push labour concerns in APEC member economies, their task is complicated by countries’ varying labour standards.
APEC groups Australia, Brunei, Canada, Chile, China, Hong Kong, Indonesia, Japan, Malaysia, Mexico, New Zealand, the Philippines, Papua New Guinea, Singapore, South Korea, Taiwan, Thailand and the United States.
Takashi Izumi, general secretary of ICTFU’s Asia-Pacific Regional Organisation, said that “economic growth has not been accompanied with (as much) democracy, social justice and freedom of association”. In countries like Malaysia, for instance, the percentage of organised labour stands at only 10 per cent.
In Asia’s manufacturing sector, which has powered the rapid growth of many of the region’s developing nations, labour rights, standards and mechanisms that allow workers to negotiate with employers do not always exist.
For instance, Izumi says, local governments hosting export processing zones and industrial parks have been known to offer no- strike environments as “the greatest incentive for foreign investment”.
Many APEC economies generally recognise workers’ rights, “but there are cases where freedom of association is not available and exploitation takes place. That’s got to go,” remarked Jordan.
Ken Douglas, president of the New Zealand Congress of Unions, says ICTFU does not seek uniform standards for labour across APEC economies, and certainly not common wage rates.
But “it’s part of the democratic practice of nation-states to allow workers to claim their share (of wealth they helped produce) under collective bargaining negotiations”, he said.