Friday, November 20, 2026
Stephen Dale
- Hundreds of thousands of Swainson’s hawks have begun their marathon migration which takes them through as many as 16 countries in the Americas — an epic journey of over 11,000 kms.
Having set off in late October from their prairie home in northern Saskatchewan and Alberta in the Canadian west as well as from the U.S. north-west, the birds should reach their wintering grounds in Argentina’s pampas by mid-November.
As they fly, wildlife officials on two continents are watching to see whether a new international deal will prevent a repeat of the pesticide poisonings in Argentina, which in the past several years have killed at least 20,000 Swainson’s hawks and significantly reduced the number of birds returning north.
“I think things will be better this year,” says Pierre Mineau, head of the pesticide section of the Canadian Wildlife Service, a branch of Canada’s environment ministry. “I don’t think we’ve solved the problem, but we shall soon see how much progress we’ve actually made.”
Brian Woodbridge, Mineau’s counterpart at the U.S. Forest Service in Yreka, California is cautious: “I’m going to wait until we see what happens this year before flying the flag of victory.”
Woodbridge and Mineau are among a group of North American wildlife specialists who were baffled by the plunge in the population of the Swainson’s hawk, one of the major bird species on the Canadian and U.S. prairies which still numbers some 400,000.
“Fortunately, they are not rare birds yet,” says Mineau.
The answer to the riddle came when Argentine farmers and researchers discovered huge numbers of hawks lying dead in fields that had been sprayed with monocrotophos, a toxic insecticide that had been banned in Canada and voluntarily withdrawn from use in the United States by its former manufacturer, DuPont.
But monocrotophos continues to be marketed in Latin America. The Swiss company Ciba-Geigy sells it under the brand name Nuvacron.
In Argentina, the chemical was used to control infestations of grasshoppers — one of the primary foods of Swainson’s Hawks — in fields of alfalfa, sunflowers, and some cereals.
In a Canada-funded study, Argentina’s Instituto Nacional de Tecnologia Agropecuaria (INTA) compiled data on 18 reported kills between October 1995 and February 1996, the largest of which resulted in the deaths of 3,000 Swainson’s hawks.
Woodbridge, however, has reported seeing an entire flock of 7,000 hawks killed.
In one case, “we found hawks standing upright in fields that had just been sprayed. They were propped up by their partly spread wings,” he told the nature magazine, Audubon.
In response to the carnage, Argentina’s federal government has since outlawed the use of monocrotophos for grasshopper control and in alfalfa fields where Swainson’s hawks forage for food.
Vast public and international pressure has also pushed Ciby- Geigy to act. In August, company officials met in Washington with U.S. and Canadian environmentalists and agreed to stop selling monocrotophos in the pampas, to buy back existing stockpiles of the chemical, and to try to persuade other makers of the pesticide to do the same.
Woodbridge, who has just returned from another trip to Argentina, told IPS from his northern California office that the response has been better than he would have expected.
“There’s a huge amount of activity there in support of the Swainson’s hawk,” he reports.
“In the pampas, there are posters everywhere saying ‘don’t kill these birds.’ It’s causing a minor revolution. In the government, in particular, people are working to come up with a range of long-term alternatives to conventional agricultural management,” Woodbridge said.
Mineau, the Canadian official, also praises his counterparts in the Argentine government who “have taken this issue very seriously.” He describes a 1969 Argentine pesticide registration law as “incredibly forward-looking”.
But he adds that enforcement remains a problem in Argentina, particularly in an age of government cut-backs. He also says the deaths of the Swainson’s Hawks underscores the need for a new mechanism to deal with trans-border pesticide issues.
He explains that the most persistent class of pesticides known as organochlorines (which include DDT) are regulated by international treaties. But the same is not true for less persistent, but sometimes acutely poisonous pesticides like monocrotophos.
Having to fight against a poisonous chemical in all of the countries through which a migratory bird passes is an almost impossible task, says Mineau. “I’ve participated in trying to get a chemical banned in Canada, and it is a long and ponderous process.”
The Canadian official also has critical words for Ciba-Geigy which he says should not have allowed the poisonings to take place in the first place.
“I think that often the product was put in the hands of farmers who were not told enough about the potential consequences of using it,” the scientist says.
“The chemical has a long history of killing birds,” says Mineau. “It has a clear track record for this, and they (the company) know this, because originally there was an attempt to market it as an avicide” — a substance to kill birds.
Judy Shaw, Ciba-Geigy’s government policy manager in Toronto, defends the company’s performance, saying the problem arose because new crops were recently introduced to the pampas. And “when agriculture changes and cropping practises change, then there have to be some adjustments made in the tools we use.”
Also, “I would highly doubt” that monocrotophos was ever intended as an avicide, Shaw told IPS. She said the company never approved the chemical for controlling grasshoppers, and adds that Mineau’s suggestion that the company should have specifically warned against that use would have been too cumbersome a process.
“You can’t possible off-label every single thing,” she says. “If you list all the things you couldn’t use it on, then you’d have a book.”