Economy & Trade, Headlines, Human Rights, Labour, North America

U.S.-LABOUR: Conduct Codes Cut Child Labour, But Aren’t a Panacea

Peter Zirnite

WASHINGTON, Oct 22 1996 (IPS) - Corporate codes of conduct have had a positive affect on the international garment industry, but they will not by themselves end the exploitation of child workers, according to a study released by the U.S. Department of Labour Monday.

While conduct codes have created a “potential downward trend in the use of children” in apparel manufacturing worldwide, the Labour Department cautions that the codes are only as effective as the monitoring companies use to enforce them.

And labour activists say that corporations will not step up code enforcement unless consumers apply more pressure, because their executives are driven more by the fear of adverse publicity than by social consciousness.

“Private industry now recognises that it can take steps to make sure boys and girls are not robbed of their childhoods. But codes are not a panacea,” U.S. Secretary of Labour Robert Reich said. “No code is worth the paper it’s printed on without strict enforcement of its requirements.”

Reich’s comments were made in response to the release of ‘The Apparel Industry and Codes of Conduct: A Solution to the International Labour Problem?’, a 200-plus-page report based on a survey of 45 U.S. importers and on-site visits to 70 plants in six countries that make clothing for U.S. firms.

The report found that child labour was down significantly in the Latin American countries studied — the Dominican Republic, El Salvador, Guatemala, and Honduras. But it cautioned that while fewer children are now working in large factories, the exploitation of children remains a problem in both subcontracting and homework.

In the Philippines and India, “it is clear that children continue to work for subcontractors and in homework,” according to Labour Department officials.

“Child labour remains a serious problem, with hundreds of millions of working children around the world,” the Labour Department concluded. “However, the presence of children in the garment-export industry may be reduced by implementing codes of conduct.”

Of the 45 U.S. companies that responded to the Labour Department survey, 36 said they have adopted policies that specifically prohibit children from producing the goods they import and have distributed these codes of conduct to their suppliers.

However, only 22 of the 70 overseas plant managers questioned said they had communicated the codes to their workers, and just 21 had posted the codes in work areas.

“An important issue regarding the implementation of corporate codes is their transparency, or the extent to which foreigner contractors and subcontractors, workers, the public, NGOs (non- governmental organisations), and governments are aware of their existence and meaning,” the report states.

“When transparency is lacking,” it adds, “interested parties cannot benefit fully from a code of conduct.”

Noting that monitoring is “critical to the success of a code of conduct,” the Labour Department points out that most codes “do not contain detailed provisions for monitoring implementation” and that some monitoring systems amount to nothing more than “self-certification” by contractors or suppliers.

The report calls on U.S. importers to take a more active role in monitoring, in particular the work of subcontractors. Other recommendations include the adoption of more uniform codes of conduct and the adoption of codes by “all elements in the apparel industry” — manufacturers, retailers, buying agents, and merchandisers.

The Labour Department also called on companies to work more closely with NGOs and foreign governments to ensure that workers are adequately informed about codes of conduct “so that the codes can fully serve their purpose.”

Charles Kernaghan, director of the National Labour Committee, agreed with the Labour Department finding that corporate codes have reduced the number of children working in Latin American clothing factories. “There has been some improvement,” he said, “but it is not over overwhelming.”

And Pharis Harvey of the International Labour Rights Education and Research Fund concurred with the report conclusion regarding the need for stricter code enforcement. “Clearly, codes are only as good as their enforcement mechanism,” he said. “No company has yet developed an adequate overall monitoring structure.”

The two labour activists, however, dispute the Labour Department’s contention that companies have adopted codes out of a sense of “social responsibility,” as well as in response to pressure from the media, labour groups, and consumers.

“This thing has been driven by the U.S. consumer,” said Kernaghan, whose New York-based group has organised opposition to the labour practises employed by Liz Claiborne and The Gap, who were among the U.S. firms surveyed by the Labour Department. Corporate codes of conduct adopted to date, he said, are “strictly advertising, public relations.”

“What we are seeing is these companies going through their contortions as they try to regain control over this (issue),” Kernaghan said, adding that U.S. firms are “terrified” of consumer reaction to reports that their products are produced by child labour.

Both Kernaghan and Harvey warned that in the battle to sway public opinion corporations will play the cost card, arguing that improving labour conditions will result in higher prices for consumer. But they say this is a false argument.

“Their mark-up on the clothing is extraordinary,” Kernaghan said, noting that his research has shown that on average labour costs account for just “one-half of 1 percent of the sale price of the garment,” with shipping, advertising and corporate salaries accounting for the balance.

Harvey concurred. “An awful lot of people in the United States live off that worker in El Salvador or the Dominican Republic,” he said, adding, “Cheap labour doesn’t seem to lower the prices of goods. It just raises the level of corporate profits.”

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags