Saturday, November 21, 2026
Ramesh Jaura
- As money becomes scarce and the public presses to make development aid more effective, a tug-of-war has begun within the German government on whether to quit or stay put at the United Nations Industrial Development Organisation (UNIDO).
Germany’s minister of economic cooperation and development, Carl- Dieter Spranger, whose ministry provides 9.37 percent — 17 million marks (some 11 million dollars) — of UNIDO’s annual budget, favours moving out of the organisation.
He broached the issue Wednesday at a meeting of the council of government ministers, headed by Chancellor Helmut Kohl. He argues that the 30-year old Vienna-based agency, which offers technical assistance and fosters industrial cooperation between industrialised and developing countries, has become practically redundant.
Spranger argued that the 168-member UNIDO, which employs 800 people and has an annual budget of some 100 million dollars, was not willing to reform itself.
Mandated to support industrial development in the developing nations, UNIDO had no longer any role to play now that market economy is making inroads into the Third World countries and the state is increasingly on the retreat, argued Spranger.
Should the council of minisers back him, Germany would quit next year. It will then follow the United States, which moved out last year. But media reports, say that while foreign minister Klaus Kinkel may share Spranger’s views in principle, he rejects moving out of UNIDO as an automatic response.
UNIDO has gone through a series of crises in recent years. Besides facing charges of corruption — including a messy computer deal in the eighties — UNIDO has had to face falling donor confidence.
The agency says that under a three-pronged process, the number of staff has been cut from 1,350 at its peak in 1992 down to 800 with another 100 more to go. Some of these staff service other U.N. organisations headquartered or with offices in Vienna. Second and third stages included restructuring the organisation more towards the specific, and changing, needs of the industrial sector in the developing countries and streamlining the management of UNIDO.
A German foreign ministry spokeswoman told IPS Friday that the question of withdrawal from UNIDO needed to be considered “in all thoroughness” and that no descision had yet been taken.
The view ascribed to Kinkel is that Germany cannot try to muster international support for its bid to become a permanent member of the U.N. Security Council, while at the same time walking out of a special organisation of the world body. Bonn Foreign Office diplomats, according to observers, are particularly concerned about the repercussions of a decision in favour of withdrawal.
UNIDO continues to be regarded as an important organisation for the developing countries — whose numerical support is essential to Bonn’s U.N. ambitions. The Group of 77 (G-77) developing nations has strongly defended UNIDO as a “friend of the south”.
It angrily dismissed the 1995 conclusions of the Global Governors group of experts — including Swedish premier Ingvar Carlsson and former Commonwealth secretary general Shridath Ramphal — that UNIDO should be closed down as “industrialisation does not play the significant role it once played in development”.
“A direct attack on developing countries” and a “betrayal of the commitment to interdependence between North and South” was the G-77 Vienna chapter’s view at the time. Its views are now more moderately expressed but G-77 support for UNIDO is undimmed.
UNIDO spokeswoman Judy Castelino said in Vienna on Thursday that Germany’s decision to quit the organisation was a “big disappointment,” and Austrian foreign minister Benita Ferrero- Waldner said in a statement that she would encourage Bonn to reconsider its decision.
Spranger says effectiveness of German aid will not be adversely affected if Bonn quits UNIDO. However some see a link between Spranger’s move and a reduction of six percent in his ministry’s budget for 1997, to be scaled down by 500 million marks (some 334 million dollars) to 7,650 million marks (5,100 million dollars).
The economic cooperation ministry hopes to make up for the missing funds by saving 200 million marks (some 134 million dollars) in contributions to the European Development Fund (EDF) and the World Bank’s soft-loan arm, the International Development Association (IDA).
Cuts are also envisaged in Germany’s contributions to the regional development banks and the United Nations Development Programme (UNDP).
Spranger has expressed concern that as money becomes scarce, giving financial and technical assistance to people in distant lands might become less and less acceptable to an average German taxpayer.
A recent official paper prepared by the ministry of economic cooperation said: “The world is undergoing a process of economic, ecological and cultural globalisation, which necessitates the strengthening of international cooperation.”
For that reason, the policy of development cooperation was — along with foreign policy, foreign economic policy and security policy — an integral component of Germany’s external relations and its policy aimed at consolidating peace, said the BMZ document.
Besides, development cooperation policy was becoming more and more important as part of domestic policy also, because it helped secure the future of all the people, added the paper.
“Because development cooperation policy is a part of the general policy, its success depends on the extent to which it is coherent with the foreign policy, foreign economic policy, trade policy, financial policy and environmental and agricultural policy.”
In response, opposition Social Democratic Party world economy spokesman Ingomar Hauchler told IPS that in a world undergoing globalisation, assistance to multilateral organisations should be increased and not curtailed.