Asia-Pacific, Development & Aid, Headlines, Population

INDIA-RIGHTS: Are Children Happier on the Streets?

Meena Menon

MUMBAI, Nov 18 1996 (IPS) - A death of a child in a state-run remand home has trained the spotlight on their appalling condition and the failure of the Indian government to implement laws framed for the protection of delinquent and neglected children.

On Aug. 7, two and a half-year-old Parshuram Vaghari, died in a remand home at Bhiwandi, near Mumbai (previously Bombay). His elder brother said Parshuram was beaten mercilessly by attendants at the home, and died as a result.

The incident would have gone un-noticed, but for a social worker Krist Pereira who filed a writ petition in the Bombay High Court in mid-October, holding the remand home responsible for the boy’s death.

Pereira said Parshuram was hit by cricket bats and sticks, and his death was not recorded at the nearby police station. Neither was there a record of admission or treatment at the two nearby hospitals as required under the Juvenile Justice Act.

Pereira, also stated that the deaths of two other children who had died as a result of beating, were recorded as natural deaths.

Besides, he said that the home was in an appalling condition and the children, an estimated 200, both delinquent and neglected, were not provided proper food, clothing or education.

The staff at the home was not trained in dealing with children and were not sensitive to their problems. After the petition was heard, Pereira and his advocate were allowed to inspect the records but the case files were denied to them.

An inspection of the home revealed that the boys themselves did the work including the cooking and cleaning and they were very scared to talk about the incident.

The court has appointed a judicial officer to enquire into the matter and submit a report by Nov. 29.

Hundreds of thousands of children live on the streets in India’s cities. Those unlucky enough to be rounded up by the police — either as vagrants or involved in petty crimes — often end up in remand homes.

Their fate is decided by Juvenile Welfare Board’s. However, Mumbai’s board has been closed since Nov. 1. Its two members, Vijaylakshmi Pandit and Leela Rele resigned in disgust over the state government’s complete indifference to juvenile justice.

“Since the Board was set up in 1992, we have been demanding more space, more staff and we want to sit for five days instead of the present three. Though we have the powers of a magistrate, we are allotted a small office where … there is no place for the staff … We have no telephone either,” says Pandit.

Neither has been paid by the government, though for three years they have been handling the cases alone. “Sometimes I alone have to deal with 91 cases in a day,” says Rele, who is a well-known social worker in Mumbai.

Ten years after India’s Juvenile Justice Act was passed for the “care, protection, treatment, development and rehabilitation of neglected or delinquent juveniles”, children are victims of official neglect.

Remand homes are generally worse places for their inmates, than the “dangerous” streets from which they were “rescued” by the police.

Located in the centre of the crowded powerloom town of Bhiwandi, the remand home where little Parshuram died, has 175 boys and 77 girls on its rolls. The day IPS and another journalist visited the home after seeking permission, it seemed to have been spruced up for the visitors.

A large tray of food was brought in for inspection and the visitors invited to eat. Their comments were noted down by a clerk, who claimed this was a daily practice. Outside on the veranda, running along the L-shaped rooms, plates of food were laid out on the ground for the children of the remand home.

In one corner, two women were making chapatis or bread. A man who refused to identify himself showed the visitors the new kitchen. With white marble and black stones and airy windows, it was the best room in the otherwise dingy and depressing place.

There was no question of being allowed to speak to the children who were assembled in a large hall, which doubled as their sleeping quarter, and the staff were not even willing to give their names.

Apart from a well-rehearsed ‘namaste’ (traditional greeting), the children were quiet, their tired faces telling their stories.

In the girls section, they had sat down to lunch. One girl though had been made to sit out and eat. Asked why, the visitors were told that she was ill and refusing to eat.

Officials in charge of the home insist the children are well cared for. They have filed an affidavit denying the beating and said Parshuram died due to “respiratory failure due to aspiration pneumonia.”

Social workers say unless the state takes responsibility for juvenile justice, remand homes will continue to be indifferent to the plight of their young inmates, who have no one to fight for their rights.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags