Development & Aid, Economy & Trade, Global, Global Geopolitics, Headlines, Labour, Population

CHILDREN-LABOUR: West Warned Against ‘Simplistic Solutions’

Dipankar De Sarkar

LONDON, Dec 11 1996 (IPS) - The West — which has its own child workers — should think twice before prescribing “simplistic solutions” to end the scourge of child labour in developing countries, senior United Nations officials and academics said Wednesday.

Their comments came at the London launch of the State of World’s Children report for 1997 — an annual review published by the United Nations Children’s Fund (UNICEF) — where officials and researcher scholars highlighted the problem of child labour in Britain.

“Industrialised countries tend to go on soap boxes and preach, so its worthwhile reminding them to look at their own backyard and avoid prescribing simplistic solutions for developing countries,” said Jim McKechnie of the University of Paisley in Britain.

Some experts had expressed concern that highlighting child labour in industrialised countries will only prompt the developed world to dismiss the issue as insoluble, whereas the reality in developing countries was so harsh it needed to be addressed urgently.

But Richard Young of UNICEF India said the problems in industrialised countries need to be articulated precisely in order to goad them into taking constructive action rather than simple punitive measures.

“Yes, child labour in developing countries is qualitatively different — child trafficking, separation from parents and bonded child labour — are crucial human rights issues,” said Young, a member of the Fund’s global Child Rights Team.

“But it is important for industrialised countries not to be complacent and assume they can point the finger at developing countries.”

Young said the task of eliminating child labour needs “a global coalition” and code of conduct based on a common understanding of the problem instead of imposition of punitive measures.

According to McKechnie, who has researched child labour in Britain for the past several years, 70 percent of all children in Britain are in some kind of employment by the age of 16.

Children work not only in newspaper delivery — a traditionally accepted area of child employment — but also in shops, catering and construction sites, and as waiters, garage mechanics, gardeners, cleaners and door-to-door hawkers.

In spite of a British law banning child employment before the age of 13 and stipulating specific times — between seven am and seven pm — for work, McKechnie estimates 90 percent of children who work, do so illegally without any monitoring of work practices.

And far from being beneficial in terms of work experience as exposure to the ‘real world — a common belief in Britain — child labour incurs heavy costs in terms of health, safety, free time and education.

Unlike in developing countries, the reason for the existence of child labour in industrialised countries such as Britain is not poverty alone.

“There are children from the middle class as well — it is deemed of some value to them,” said McKechnie. “The background doesn’t matter. All contribute to the family budget.”

In addition, children in developed countries buy the goods of youth, like clothes, shoes, music and audio equipment. There is evidence that child labour is part and parcel of societies across Europe and in the United States. “Countries of Eastern Europe are now admitting that children are contributing as much as in the U.S. and Britain,” McKechnie saidrt too mentions child labour in industrialised countries, saying the view that child labour only happens in the poor world is a “myth.”

While the vast majority of working children are found in developing countries, children routinely work in all countries, it said, adding it is the nature of the work that determines whether or not they are act of their working.

“Yet hazardous forms of child labour can be found in most rich countries. Usually, the exploited children come from ethnic minorities or immigrant groups,” he said. In the United States, the majority of child workers are employed in agriculture, and a high proportion of them are from immigrant or ethnic-minority families.

A study by the US General Accounting Office showed a 250 percent increase in child labour violations between 1983 and 1990, and in a three-day operation in 1990, the U.S. Department of Labour discovered more than 11,000 children working illegally.

The same year, a survey of Mexican-American children working on New York state farms showed that almost half had worked in fields still wet with pesticides and more than a third had themselves been sprayed either directly or indirectly.

The London-based NGO Anti-Slavery International reported in 1995 that the majority of the estimated one to two million school-age children employed in Britain were employed illegally. It said employers were flouting the law and that local authorities lacked the resources to implement it.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags