Saturday, November 21, 2026
Mahesh Uniyal
- How poor are the poor in India? Until now the answer to this question has depended on the government definition which measures deprivation by fixed levels of income and nutrition.
Using these benchmarks, the national Planning Commission came up with an estimate that not more than one in every five of the 900 million people in India is poor.
Now, however, a UN-sponsored survey of rural India shows that a much greater proportion of people in the villages are several times poorer than the official measure of poverty.
According to the study – sponsored by the India office of the U.N. Development Programme (UNDP) and done by the National Council of Applied Economic Research (NCAER) – more than one-third of people in the half-a-million hamlets of this mainly rural nation, are way below the official poverty line.
The bulk of Indians live in villages and 16 percent of them have less than three rupees (less than 10 cents) a day to buy essential needs. Another 18 percent are slightly better off – with a daily income of two rupees more. This adds up to less than 2,000 rupees annually, while officially poverty is defined as an annual income of less than rupees 11,000 per person.
“We have a very poor state of human development in our country, specially in the central and eastern regions,” said Rakesh Mohan, NCAER Director General who unveiled the report last week at a workshop organised by the UNDP and the government of one of India’s poorest states.
“There are 350 to 450 million people in these six states who have very, very serious problems,” he told the workshop which was held in the city of Bhopal, the capital of central Madhya Pradesh state.
Mohan was referring to the northern, central and eastern states of Bihar, Madhya Pradesh, Rajasthan, Uttar Pradesh, Orissa and West Bengal. Traditionally, only the first four of these, known by the acronym BIMARU (‘ailing’ in Hindi), are considered problem areas for human development.
The NCAER survey has, however, stretched the map of underdevelopment in India to include Orissa and West Bengal. The investigation was conducted over four years and quizzed 33,000 rural households in 1,800 villages in 16 states of India.
The rural poor do not own land and depend on wage work for a living, the survey found. That they are also mostly underfed is obvious from the finding that at best, only one in every five households in the villages of the two poorest states — Uttar Pradesh and Bihar — buy from the subsidised foodgrain shops of the government’s Public Distribution System.
“The PDS (Public Distribution System) coverage is worst in the states which need it most,” said NCAER chief Mohan.
More than half of rural India lives in makeshift shelters and do not have electricity in their homes. In Bihar and West Bengal, not more than 15 in 100 village houses have electric connections.
And only a fourth of all village homes have a water tap. In Bihar, only four percent village households get piped water, while in rural West Bengal the proportion of families with this facility goes up to nearly a tenth. Madhya Pradesh and Uttar Pradesh are slightly better with 11 and 14.7 percent respectively of rural households having piped drinking water.
The NCAER rural human development survey also shows that India has overestimated its gains in primary schooling. It reveals that the official primary school admission figures according to which every child of school going age is enrolled, are inflated. The primary enrolment figure actually turns out to be 70 percent.
Another disquieting finding, NCAER’s Mohan said, is that, though government schooling is supposed to be free, there is “a fair amount of private (household) expenditure on education.”
The average rural family in India spends 368 rupees (10.5 dollars) annually on each of its schoolgoing children. However, in Uttar Pradesh and Rajasthan, the typical village family spends more than this on educating its children.
Some 122 out of every 1,000 people of all age groups in Indian villages suffer from short duration illnesses, while nearly 46 per 1,000 villagers of all ages, report major ailments. Generally, women are more prone to sickness than men.
The NCAER survey is likely to be followed by more detailed information on living standards in India as the states are planing their own human development reports. A year ago, Madhya Pradesh became the first in the country and the first sub- national unit in the world to prepare such a report which is inspired by the UNDP annual Human Development Reports.
Development experts who gathered in the Madhya Pradesh capital last week for the release of the NCAER survey said the poor must be involved in gathering information about their lifestyles to ensure that the data is not fudged to please governments.
They advised other states to follow the example of Madhya Pradesh. The state is using its half a million elected village councillors to “create an authentic data base on human development indicators,” state Chief Minister Digvijay Singh told the meet.
State panchayat (Village Council) members carried out a door- to-door survey of school enrolment and of adult illiteracy. The panchayats will use this information in making plans on what they are going to do to raise educational standards in their respective areas, Singh said.