Saturday, November 21, 2026
Mario Gonzalez
- The organized indigenous peoples movement in Ecuador finds itself in one of the most difficult moments in its history: facing the paradox of having access to power while being part of the political opposition.
The Confederation of Indigenous Nationalities of Ecuador (CONIAE), the most important indigenous organization in the country, is also riven by differences between representatives of the Amazonian region and the highlands.
This was evident Sunday when CONIAE chose its leaders. Antonio Vargas, a leader from the Amazonian region, was elected as the new president of the organization, over the opposition of indigenous groups from the highlands who charged that the electoral process was marred by irregularities.
Former president Jose Maria Cabascango, had been seeking re- election with the support of Quechua Indians from the highlands.
The CONIAE, which celebrated its 10th anniversary in November, represents 10 indigenous communities in Ecuador, of which seven are from the Amazonian region: Quechua, Shuar, Ashuar, Shion, Secoya, Cofane and Huaorani.
In the past five years the organization has been controlled by leaders from the highland region.
The split within CONIAE began during elections last May. The indigenous movement launched an independent electoral front for the first time in Ecuador’s history and obtained eights seats in Congress and 71 sectoral and local positions. That transformed them into the fourth electoral force in the country.
The movement was headed by Luis Macas, one of the top indigenous leaders from the highlands, now a leading opponent of the government of president Abdala Bucaram.
On the other side of the political spectrum are those Indian leaders who declared their support for Bucaram when he faced the right-wing Social Christian Party in the second electoral round.
Rafael Pandem and Valerio Grefa, two Amazonian leaders with long political careers, were recently appointed by Bucaram to become Minister and Vice-Minister of the new Ethnic and Cultural Ministry.
Local analysts point out that Bucaram applied the old strategy of “divide and conquer” when he saw that the indigenous movement was gaining important positions in the country’s political scene.
“There have always been divisions between these two indigenous groups, who have different ways of understanding politics and doing politics,” said anthropologist Natalia Wray, who conducted a study on the Indians’ electoral behavior during the general elections last May.
“The communities of the Amazonian region have a more practical approach, because they have undergone other types of political processes, like the negotiations with oil and lumber companies,” explained Wray.
Indian groups from the highlands, on the other hand, “have a more forward-looking vision, in which the struggle for larger issues predominates, like the recognition of indigenous rights and equality, due to their close relationship with the structure of the (large farms) left behind by the colonial period”.
According to Rodrigo de la Cruz, a technical assistant for the Coordinating Committee for Indigenous Organization of the Amazon Basin (COICA), “it is a mistake to think of indigenous peoples as a homogeneous mass that struggles for one set of interests in particular”.
“Indigenous peoples, like any other human society, have profound differences that emerge from different interests and different historical processes, although we agree on the basics, which is the recognition of our rights”, said the expert.
For that, according to Cruz, there are basically two paths: “to exercise political power from the opposition, as has been our tradition, or within the governing group, which can be seen as a defeat or as a serious move ahead for our movement”, he concluded.