Environment, Headlines, North America

ENVIRONMENT: Mining Firms Win Battle, But Lose Powerful Weapon

Mike Dennison

HELENA, Mont., Dec 6 1996 (IPS) - Multinational mining corporations won their electoral fight against stricter pollution standards, but they may have to go into future battles without their most effective weapon — money.

Montana voters last month rejected an effort to impose some of the nation’s toughest wastewater standards, a campaign in which supporters were outspent 6-1 by opponents, whose coffers were filled by free-spending mining firms.

At the same time, however, voters approved an initiative that will limit the ability of corporations to buy future victories by prohibiting them from making direct expenditures on ballot measures. It is a defeat corporate executives have vowed to fight.

Initiative 122 (I-122) would have created tougher wastewater- treatment standards for gold and other precious-metal mines. But, in a classic battle of big money versus grassroots politics, the mining industry prevailed, spending more than 2.3 million dollars to defeat the measure in the Nov. 5 election.

“I think with that kind of money battling a citizens’ initiative, we could have run the (U.S.) Bill of Rights and got beat,” said Gary Buchanan, a Montana stockbroker who co-chaired the I-122 campaign, a loose coalition of environmental groups, ranchers and business people that spent about 400,000 dollars.

Golden Sunlight Mining Inc., which is owned by Canadian mining giant Placer Dome Inc., spent nearly 400,000 dollars to defeat I- 122, while its parent firm spent another 150,000 dollars. Asarco dumped in 350,000 dollar, as did Pegasus Gold Corp. and its subsidiaries, which operate several gold mines in Montana and the western United States, and petroleum and mining giant Atlantic Richfield Corp. spent 50,000 dollar.

But the largest single contributor, providing at least 525,000 dollars, was mining conglomerate Phelps-Dodge Corp. and its partners in an open-pit gold mine proposed to be built near the Blackfoot River.

All this money was funneled through a central campaign group called Montanans for Common Sense Water Laws, which came under fire because its name didn’t reflect the true source of its financing: the mining industry.

The state’s chief campaign-enforcement officer sued the pro- mining group in October for

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags