Development & Aid, Headlines, Human Rights, Latin America & the Caribbean, Population

INDIA-CHILDREN: Juvenile Lawbreakers Languish in Remand Homes

MUMBAI, Dec 15 1996 (IPS) - Young lawbreakers in India who are sent to state-aided remand homes face a life of terrorlocked away in overcrowded prison-like institutions that have earned infamy for sexual and physical abuse.

The brutality and lack of basic facilities repeatedly have led inmates to make desperate bids for freedom. In June last year, 100 children escaped from a remand home in the state of Uttar Pradesh because they were regularly starved and beaten by the staff. Thirty two were caught by the police and sent to a home in the state capital Lucknow.

Seeking to gloss over the incident, district officials alleged the funds sanctioned for the home had been “misappropriated” by the staff. But lawyers and child rights activists say the whole system of institutionalised care for neglected and delinquent children in India needs to be overhauled.

Instead of rehabilitating, the remand homes are permanently damaging the children.

In Mumbai (formerly Bombay), an activist Krist Pereira filed a public interest petition in the state high court in October to make the authorities more accountable after the death of a 7- year-old in a remand home. He said tha “every home must be visited and evaluated … Just because they are destitute, does not mean they can be beaten. Someone has to be answerable for them.”

Under India’s Juvenile Justice (JJ) Act of 1986, minors should not be institutionalised, and the remand homes are only an interim arrangement until juvenile courts decide whether they should be reunited with their parents or found alternate care.

Yet, inmates languish for years in remand homes, until they turn 18 in the case of boys and 16 for girls, when they are let out and expected to deal with the world outside even though they have neither been prepared nor taught skills.

The David Sassoon Industrial School here in the capital of the western state of Maharashtra is a remand home for boys. Some 500 homeless children, those neglected by their parents and young deviants are all locked up together here.

On paper they receive basic education and are taught a variety of vocational skills like carpentry and welding, which are supposed to help them pick up jobs when they leave the school.

But indifferent staff, lack of facilities and special attention, defeat the aims of the institution. According to an ex-inmate, he did not learn anything at the school though he has a certificate to say that he has studied up to class five. “Nobody paid any attention to us after we registered … Often our superintendent used to come drunk,” he said in an interview.

Now a young man, he lives along with 35 other former inmates of the David Sassoon School at an after care hostel in a north- eastern suburb of Mumbai. “I feel if I had studied something when I was inside, the situation would not be so desperate,” he revealed after being assured that he would not be identified.

Boys who have passed out of David Sassoon, he says, know how to weld, make iron frying pans or stoves, but that would not get them jobs.

S.D. Shinde who is the counsellor, administrator and superintendent of the after care hostel claims he is helpless. “Most of the boys are not very educated or intelligent … most want office jobs … a few have started their own businesses.” Child rights activist Pereira, who has visited some of Mumbai’s remand homes, thinks the fault lies in their very structure.

At present “homes are understaffed and any attempt to innovate meets with bureaucratic red tape … Sometimes you have two child welfare officers handling 100 children. Untrained people cater to the children and they lack all sensitivity to the issues … there is no motivation to teach or to learn.”

Moreover if neglected minors and young lawbreakers were kept separately, the remand homes would be easier to manage, he thinks. At the David Sassoon School, for instance, an older boy ruptured the spleen of a much younger inmate recently. This was his second assault: earlier he had blinded a boy in one eye.

Malathi Pillai, programme officer (children in specially difficult circumstances) with UNICEF, said the JJ Act did not facilitate an analysis of cases before they go to the remand home and there is no way of finding out what the child’s need are.

“There should be a roster of referral residential homes to which children can be sent,” she said. “However the JJ act, though a good act does not talk of non-institutional services. There are foster care schemes, sponsorship and adoption schemes, which people are not even aware of.”

In Maharashtra, UNICEF and the state government are pioneering the ‘Bal Sangopan Yojana’ which prevents children from being institutionalised. “If the probation officer feels the child is better off with foster care rather than in a home, then we have a list of people identified and the child can grow in a family,” Pillai explained.

UNICEF and the state’s Department for Women and Child Welfare have taken the initiative to amend the rules of the JJ Act which will be presented at the forthcoming winter session of the state assembly in Nagpur.

Two years ago, MS University, Baroda, did an evaluation of the services and rehabilitation programmes under the JJ Act in the states of Gujarat and Maharashtra. The conclusions were damning for the authorities, particularly in Maharashtra.

But none of its recommendations have been implemented. Says social workers Farida Lambay: “The concept of rehabilitation has to change and physical facilities for the child have to improve.”

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags